Instructables

Is it possible to set up a RAID 0 and RAID 1 using the same 2 drives?

If I have two 1TB drives, can I partition each one into two 500GB drives, (Labelled A1, A2, B1,B2)  then set up a RAID 0 array between A1 and B1, while having A2 be a RAID 1 backup of B1, and B2 a RAID 1 backup of A1?

Or would this Simply give me the equivalent speed of a TB Raid 1?

(From what I understand, this would be similar to RAID 5, but wouldn't require a separate RAID card.)

lemonie2 years ago

I just thought that you've invented a new concept:
"Redundant Array of Independent Partitions" RAIP.

L
Bartboy (author)  lemonie2 years ago
From what I understand, the only way to do what I want would be to buy three drives...
lemonie Bartboy2 years ago
Do you need to do this, or can one RAID configuration work for you?

L
Bartboy (author)  lemonie2 years ago
Well it's probably more of an experiment than anything else.

But if I could have two partitions from separate drives striped so as to increase speed, then have the other two partitions back them up (crossed over so as to prepare for drive failure) I'd get the same speed as just using RAID 1.

But if I could somehow make the backups so that they only backed up when there was minimal use of the other two partitions, it would be cool.

Seems like there's no software to do this.
lemonie Bartboy2 years ago

RAID  works on actual drives, I really don't think there's a fundamental advantage to the partition idea.
If there was, you would have heard of software that RAIDs a single-drive...

L
Bartboy (author)  lemonie2 years ago
Well, there is...

You see, the backups would be done when there was minimal read/write.
Wouldn't "actually" be RAID.... But something similar?
So you'd get the security of RAID 1, and a small speed boost.
lemonie Bartboy2 years ago

Hmm, is the predicted speed-boost going to be significant?

L
Bartboy (author)  lemonie2 years ago
And RAID is fun!
lemonie Bartboy2 years ago

Oh damn, I could have done a super RAID installation with my old Gigabyte-board.... but I accidentally screwdrived a SM-transistor off it.

L
Bartboy (author)  lemonie2 years ago
I happen to have three identical USB2 printers. Kinda slow, over 10 seconds a page.
Is it possible to set something similar to a RAID0 for printers?...
So that if I have a 15 page document, ever third page is printed by each printer?


Would also be cool/useful.
lemonie Bartboy2 years ago

You'd have to split the print-job, but the thing to do would be to have 2 printers each do every other page, like odd/even.
MS Word will surely let you do that.

L
Bartboy (author)  lemonie2 years ago
Not really....
I think the point is that it would give you speed + data protection, without having to buy a RAID card.
Vyger2 years ago
At this time as far as I know the answer is no. The reason is that the raid controller doesn't even care about the partitions. The controller treats the drive as a whole and works independently of any data on it. This is why it works for any type of partition. So, like lemonie said, no.

Just a note, if I were you I would use them in a mirrored array. If one of the drives fails, and there appears to be a high likely hood of that. then you will not loose all your data. If you put them in a stripped array and one goes bad, you loose everything on both drives. Read speeds are increased in a mirrored array but write speeds are not. However new drives are already so fast, and they cash everything for delayed writing, that you will not notice a difference for almost all applications.
Bartboy (author)  Vyger2 years ago
Well, my idea would probably have to involve not a true RAID, but some other strip of data and backups on the partitions. I'd want the backups to only be done while the drive isn't doing anything... So a delayed mirror. Difficult.
lemonie2 years ago

The RAID controller is on the board, it manages by IDE channel. So I would say no.

L
Pro

Get More Out of Instructables

Already have an Account?

close

PDF Downloads
As a Pro member, you will gain access to download any Instructable in the PDF format. You also have the ability to customize your PDF download.

Upgrade to Pro today!