What would cause a fresh, tree-ripened lemon to lose it's flavor?

A friend recently gifted me with a dozen beautiful lemons, picked right from his trees.  I juiced a couple and got nearly 1/2 cup from each lemon but the juice tastes almost nothing like lemons.  The flavor is remotely citrus but not at all what a lemon is supposed to taste like.

What would cause this? Does anyone know?

Picture of What would cause a fresh, tree-ripened lemon to lose it's flavor?
sort by: active | newest | oldest
bajablue (author) 4 years ago
Thank you for taking the time to explain this!
It also could be to ripe most citrus fruit is picked green and ripens in transit. I found this out working as a truck driver and picking up fruit in Florida and driving it back to Canada.
bajablue (author)  Josehf Murchison4 years ago
The transit of the lemons was only about 2 hours, but thanks for sharing that info, Josehf.
Its not the transit it's the tree or vine ripened it changes the flavor from what we are accustomed too. I eat a lot of wild food and vine ripened is different.
bajablue (author)  Josehf Murchison4 years ago
These lemons were definitely vine-ripened and freshly picked.
Burf4 years ago
Using a nitrate based fertilizer on a lemon tree after it has begun flowering will often produce tasteless, thick skinned fruit.
bajablue (author)  Burf4 years ago
Thanks for that info, Burf!
Vyger4 years ago
Wow, life gave you lemons and you managed to mess them up. Are you a politician by any chance? Well, to be fair, they did come to you already broke.
bajablue (author)  Vyger4 years ago
LOL, Vyger!!!
mole14 years ago
It could be the variety of lemon. Has the tree ever had good flavored fruit? I believe that like apples, most commercial trees are not grown from seed, they are grafted onto 'root stock' . Root stock may or may not produce flavorful fruit. If a branch grows from below the graft, the fruit can be very different than that from above the graft. Or if it was grown from seed, the fruit may not taste very good.

If the tree normally has great tasting fruit, could it have been frozen? Freezing tends to destroy the flavor of citrus.
bajablue (author)  mole14 years ago
Interesting, mole1. The grove is in central Baja California and I've never tasted lemons from it before. I'll need to ask my friend about that.

No chance of the fruit freezing.

I wonder if the cause might be a nutrition deficiency?