how to make magnet motor free enrgy w/o neodymium?

i dont have access to buy neodymium or much parts like roms and hard drive to slavage dozen of it. all i have are craft magnets.. ceramic type i think...

sort by: active | newest | oldest
Jack A Lopez says: Mar 13, 2011. 12:56 PM
It is not obvious to me how one goes about making a "magnet motor free enrgy" with Nd-based magnets.  So I don't think you're at real disadvantage there with just having the weaker ceramic kind.

However, some persons (or robots) answering this question will likely tell you your "magnet motor", whatever it is, they'll tell you that such a thing is totally impossible based on thermodynamic arguments.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laws_of_thermodynamics

Anyway, I'm not sure what exactly what kind of "free energy" or "magnet motor" you want to build, but I think there's a good list of them, here:
http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directory:Magnet_Motors
Jack A Lopez in reply to Jack A LopezMar 13, 2011. 1:04 PM
The Bedini SG motor should be in that list, but I think for some reason it is not. It's also at PesWiki, here:
http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directory:Bedini_SG
AndyGadget in reply to Jack A LopezMar 13, 2011. 1:17 PM
WOW! The David Hamel Motor sound good :-

Supposedly, the "3 cone device" or "3CD" gives forth the principle of perpetual motion via 3-body interaction physics to the zero point energy field via the usage of duality/magnetism and of vibration. Chaos physics induced through 3-body interactions. Chaos induced to provide runaway conditions of acceleration in the apparatus. A method of 'straining the aether' through torsion field interactions through magnetism and extreme vibration.

And it's believed to be Atlantean in origin. 

With all those scientificy words, how can it not work !!!


Jack A Lopez in reply to AndyGadgetMar 13, 2011. 1:56 PM
Well it should be scientific-y, considering that David Hamel got his ideas from aliens from another dimension who talked to him through his TV, as explained in the biographical section of the same article, here:
http://www.peswiki.com/index.php/Directory:David_Hamel_Motor#David_Hamel:_The_Man_Behind_The_Physics
No-Shi-De (author) in reply to Jack A LopezMar 14, 2011. 7:25 AM
uhm, are u aware of those rotor with magnets, and by means of repulsion from the stator, it rotates. sumthing like that....
No-Shi-De (author) in reply to Jack A LopezMar 14, 2011. 7:31 AM
iim not sure, the sounds a little bads on the second link, but i think he uses strong magnets, or neodymium.

wat im trying to make is sumthing like that if possible w/o using neodymium?
kelseymh in reply to No-Shi-DeMar 14, 2011. 7:46 AM
No, it won't just rotate. The forces balance.
Jack A Lopez in reply to No-Shi-DeMar 14, 2011. 10:26 AM
Have you seen this one?
http://www.rexresearch.com/minto/minto.htm

It is essentially a rotary version of "Dippy Drinking Bird"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drinking_bird

And I suspect something like that might actually work, but for that you need easily liquefyable gasses, like freon or propane, not magnets.

As far as magnets go, I have never seen any arrangement of permanent magnets capable of sort of "pushing itself" for more than a fraction of one rotation.

Moreover I would not expect such a thing to be possible, any more than I would expect  a self-driving wheel could be made from springs and counter-weights.   Arrangements of  magnets can be made to
store small amounts of energy, just like springs, and flywheels, and weights can.  Then the thing that you build requires "winding up" to store energy in those various storage elements, and then after a while it  "winds down" because there was only so much energy stored in it.

Ah, but you say that magnets have some sort of mysterious ability to interact with fabric of space itself, and somehow extract energy from it, from space, from the vacuum. 

Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight...   ;-)

The only other internet resource I can think of for magical magnet motor plans, besides PesWiki, is that place RexResearch, linked above for the Minto heat engine, and here:
http://www.rexresearch.com/index.htm

Just go there, and do a Ctri-F to search for "magnet motor" within the body of the page. I'm pretty sure there's more than one.

minto-wonder-wheel.jpg
No-Shi-De (author) in reply to Jack A LopezMar 15, 2011. 1:05 AM
im not sure about this, but i think i saw this in myth buster, a cover is missing in the diagram i think, to provide th lower temp, other wise, kelseymh is right, it just might find a state of equilibrium. but, w8.. i'll re post, i'll try to find what im saying..
No-Shi-De (author) in reply to Jack A LopezMar 15, 2011. 1:08 AM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jYcjjSfiNNE

like this one..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5lXNpOnurw&feature=fvsr

or this...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uHffliC2whk

however, they're usiing neodymium....
Jack A Lopez in reply to No-Shi-DeMar 15, 2011. 7:52 AM
Hey thanks for actually posting a link or two reference that which you are asking about.  That is very helpful!

Note that when a YouTube video mentions a name, you can try searching for that name via Google, or narrow the search specifically to  PesWiki's pages.

E.g. the first video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jYcjjSfiNNE
you posted says "Perendev" in the title. See:
http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directory:Perendev_Power_Developments_Pty_%28Ltd%29

Says Mike Brady, head of company named Perendev, was arrested for fraud in Germany last year, and the company closed its doors. I guess that means the oil companies got to 'em. Bummer. They should have made it open source.  ;-)

The third video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uHffliC2whk
says "Calloway", and the search returns:
http://peswiki.com/index.php/OS:Calloway_Magnet_Motor

In the third video kind of looks it kind of looks like the narrator is "pumping" this motor, by moving the "stator" magnet in his hand back and forth, and that the motor won't run without him doing that.

BTW, have you seen these?

Curie point heat engines
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RWrTvB-oK94
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LexcwNDW-2s

Rubber Band Heat Engine
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBXL93984cQ

AndyGadget in reply to No-Shi-DeMar 15, 2011. 10:24 AM
A shame that first video doesn't have audio.
You're missing the hiss of the compressed air jet driving it.
adeksayo in reply to AndyGadgetMar 24, 2011. 10:53 AM
for real?
adeksayo in reply to Jack A LopezMar 24, 2011. 10:57 AM
aww..
wow.... tnx jack... woudnt hav known that... so i guess no one has really ade it possible yet???

p.s. tnx for the info.
No-Shi-De (author) in reply to adeksayoMar 24, 2011. 10:59 AM
for real?

sorry, i was loged in in my friends name..
No-Shi-De (author) in reply to adeksayoMar 24, 2011. 10:59 AM
aww..
wow.... tnx jack... woudnt hav known that... so i guess no one has really ade it possible yet???

p.s. tnx for the info.


sorry, i was logged in in my friends name...
No-Shi-De (author) in reply to Jack A LopezMar 24, 2011. 11:00 AM
tnx for the links, guess heat can help, but guess it won't be a hundred percent dipendent on mags...
No-Shi-De (author) in reply to Jack A LopezMar 24, 2011. 11:01 AM
i guess i'll close this qestion. tnx for the heaads up.
AndyGadget in reply to No-Shi-DeMar 25, 2011. 7:54 AM
 
That's my guess, although if you read the video's comments, other people have different ideas about how it was set up.
What would happen if that wasn't driven in some way is that the magnets would find an equilibrium state and the motion would stop.

Magnets behave in very strange ways; gyroscopes are another thing like that - their movements are sometimes weird or counter-intuitive -  but they do conform to the established laws of physics.  They don't pull energy from nowhere and they don't run for ever (although with very low friction in an efficient system, they can run for a very long time.)



7Kelson says: Aug 19, 2012. 8:06 PM
What about giving the hojo motor a try?
rickharris says: Mar 14, 2011. 1:34 AM
Free energy? Doesn't exist no matter what type of magnets you have.
No-Shi-De (author) in reply to rickharrisMar 14, 2011. 7:23 AM
uhm.. yes.. what i ment, is, isaw those who made magnets and by means of repulsion, the rotor inside rotates, although i understand that its not 100% free, i just want to try to mimic it, but most i saw uses neodymium magnets.
rickharris in reply to No-Shi-DeMar 16, 2011. 7:02 AM
You can make an electric motor with any kind of magnet.
adeksayo in reply to rickharrisMar 24, 2011. 10:52 AM
i didnt ment electric motor, "magna motor"
No-Shi-De (author) in reply to adeksayoMar 24, 2011. 10:58 AM
i didnt ment electric motor, "magna motor"

sorry, i was loged in in my friends name..
Pro

Get More Out of Instructables

Already have an Account?

close

PDF Downloads
As a Pro member, you will gain access to download any Instructable in the PDF format. You also have the ability to customize your PDF download.

Upgrade to Pro today!