COMMUNITY : FORUMS : COMMUNITY BLOG


Anarchy and teens

What the deuce is with these teenagers and anarchy? Is pure evil and chaos what they want, and are attracted to? What the deuce do they want? I know most will stop being anarchists (not truly) eventually, but is it a trend, a cult, a what? Comments will be most appreciated my fellow insructa-users

anarchy.gif
sort by: active | newest | oldest
frenzy says: Sep 18, 2010. 8:58 AM
When i was younger and first hearing about anarchy it was from the punk scene. I'm an inquisitive person though so i did research before taking on a new philosophy.

Now that i'm older i have a much more developed understanding of anarchist theory, and it's the only thing that makes any sense to me.

If you're interested in anarchist theory, take a look at this : http://www.black-rose.com/articles-liz/intro-@.html

also chaos =! anarchy, a pure definition of anarchism is "a political philosophy which considers the state undesirable, unnecessary and harmful, and instead promotes a stateless society"

Some might believe that a stateless society would breed chaos, and in there lies a good debate.
skunkbait says: Jun 21, 2008. 11:33 PM
I'll have to say that most kids who wear the "anarchy symbol" don't even understand what it means. Anarchy can be political, or situational. Anarchism has been attached to alot of things over the years, from the Haymarket Riot, to Sacco and Vanzetti, all the way to Sid Vicious and the Sex Pistols. It was also frequently seen as a means to further communism/marxism, by destruction of "the establishment". In a perfect (read impossible) world, lack of government control (political anarchy) would not be such a problem. Realistically though, there are entirely too many people (and groups of people) willing to abuse the absence of law and governmental control. Do I hate outside governmental interference? Absolutely! How would this world be without any restraint upon the selfish, uncooperative and ignorant masses? Not so good. Most current "anarchism" is a fad, latched onto by kids who don't understand it. All they know is that it gets attention and infuriates the powers that be. True political anarchism is just not practical be cause of humanities inadequacy to behave itself. If you've ever lived in a "might-makes-right" society, you will understand.
chicks dig me in reply to skunkbaitSep 13, 2010. 1:19 PM
you know? your absolutely right. most teens who latch on to the "fad" of anarchism dont completely understand it. i, on the other hand, do. and it enfuriates me that people wear the anarchist order symbol without truely believing/understanding what anarchism is really all about. and really, i know there are some people who wear it AND believe it (such as myself) and my appologies to whoever that may be, but there are people who just say they're anarchists and wear it because they think its "cool" or that it will make them "cool". once again my appologies to whoever this offends.
skunkbait in reply to chicks dig meSep 15, 2010. 8:09 PM
I don't wear it anymore. I did for years, but after seeing a few to many "posers" wearing them, I bailed.
chicks dig me in reply to skunkbaitSep 17, 2010. 12:52 PM
yeah.
drinkmorecoffee in reply to skunkbaitOct 14, 2008. 10:28 AM
This comment is a little late, I suppose, but have you read The Man Who Was Thursday?
skunkbait in reply to drinkmorecoffeeOct 14, 2008. 11:53 AM
No, but I think my sister mentioned it.
drinkmorecoffee in reply to skunkbaitOct 14, 2008. 12:18 PM
Yeah, it's worth reading. Some good ideas relating to the topic of anarchy.
skunkbait in reply to drinkmorecoffeeOct 14, 2008. 1:29 PM
I'll try to give it a read. I'll see if I can find it online. I have like 2000 books, but I rarely read paper anymore.
drinkmorecoffee in reply to skunkbaitOct 14, 2008. 1:39 PM
Chesterton is always worth reading.
http://www.gutenberg.org/etext/1695
:)
ChrysN in reply to drinkmorecoffeeOct 14, 2008. 10:07 PM
How about some Emma Goldman.
theburn7 (author) in reply to skunkbaitJul 8, 2008. 12:46 PM
All of that is what i thought, i needed a confirmation, thank you skunkbait
CameronSS in reply to skunkbaitJun 22, 2008. 11:34 AM
Exactly. It seems that people know that it's a symbol of rebellion, and they want to rebel, but they don't really know what they're rebelling against. Similarly, I know a guy at my school who scratches pentagrams into everything. Particularly, in the theater, he will take a utility knife and engrave them into wood and paint, or use a Sharpie. Clearly, he does not know what they really mean, since depending on his audience, he identifies himself as either atheist, Satanist, or pagan. He knows that it will get a reaction, and that's all he really wants.
lordjohnnym says: Aug 12, 2008. 8:23 AM
(removed by author or community request)
lordjohnnym in reply to lordjohnnymAug 12, 2008. 8:24 AM
i am also an irish reoublican (strong irish nationalist), so i rebel against the british goverment and dont abide by much of their stupid laws.
killerjackalope in reply to lordjohnnymAug 12, 2008. 10:47 AM
So you're in northern Ireland then... Maybe everything will reach a time when the states can co-exist, there will always be two countries by now but it's funny the way it all falls together, ulster is technically british but governs itself to an extent...
jessyratfink says: Jun 23, 2008. 8:50 AM
I've never understood the anarchy bit. My first boyfriend and I were completely into punk culture, and he got swept off his feet by the idea of anarchy really quickly. A lot of the kids did, honestly. I just could never believe that it would work to anyone's benefit. I think anarchy is just something that sounds good for people that hate being told what to do and have no idea how governments actually run. :P
uguy in reply to jessyratfinkAug 12, 2008. 10:32 AM
Jessy, It's hard to believe you were ever "completely into punk culture". I for one am certainly glad you "saw the light". But it would be interesting to see a punk stuffed robot doll. LOL
Keith-Kid says: Jun 22, 2008. 7:14 PM
Krusty Krab Unfair!
Mr. Krabs is in there!
Standing at the concession!
Plotting his oppression!

{ Music Starts Up }

I will restore the working man to his rightful glory!

I will dismantle this oppresive establishment board by board!

I will saw the tables of tyranny in half!

Gnaw at the ankles of big business!

Squidward will be so proud!

Gjdj3 in reply to Keith-KidJul 10, 2008. 3:26 PM
Lol. Spongebob.
media-v8153688pbYSb6Rn1209887214Med.jpg
bumpus says: Jun 22, 2008. 2:18 PM
hahah, i just bought it at a yard sale a week ago, its a good read
CIMG2164.JPG
jessyratfink in reply to bumpusJun 23, 2008. 8:47 AM
Whenever we get that into work it always sells instantly. I've actually never gotten to look at it. I'm always just like, "OMG ANARCHIST COOKBOOK! SOMEONE WILL BUY THIS FOR 20 BUCKS!! YAY!!"
whatsisface in reply to jessyratfinkJun 23, 2008. 12:35 PM
It's not worth reading, it's outdated and dangerous trash that has very little to do with the point of anarchy.
bumpus in reply to whatsisfaceJun 23, 2008. 1:42 PM
i think its just something different to read
bumpus in reply to jessyratfinkJun 23, 2008. 9:56 AM
I would suggesting reading it, its a pretty good book, *interesting view points of pre-veitnam war*

HOORAY READING :D

guyfrom7up in reply to bumpusJun 22, 2008. 3:18 PM
isn't that book illegal or something?
teaaddict314 in reply to guyfrom7upJun 23, 2008. 1:01 AM
actually i think it is illegal
bumpus in reply to teaaddict314Jun 23, 2008. 7:41 AM
nope, the book itself isn't illegal, you can get it at various bookstores
bumpus in reply to guyfrom7upJun 22, 2008. 3:28 PM
no, almost everything in it is illegal
KentsOkay in reply to bumpusJun 22, 2008. 3:14 PM

AHHAAA!!! SCAN EVERY SINGLE PAGE AND UPLOAD AS SLIDE SHOW!!!

octollama in reply to KentsOkayMar 3, 2012. 11:43 AM
You can Download a pdf of it almost anywhere on the internet...
bumpus in reply to KentsOkayJun 22, 2008. 3:22 PM
maybe...
Plasmana in reply to bumpusOct 14, 2008. 2:18 PM
Please...
bumpus in reply to PlasmanaOct 14, 2008. 2:24 PM
Perhaps...
KentsOkay in reply to bumpusJun 23, 2008. 7:44 AM
Please with a cherry on top!
Sunbanks in reply to bumpusJun 22, 2008. 6:41 PM
Do it!!
keastes in reply to SunbanksAug 13, 2008. 6:01 PM
here 'nuff said
PKM in reply to KentsOkayJun 22, 2008. 3:15 PM
You know you can read it, in all its outdated, error-filled glory online, don't you?
KentsOkay in reply to PKMJun 23, 2008. 8:28 AM
.... WHERE!?!?!??!
bumpus in reply to PKMJun 22, 2008. 3:30 PM
Its not the same one, the online version was written by "The Jolly Rodger" the book, as pictured, was written by William Powell
skunkbait in reply to bumpusJun 22, 2008. 8:16 PM
I think (if I remember right)Powell renounced the original work and sued the publisher. Subsequent copies have his name removed. That being said, my kids and I like the ACB, but it should be approached with EXTREME caution.
bumpus in reply to skunkbaitJun 23, 2008. 9:58 AM
not necessarily, just don't do the illegal stuff in there... as i was telling jessyratfink, it has some interesting views on before and during the Vietnam war, which was when it was written and published.
skunkbait in reply to bumpusJun 24, 2008. 3:19 AM
I agree. I appreciate the political/historical discussion in the prologue. When I say Extreme caution, I'm talking about the explosives, incendiaries, and such. The instructions are decent, but if you're not trained in those things, you might not know all of the fine points of blowing stuff up and burning stuff down. Trust me, sometimes even great ideas leave you with no eyebrows and partial deafness!
bumpus in reply to skunkbaitJun 24, 2008. 8:49 AM
hmm, maybe that's why I'm 16 and still don't have hair on my one leg...
skunkbait in reply to bumpusJun 24, 2008. 9:31 AM
LOL!
PKM in reply to bumpusJun 22, 2008. 5:02 PM
Ahh.. I never knew that, I have been maligning this book incorrectly. Is the print version any better?
bumpus in reply to PKMJun 22, 2008. 6:19 PM
a lot more text, i would recommend reading the book, its rather interesting
octollama in reply to bumpusMar 3, 2012. 11:45 AM
You can Download a pdf of it almost anywhere on the internet...
Labot2001 in reply to bumpusJun 22, 2008. 2:40 PM
?? What is it?
bumpus in reply to Labot2001Jun 22, 2008. 3:25 PM
a book
Labot2001 in reply to bumpusJun 22, 2008. 4:22 PM
About??
bumpus in reply to Labot2001Jun 22, 2008. 4:36 PM
a cookbook for destruction of the economy and government
=SMART= in reply to bumpusJun 22, 2008. 5:29 PM
wait a cookbook for food ?
bumpus in reply to =SMART=Jun 22, 2008. 6:20 PM
no, defiantly not
Patrik in reply to bumpusJun 23, 2008. 11:05 PM
Huh - that's one of the few times I've seen that typo used correctly! ;-)
bumpus in reply to PatrikJun 24, 2008. 8:48 AM
yeah, I er....planned to do that, yeah thats it

:D

Labot2001 in reply to bumpusJun 22, 2008. 4:41 PM
Cool.
theburn7 (author) in reply to Labot2001Jun 23, 2008. 12:23 PM
how is that cool, and why? that is the question
Labot2001 in reply to theburn7Jun 23, 2008. 1:13 PM
It's cool that the call it an Anarchy "Cookbook"; it contains "recipes" for destruction of government. It's cool how they themed it.
xACIDITYx in reply to bumpusJun 22, 2008. 2:31 PM
SWEET!
PKM says: Jun 22, 2008. 9:06 AM
I saw a youngish teenager on a train, covered in anarchist symbols and german flags and studded leather and all that, complain to the conductor that a homeless guy with a dog had sworn at him. Not threatened him, not come near him, not caused him any sort of actual disturbance- just sworn at him.

Raaa anarchy crush the system f*** the government we want independence while it suits us and we don't have to leave our affluent middle-class comfort zone.

That's pretty much my impression of teenage "anarchists". Some teenagers are anarchic, in that they have no respect for law and order and feel that they can do whatyever they want, but that's not the same as anarchy. Sadly they don't seem to understand that their repeated petty (or not-so-petty) thefts and other crimes wouldn't get them a fine or community service in an anarchist society, they would instead probably get lynched and killed. Oh well- most of them seem to grow out of it.

Perhaps we could learn a lesson from the Amish? Give your kids proper discipline until they are just about old enough to learn for themselves about responsibility and the consequences of their actions, then take them completely off the leash and let them do absolutely whatever they want for a while.

Sorry- end of rant.
theburn7 (author) in reply to PKMJun 23, 2008. 12:32 PM
neat story
killerjackalope says: Jun 23, 2008. 8:10 AM
Well it's basically a fascination with independence and rebellion, anarchy is often associated with such things since it's about not having a central government at all, burning the establishment if you will... Of course the kids like it because of the rebellion bit, however most of them have no idea what it means, my mum works in youth arts, they recently started a new campaign of youth arts using the name youth anarchist arts, also falling in well with their yava name, the whole thing identifies well with them because of the anarchy aspect but the leaders are there to facilitate, not control, the kids have creative control of the projects start to finish, it works out nicely... That's anarchy on a small scale, like think of it as no teacher in a class and we all learn on our on terms, but then there wouldn't be a class, a school... In the real world anarchy can't work, it's too idyllic, however I personally feel that to some extent the ideals of anarchy should be brought in to the everyday, to help keep the government from having control over everything, a government should never be more powerful than the sum total of it's people in my opinion...
whatsisface says: Jun 22, 2008. 3:10 AM
Why must people use "what the deuce?" all the time? It's really quite irritating, for me at least.
ll.13 in reply to whatsisfaceJun 22, 2008. 3:29 AM
maybe they think it's quite quaint.
whatsisface in reply to ll.13Jun 22, 2008. 3:50 AM
Possibly, but i've never even heard the most quintessential of englishmen say it. I've only heard it on family guy.
ll.13 in reply to whatsisfaceJun 22, 2008. 4:11 AM
I've only read it in Biggles. =)

-but considering "Family Guy's" popularity I guess that's it.
Kiteman in reply to ll.13Jun 22, 2008. 11:46 AM
I say it sometimes, but I did have a whole shelf of Biggles books as a child.

I also say "what the devil?", "Ye gods and little fishes!", "Let's give 'em what-for, eh chaps?" and "never mind, it's not their fault that they're American".
ll.13 in reply to KitemanJun 23, 2008. 1:04 AM
shweet, do you still have any for your kids? last time I checked we have 19(out of 90 odd) 0.o
Kiteman in reply to ll.13Jun 23, 2008. 2:37 AM
They're mostly in a box in the garage somewhere. #1 son has tried a couple, but they're not to his taste.
Labot2001 in reply to KitemanJun 22, 2008. 12:32 PM
Labot has link for Kiteman.
whatsisface in reply to KitemanJun 22, 2008. 11:53 AM
I use "Let's give 'em what-for, eh chaps?" as well as "Hey, it's a thingie! A fiendish thingie! " and "This place reminds me of Blackburn, Lancashire".

Double points for knowing the origin of the last two without google

Kiteman in reply to whatsisfaceJun 23, 2008. 2:32 AM
First thoughts are The Goodies, but, since you're a Colonial trying to be obscure, I'd say Monty Python.
Kiteman in reply to KitemanJun 23, 2008. 2:35 AM
>Google<

Oh, no, it's those four.
whatsisface in reply to KitemanJun 23, 2008. 9:00 AM
:D Best films ever.
Labot2001 in reply to whatsisfaceJun 22, 2008. 12:29 PM
Double points for knowing the origin of the last two without google

Now I have to look them up =P
teaaddict314 says: Jun 23, 2008. 1:15 AM
Adults do a lot of anarchic things as well....
teaaddict314 says: Jun 23, 2008. 1:02 AM
When were good just close your eyes, so when we're bad we'll scar your minds.
Lithium Rain says: Jun 22, 2008. 6:59 PM
That is an unfair generalization. Teenagers are very maligned, IMHO.
Goodhart says: Jun 22, 2008. 4:35 AM
In a word: independence After having lived under the Supreme rule of parents for 12-18 years or longer, it is a natural reaction that all rule is wrong; sort of a sling shot effect of being, as they would see it, held back for so long.
Labot2001 in reply to GoodhartJun 22, 2008. 12:37 PM
In a word: independence

=/

I usually don't disagree with you Goodhart, but anarchy and independence are two completely different things.
Goodhart in reply to Labot2001Jun 22, 2008. 12:52 PM
I didn't mean they were, I meant one was used to achieve the other. One "rebels against all authority", that is, attempts to obtain to self rule, in order to achieve their independence......and eventually they will learn just how dependent we all are on each other. :-)
Labot2001 in reply to GoodhartJun 22, 2008. 1:04 PM
Ooooh, I see now. =]
Pro

Get More Out of Instructables

Already have an Account?

close

PDF Downloads
As a Pro member, you will gain access to download any Instructable in the PDF format. You also have the ability to customize your PDF download.

Upgrade to Pro today!