I'm a homeschooler. I will post a proper break-down tomorrow when I have time, so ttyl :P

My siblings and I are homeschooled all the way. 16 years old and the second youngest I would strongly vote for homeschool. I agree with what Lithium Rain posted. The freedom is amazing. You can learn about exactly what you are gifted at and interested in. Two of my brothers and I started a homeschool forum recently:  RealEd.net hoping to encourage homeschoolers.

I found this on the Wiki page for Homeschool:

"Numerous studies have found that homeschooled students on average outperform their peers on standardized tests.[66] Home Schooling Achievement, a study conducted by National Home Education Research Institute (NHERI), supported the academic integrity of homeschooling. Among the homeschooled students who took the tests, the average homeschooled student outperformed his public school peers by 30 to 37 percentile points across all subjects. The study also indicates that public school performance gaps between minorities and genders were virtually non-existent among the homeschooled students who took the tests.

New evidence has been found that home schooled children are getting higher scores on the ACT and SAT tests. A study at Wheaton College in Illinois showed that the freshmen that were home schooled for high school scored fifty-eight points higher on their SAT scores than those of kids that went to a normal school. Most colleges look at the ACT and SAT scores of home schooled children when considering them for acceptance to a college. On average, home schooled children scores eighty-one points higher than the national average on the SAT scores."

Also, Even though homeschoolers only comprise about 2% of the school-age population, they've won 5 of the last 12 US national spelling bees,
so I think it is definitely possible to get a good education at home.

An interesting book on the subject "Weapons of mass instruction" (by John Gatto - a long time NY school teacher and winner of the schoolteacher of the year award) traces the formation of the US national compulsory schooling system to an effort to control a cheep labor force and suppress the growing intelligence of the working class.

Anyway, good luck with whatever you decide!

Hmm.. I could have sworn this was an old thread.. but I guess the one I'm thinking of could be a "Home schoolers report in". I credit being home educated (I say educated rather than schooled for many subtle reasons, but will use the terms interchangeably in the general case) until the age of 9 with keeping my passion for learning alive through the mind-numbingly tedious years from age 9 to about 15 when I could finally start learning something that really interested me, go on to do A levels and go to university. Just in terms of education and your learning process, a good school would probably be better than home school which would in turn be better than a bad school. The socialisation aspects are probably less relevant to you if you are already a teenager and know how to make friends, work with people etc. My primary concern would be qualifications. I don't know how these work in the States or what (if any) you are intending to take, but I know that as brilliant as my home education was, I don't think it could have got me through the qualifications I took (and that is with two teachers as parents). The best scenario I can think of would be if you could part-time at school, but I don't know if that's possible. As for the religious zealotry part- find a home school course that has nothing whatsoever to do with evangelical/fundamentalist/YEC christianity. I have seen excerpts from some of those courses that made my brain physically hurt.

For how long would you be home schooled? Since you've already experienced private school this isn't a "one or the other issue".
Personally I'd recommend going to public school for long enough that you know it sucks and how - then switch to home schooling. In this way you'll have experience of all 3 systems.

L

Homeschool all the way. I was homeschooled. It's awesome. You go at the precise pace you need to go. The teacher-student ratio is excellent. :D No waiting for teachers to count noses. No mandatory time-wasting activities. No spending lots of money and waiting in line for lunch. No bullies. No gangs. No security issues. There are lots of free and cheap resources for homeschooling you can use, making it possible to get an excellent education for less money. You can customize the curriculum to your own interests and needs. Some people slam it, and say we all have a supposed "lack of socialization",. Stuff and nonsense. I certainly hope school isn't the only place you see and are with other people. If it is, you haz a problemo! :D Others say there's not as many opportunities for stuff like sports or other extracurricular activities. Again, nonsense. Homeschooling leaves you with the time and money to pursue the extra activities you want on your own schedule.

Personally, I'm an advocate of traditional schools (and not just because I'm a teacher). Please remember that I am speaking about UK schools. Your teachers are all specialists in their chosen subjects, and contractually required to attend regular training to ensure their knowledge and skills remain up-to-date. Since budgets are based on numbers, school labs and workshops have much more equipment than a single family can easily afford or store. I am also a firm believer that the social side is very beneficial, even the bullying, as you will, at some point, end up working with people you don't like, or who will try and bully you. If you have not already learned to deal with those situations, you will end up at a serious disadvantage.

It's not that I wouldn't want to be homeschooled, because I would, but I don't think my parents would be up to it. Not that they're lazy or stupid, but it has been a long time since they were in high school. I could just see my mom teaching: "And this little symbol means and, which is usually called, um.... an...." "It's an ampersand." "Thanks, and the little dot at the end represents the end of a sentence."

If part of the decision of where or what to do is based on your budget and what your parents feel in your best interest, is going to "free" public school just out of the question? And if you live out in the boonies, would the time and effort spent going to school would more productive if you were just homeshcooled? I only know of a pair of kids that are homeschooled because of their parent's beliefs and church affiliation which can support it. Because of the family situation, the kids were mainstreamed back into public school and had a tough time adjusting back socially since they were never in a non-homeschool. I never considered homeschooling because I did not have a structured system or available tutors that would work out. Besides, most of life's tough lessons are learned growing up and dealing with all kinds of life in a public school. Some public schools do suck. Well, here in New York City, I even have disdain for one of my friend's wife who is a schoolteacher because she just views her job as a professional babysitter. One school has the parents association trying to pull a coup d'etat mutiny on the principal of the school. But sometimes you have no choice to your assigned local school in many cases and options to transfer to something better does not work out. So in those cases, I believe, you stick it out and make the best of it. Bright students will always shine. There will always be one teacher who is a positive role model to make the best of things. As for the extras like music, arts, advanced studies,... that is already paid for by taxes. Take advantage of it if you can. I really don't like to make recommendations on what people do because there are so many things to consider in making a big decision like this. All I can say is that sometimes you have to sacrifice something in the short term, put up with the pain, and hope for better things in the future. Times are rough for everyone. Best of luck to you.

Cyber-School ftw. It's like public school, in the sense that you don't have to pay for anything, however you can work at your pace, or work with a virtual class (at least at PaCyber)