Suggestion: Editing Comments

Hey, I got a suggestion for Instructables: allow comment editing.
It just sucks that, if you comment, you notice you made a typo, and thus want to edit it, but the only way by doing so is deleting your old comment, leaving a (removed by author or cumminty request) behind.

sort by: active | newest | oldest
1-10 of 12Next »
wilgubeast3 years ago

removed by author or community request.

Just kidding. This would be useful. But it would make comment moderation a moving target.

Zachrey3 years ago

I agree! I just wrote this LONG great comment and saw a typo and forgot to select all and copy before deleting the comment. NNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!

GitarGr83 years ago

Just make it like Reddit comments. It's pretty damn annoying that you can't fix your typos. All you have to do is include some kind of indication that the post has been edited. As it stands, I have to delete my comment, fix my typo, and post a new comment. That's real dumb.

mikeasaurus4 years ago
It's a double-edged sword. Editing comments after posting might be easy for editing typos, but can be confusing (misleading) for conversations / heated debates.

(Unless, it is possible to automatically disable editing on comments that have had a reply?)
Sorunome (author)  Kiteman4 years ago
That might actually be a pretty good idea and in-between solution.
If it works - I don't know code from semolina, so I have no idea if it is actually possible.
Sorunome (author)  Kiteman4 years ago
It is possible to do so software-side. Either they have already stored if a comment has a reply, or, as they have stored to which comment the current one is a reply, you need to loop through all comments in order to find out if it got replied to.
As that might be a bit slow to do that for every comment I would suggest some easy filtering for a [edit] link client-side by looking at the tree structure, and then when submitting the actual edit looking through all the comments.

If they use MySQL they could also like select the comments where the reply id is the current comment.

But then again, I am sorry to say this, but some of instructables code is not very good at all, like using multiple elements with the same ID and stuff like that.
I can't comment on that - maybe if you sent an email to HQ about it?
Sorunome (author)  Kiteman4 years ago
What is 'HQ'?
Also, shouldn't developers check the forums?
1-10 of 12Next »