knives? who carries one?
Hello, i am a designer at SAIC and i am researching knives and who does and does not carry them. If you do not mind could you post your experiences with pocket knives and why you do or do not carry them?
Here is a poll i am using to collect some numbers http://poll.pollcode.com/bs684r
All of this data is to help me design something that could be seen in the pockets of more people as i think a knife is an incredibly valuable accessory that comes in handy on so many occasions, and its a shame more people do not carry them.
Thank you so much for your help and i will post whatever progress i make on this.
-Dave
Here is a poll i am using to collect some numbers http://poll.pollcode.com/bs684r
All of this data is to help me design something that could be seen in the pockets of more people as i think a knife is an incredibly valuable accessory that comes in handy on so many occasions, and its a shame more people do not carry them.
Thank you so much for your help and i will post whatever progress i make on this.
-Dave

















JUNE 2013 Build Night - 3D Printing with 123D & Tinkercad
Instructables Build Night w/ Bare Conductive @ Noisebridge
Embed a 3D viewer in your Instructable
Maker Faire 2013 Slide Show!
Fried Contest Launches 5/13, HQ Celebrates with Fried Day Friday
MEH! :D A Build Night at Montana Ethical Hackerspace!
Got contest ideas? Want to help HQ staff?
Large Instructables Robot head made out of driftwood, check it out!
Call for pre-made parts!
The Instructables Green Design Contest is starting on Earth Day!

Visit Our Store »
Go Pro Today »




My busker friend had a big scary knife and the cops came around. They talked to him and it was fine but it may have cost him some money as a busker by getting fewer coins.
I'd suggest keeping your knife out of sight.
I think the reason more people don't carry "such an amazingly useful tool" is because they aren't allowed to or don't want to give others the wrong impression. I'm sure we've all gotten the weird looks when we've pulled out our knives to open a package or something. Plus there are all kinds of places that have zero tolerance for weapons, job sites, offices, government buildings, etc. Most job sites that require you to complete a task, like opening boxes, cutting wires and tie downs, etc, will supply you with the tools to do so in an efficient manner, making your pocket knife useless.
As for gaining female market share. I think the problem is that the things knives are useful for, aren't what the ladies are doing. Statistically speaking. Most women I've known carry a knife in their cars glove box but only a couple have carried one on their person and they were always the ones that were into the activities that weren't "stereotypically" feminine. I think if they (females) have a lifestyle where a knife is useful, they'll carry one. There probably isn't some magic "make it pink and shiny and slap a kitty logo on it" formula that will pull all the girls into the store.
Now, I am looked down upon if I carry my tool, to certain places.
My Dad gave me the pocket knife (long before the 'multi-tools became popular, other then the Swiss Army knife), it had a useful can opener, bottle opener, and leather punch, besides the two blades, and it got me out of a lot of "car" troubles.
It was a BARLOW, with hardened (not stainless) steel blades and so needed to be cared for. It rarely needed sharpening however and held a good edge if properly used. I still have it and it was 41 years ago that it was given to me.
However, I no longer carry them at work, since they allegedly worry the students.
They aren't worried about the bunsen burners, acids, radioactive samples, chisels, hacksaws, pillar drills, laser-cutter and disc-sanders, lathes and band-saws, but they are worried when I sharpen a pencil with a one-inch blade, but there you go...
I feel as if the average person does not want to mug, stab, or cause some sort of harm to another person and i feel like there are many frustrated people who right now are looking for some sort of way to open a package, cut some wire, or possible do some food prep on the go, but these people are without a tool to do any of this stuff.
So i am a little lost as to how to put that simply and get some good info out of it.
Thanks for your input though!
----------------------------------
Ah, I think the same problem exists if you take a look at the stuff they design for women's tools. I take note because I am always on the lookout to get tools for my daughter(teen). You can paint it pink or cool girly designs, make the handles more ergonomic for smaller hands, but they just don't work the same for some reason. Lighter hammers make for a useless tool. Is it a general cultural thing, go find someone with a knife if you need a knife? I think it may be that females use different kinds of tools, more precision and smaller. I will always get the myriad of tweezers and makeup brushes to use on my electronics. But hey, if you want to talk design, plenty of folks here to chime in.
So looking at why girls do not carry knives and getting some first hand info is important.
So are knife handles really to big for girls?
Though still i like that approach of looking at a comparison between how girls approach cutting vs how guys, and how to work around that to make it as efficient as possible while looking elegant/girly/not overtly girly
This sounds like a sexist pig but most women will carry a nail file and not even think about it, but a knife dosen't fit into what most women think they may need to carry.
Now you make a multitool that has a file, mirror, lip gloss, eye shadow brush, tweezers, eye liner, etc...and happen to have a small blade on it, you might make a million. (duck and cover for the ensuing woman rants)