1-ingredient Ice Cream

 by scoochmaroo
Featured

Step 3: Enjoy!

icecream1.jpg
For the first go-round, try this recipe as-is.

Thereafter, feel free to consider this a blank canvas for all of your ice cream dreams.

Try adding honey, chocolate syrup, maple syrup, peanut butter, flavored extracts, or additional frozen fruits! Go to town, and make sure you share your favorite remixes in the comments!
 
Remove these adsRemove these ads by Signing Up
SupraHD says: Jan 12, 2013. 9:34 PM
Well, I'll try this later and add some honey. Let see what it tastes like.
june9190 says: Aug 31, 2009. 9:41 AM
it sounds different. I like banana's and in my house they do go brown.. ok so has anybody really tried it? and did they like it??? I hate to go and buy a blender and find out it's not very good.. What a dilemma!!!
sugarego in reply to june9190Dec 28, 2009. 11:44 AM
smart thinking june9190.  i *finally* tried this recipe.  in order to facilitate easier blending, i smooshed the bananas up a bit before freezing.  this made it easy to put in small pieces that weren't like giant ice cubes.  and if you think where i'm going with this is that it worked fabulously, i'm afraid that's not so.

the frozen bananas were, of course, darkened, because that's what you do, you use bananas ready for banana bread, right?  well, the color of them when they were frozen and smooshed in the bag simply darkened as they began to melt.  never got white and frothy.  i ran the blender some more, wondering if magic might start to happen a bit later.  worried b/c the bottom of the mixture was getting stirred, but the top was sitting there in a sort-of gelatinous mass.  i tilted the blender to encourage the stuff on top to get mixed in, and even stopped to stir.

what came off of the spoon wasn't even cold: the blades had generated enough heat to completely melt any trace of freeziness.  i ended up with slightly-more-blended, smooshed banana.  basically what i put into the freezer in the first place.

my wife was there with me, b/c we were planning to eat a yummy freezy banana treat, and she just kept laughing and insisting the whole thing was a big elaborate hoax.  that no one could possibly have ended up with something that resembles ice cream, and that everyone else who left comments was in on the hoax.  so, my point is: don't get a blender just for this treat.  you may feel that you, too, have become the brunt of a giant hoax.

anyone else have this experience when attempting to make this?
sherrycayheyhey in reply to sugaregoJan 7, 2012. 9:20 PM
Unfortunately I'm leaning towards the hoax side as well. I was excited to try this but ended up with some gloopy mush. I read other comments about it being better with a food processor but I thought my Ninja brand blender could accomplish the task of turning a banana into an ice cream like substance. I'm not completely abandoning this awesome idea but until I get a food processor or can convince someone with one to try this, I'm going to have to remain skeptical.
Popopopper in reply to sherrycayheyheyJul 29, 2012. 12:23 PM
I also used a ninja blender, but mine was perfect!
YellowBlu Co. in reply to sherrycayheyheyJun 24, 2012. 3:52 PM
Mine was delicious, but it wasn't working right away. When I made mine, I was a bit impatient so I just took the bananas I had even though they weren't brown. I froze them, and I stuck them in my magic bullet blender but nothing happened. So I added some milk in it and squished it with a spoon. When it had a creamy texture, I ate it. It tasted like ice cream, but at the same time, it still tasted like bananas. Of course it would taste like bananas, but it really just tasted like a regular banana with an ice creamy texture, which is what it is. Either way, I enjoyed making and eating it.
jediwhiz3 in reply to sherrycayheyheyMar 7, 2012. 1:54 PM
Mine was great. Fun to make. Great because it is dairy-free. And it was DELICIOUS. Need new snacks that are healthy and lactose-free? THIS ONE IS FANTASTIC!
laxap in reply to sherrycayheyheyJan 8, 2012. 6:40 AM
I got fantastic results, largely meeting the expectations.
My tips:
  1. Cut the banana in slices before freezing; the smaller the better
  2. Freeze
  3. Blend using a cutting blade
  4. Progressively add some water (as kitchouha suggested) while blending, if it does not turn creamy
  5. Freeze again
  6. Serve with grilled sliced almonds
vCloud in reply to sugaregoAug 30, 2011. 8:17 AM
well i heard many roumors about this recipe, i am currently trying this today, i heard blenders don't work and you must use a food processor for the best results.
Javin007 in reply to sugaregoJun 9, 2011. 4:15 PM
I'm right there with ya. I tried the brown bananas, cut in half, frozen solid in a sub-zero freezer, and blended with a Vita-Mix (same blender Bobby Flay uses.) What I got was a cold cream with a nice texture that tasted exactly like rotten bananas.

I figured maybe I had let the bananas go too long, so tried a second batch. This time I froze the peeled bananas when the skins were slightly brown, but the bananas were still white. EXACT same result. The banana "cream" tasted just as rotten as the first batch.

My guess is, unless you like the taste of way over-ripened bananas, you'll have to freeze the bananas when they are still fresh. I'm going to try that next. (Though I don't know if the freezing process itself is actually producing that "over-ripe banana" flavor.)

On another note, I find that if you add enough chocolate, caramel, nuts, and fruits to the "ice cream" it's almost edible, but that probably rather defeats the purpose.

I find it interesting that you used the word "hoax" as this is exactly the word my own girlfriend used when we tried it the first time. She refused to even taste it the second time around. Hopefully third time's the charm!
leagle in reply to sugaregoApr 9, 2011. 3:54 AM
I tried it when on vacation with my daughter so needed to buy a food processor when I got home. You need to have the bananas in pieces and really frozen so freeze them not touching if you can. I added a bit of cream to get them started and it is crucial that you don't have too much to process and push down any part processed banana into the mix. That way you can beat it until it changes to a pale colour due to the air you're pumping in. It can be refrozen but is best straight from the mixer. Do put the mixer to soak because dried banana sticks like glue and is a devil to shift :)
_chink_ in reply to sugaregoJan 14, 2010. 6:18 AM
I just made this and am eating it as I'm typing. My boyfriend is also helping me eat it (voluntarily i might add!) so it must taste pretty good.  I used VERY brown bananas, which I think is making it taste extra banana-y, so I think if you want less banana taste, use banana's which haven't gone completely brown like mine were. However, I love banana's, so I don't mind the taste, and the texture is amazing.

I think the point of this recipe is that the banana's need to be frozen whole, or at least in large chunks, and not 'smooshed', because smooshing them before frozen actually speeds up the browning process (oxidation) and releases a lot of the water content. When done as the instructable says, the frozen banana's first blend into an almost bread crumb like consistency, before taking on the smooth and silky texture described.

I do have to mention that I intially had some trouble getting it beyond the crumbly mixture, but that's mainly because I was using my stick blender with the little bowl attachement, and in the end just transferred it to the mixing cup and using the stick attachment, and it worked beautifully.

Don't be scared to try this again =P freeze the banana's whole!
caityjay in reply to june9190Sep 3, 2009. 11:39 AM
Buy a blender. Find one at a thrift store (plug it in first, of course, to test it). Blenders are, like... awesome.
sugarego in reply to caityjaySep 8, 2009. 5:47 PM
blenders are, like, a pain in the arse to clean. i have one, but never want to use it b/c you have to fill the whole dish drain with all its parts laying out to dry. then you have to reassemble and find cabinet space for it a few days later after everything's shifted. maybe i need the blender you've got.
4eversixteen in reply to sugaregoSep 23, 2009. 9:16 AM
Quick, easy Blender cleaning: I add 2-3 drops of dish detergent, fill about 1/4 to 1/3 full with warm water. Blend on high for 30 seconds or so. Then rinse well. Done. Sparkling Clean!
komecake in reply to 4eversixteenDec 28, 2009. 4:34 AM
  Oh, how much I learn just from reading comments. Awsome cleaning instructions. I'm not so afraid to get out of the blender now. :)
devynhogan in reply to sugaregoSep 22, 2009. 4:12 PM
leave put together and fill with water and soap, give it a 30 second spin and presto clean. though you do need to take it apart for some things but for this i think it will do.
sugarego in reply to devynhoganSep 23, 2009. 12:02 PM
i'll have to try this. thanks 4eversixteen & devynhogan, for the suggestion. i'm sure that this would suffice for removing banana goo, or milkshake ingredients. since i'm lazy. :)
vililyia in reply to sugaregoSep 20, 2009. 7:58 PM
Solution: stick blender. I recieved one of these as a baby shower gift and wow! Soooooo easy to clean up and I've used mine for some pretty tough things. I made my own baby food for over a year and this thing never let me down.
sugarego in reply to vililyiaSep 23, 2009. 12:05 PM
you know, it had never occurred to me to get one of these, b/c it just doesn't look like they can do what a blender does. but per your suggestion, i'm going to research it b/c it does seem ultra convenient (and compact!) which would be a welcome change. i would say that i'll have to keep my upright blender for breaking ice to small bits, but my "ice crusher" blender does no such thing. it always leaves behind lots of large bits of ice, so making at-home frozen coffee drinks and the like isn't really feasible anyway. maybe i'll be so happy with the stick blender that i'll take my current blender to a thrift store. it takes up so much room in our small kitchen! :)
vililyia in reply to sugaregoSep 23, 2009. 3:05 PM
It does take some effort to get the stick to do a good job with ice, but it can be done. There's probably some out there that do a better job with ice than mine since I've had mine for almost two years and the specific brand I have has already come out with new ones. Happy researching :)
bobwantzanapple in reply to sugaregoSep 14, 2009. 4:49 PM
my blender only has 2 parts that need cleaning...lid and pitcher
Zem in reply to bobwantzanappleSep 22, 2009. 2:29 PM
Same
PikminRed in reply to ZemJan 7, 2010. 4:45 PM
x2
sugarego in reply to ZemSep 23, 2009. 12:00 PM
well, my lid has two parts (lid, centerpiece) and my pitcher has several parts (glass pitcher, blade assembly, gasket, and bottom plastic piece that these set into, which has a guideline for when you set it on the base, so you know you've twisted it on safely). and honestly, i'm not sure i'd want an upright blender without the ability to get the blades off to make sure they're clean underneath, or without a replaceable gasket for when the rubber gets brittle (i've already replaced it once). but the convenience of just two pieces does sound nice.
PikminRed in reply to sugaregoJan 7, 2010. 4:51 PM
How old is yours? I got mine like, 4 years ago? its a nice stainless steel 'Back to Basics' brand. It works fine and is easy to clean.
bobwantzanapple in reply to sugaregoOct 11, 2009. 1:46 PM
my lid has a centerpiece too, but you don't have to take it out, just put it in the dishwasher and it gets clean.
meejenbea in reply to bobwantzanappleNov 8, 2009. 6:02 PM
I always dont use the center piece and just cover the top hole with my hand then lick off any thing thats gets on. I recomend trying to prep clean as much of the pitcher as you can with your tounge ! yum!
bobwantzanapple in reply to meejenbeaNov 10, 2009. 1:10 PM

the ice cream tasted like rotten bananas

murphypop in reply to bobwantzanappleMar 28, 2010. 8:07 AM
Did you use rotten bananas? You should only use slightly over-ripe bananas for this. I've accidentally done this too with over-over-ripe bananas, and it did NOT turn out well.
bobwantzanapple in reply to murphypopApr 1, 2010. 6:18 PM
 it was a perfectly ripe banana & it tasted rotten after freezing

overblast in reply to bobwantzanappleMar 7, 2011. 8:44 AM
If at first you don't succeed, try and try again! :)
bobwantzanapple in reply to overblastMar 7, 2011. 5:35 PM
Or try something else...
Zem in reply to sugaregoSep 23, 2009. 12:52 PM
Wow. Mine only has two lid parts and the pitcher and everything at all assembled together.
Zem in reply to ZemSep 23, 2009. 12:52 PM
Are all*
redsoxdrummer in reply to sugaregoSep 14, 2009. 2:37 PM
yo, u can put it in th dish warshur.....
firefliie in reply to redsoxdrummerApr 19, 2010. 3:45 PM

you**
the**
washer**

Micizzle in reply to firefliieJun 23, 2011. 3:41 PM
I find it absolutely hilarious when people do this. It tickles me.
Kasm279 in reply to sugaregoSep 12, 2009. 11:18 AM
what blender do you have? o.O
urtlesquirt says: Apr 12, 2012. 9:05 AM
Time for root beer extract!
thartaros says: Oct 4, 2009. 3:28 PM
can this be done with other fruits? i dont mean adding other fruits TO the bananas...my question is do other fruits become ice-creamy if blended??
skarum in reply to thartarosJul 19, 2011. 6:00 PM
it really depends on the fruit. if you were to put in an apple, then it would take a long time to blend if at all. if you put in strawberries then i would imagine that it would work a lot better. but ultimately the banana is the best fruit to do this with.
scoochmaroo (author) in reply to thartarosOct 4, 2009. 6:52 PM
I've heard rumors of peaches working. I think it has to be pretty starchy or something for it to work,
leagle in reply to scoochmarooApr 9, 2011. 4:05 AM
My daughter reckons that pineapple makes a great ice-cream. I guess it may be any high fibre fruit that works
Korlee says: Jun 4, 2011. 11:47 AM
I tried this today and it was lovely!
I was allso testing tofu-cram-thing, so I wisked the "cream" in to a foam and mixed them together with soma rasberry-jam.. I was good and my daughter loved it! :D
I'll make something like this for her birthday!
andymic says: Mar 10, 2011. 6:33 AM
This looks great! have to try it out.
I'm not sure if it would have the same consistency, but i'm going to try it with strawberries. i'll let you know when i try it ;)
zme in reply to andymicApr 14, 2011. 12:09 PM
I've heard you can do frozen strawberries with buttermilk for a similar instant treat.
barblorraine says: Mar 14, 2011. 3:07 PM
i added some peanut butter and it was also very tasty.
andross says: Mar 6, 2011. 9:14 AM
You can also make the same thing with Avocado, sounds gross, but it's good.
BellLink in reply to androssMar 14, 2011. 12:48 PM
that sounds really gross, does it really work?
earth_cruiser in reply to androssMar 13, 2011. 11:44 AM
Very good! I like to make Avocado Pudding too. Cashews are another good substitute for milk. Juliano Brotman has a great recipe for Cashew Gelato.
gwrober in reply to androssMar 6, 2011. 12:26 PM
A friend's mom did this when I was a kid - I think she added a touch of milk and/or sugar to sweeten it, but it was GOOD!
earth_cruiser says: Mar 13, 2011. 11:52 AM
This was good. It was great to make it for my children and not feel horrible about all the sugar.
chrissysno says: Mar 7, 2011. 5:53 PM
INSTRUCTABLES is a place to read and possibly try to make interesting things,,,,,,right?
Or is it a place for negative "Know-it-alls" to pick the projects apart, and generally critisize? (They sound so angry)
On a side note.....Look at the complaints by these geniuses. They all have misspelled words in them.

Don't pay attention to these people. The rest of us love your demos.
Keep them coming! ;)
me67559 in reply to chrissysnoMar 8, 2011. 5:08 PM
touche!
wreagle96 in reply to chrissysnoMar 7, 2011. 7:41 PM
I was just trying to correct two commonly believed myths. Information is power. and no mispelled words!
dagenius in reply to wreagle96Mar 12, 2011. 8:51 AM
I believe "misspelled" has two S's.
mjursic in reply to dageniusMar 20, 2011. 10:43 AM
I have the myspeling vyris, so I cant spel coorecly. ;-)
chrissysno in reply to wreagle96Mar 8, 2011. 5:28 PM
I'm surprised. I didn't mention any names, but got a reply. Perhaps I touched a nerve?
sebergast in reply to chrissysnoMar 12, 2011. 11:35 AM
haha i like banana ice cream isnt that where this instructable is all about?
chuckyd says: Mar 6, 2011. 7:44 AM
Frozen yogurt tastes like ice cream, but it's still called frozen yogurt.

So, frozen bananas should be called frozen bananas.
spark master in reply to chuckydMar 8, 2011. 1:55 PM
thank you I feel vindicated
chinasmom2000 in reply to chuckydMar 6, 2011. 7:52 AM
You're a very rigid person; try to lighten up.
zenfidelity says: Mar 6, 2011. 8:52 AM
Strictly speaking this is closer to a sorbet than an ice cream. Still hadn't thought to enjoy bananas in this way so thanks for posting, but I would recommend being more careful in your posts later on so that you don't mislead the readers. Thanks.
spark master in reply to zenfidelityMar 8, 2011. 1:54 PM
chaching give that man a ceegar
chrissysno says: Mar 7, 2011. 5:40 PM
gizmology.....Ditto!
zinnia11 says: Mar 7, 2011. 7:30 AM
I didn't see anything in the directions about using an ice cream maker (or maybe I didn't read carefully enough). Do you need one or can you just process it and freeze it?
I don't own an ice cream maker anymore but I would consider buying one for this recipe, if I need to. It sounds amazing!
kiwirise says: Sep 3, 2009. 1:18 PM
I've seen a demo of this done by a vegan and its SOOO delish and interesting the guilt that goes with ice cream. I didn't want to eat more and the woman was like "its JUST a banana there is nothing to feel bad about!" so eat more and more and more and don't feel bad because its oh so good!
scoochmaroo (author) in reply to kiwiriseOct 1, 2010. 11:34 AM
I had that same reaction! Oh, I better stop eating this. . . oh wait! It's a BANANA!
Brad I. in reply to scoochmarooMar 6, 2011. 6:28 AM
I don't like the flavor of brown bananas - but love the ones that are a bit green. Do you think I'd still like this recipe?
Treknology in reply to Brad I.Mar 6, 2011. 7:42 PM
I've been doing this for a while. I buy bananas that are just a little bit green.

I peel and DEEP freeze them. Blending one decent sized banana and a cup of cold milk gives a consistency of a "thick shake".

I've often heard the BS that people can't tell the difference between fresh and brown banana if they can't see it first. Like you, I can!
Shany120 in reply to scoochmarooMar 5, 2011. 4:35 PM
I know!! I did like strawberries, pineapples, i think It had mangoes in it, bananas, etc. I really just peeled and threw in any frozen fruit I had because originally (before I seen this) I was going to make a smoothie, and I seen "Ice cream with one ingredient" so I had to try it!
Vulcanator in reply to kiwiriseJun 16, 2010. 6:44 AM
but plants can feel pain too.
shenker10 in reply to VulcanatorAug 30, 2010. 6:14 PM
nope actuay they cant, mythbusters tested it
gafisher in reply to shenker10Mar 6, 2011. 10:34 AM
They can but they're too polite to complain.

But of course bananas aren't plants, they're seed pods, so it's OK.
WendyLD3 in reply to shenker10Nov 26, 2010. 7:18 PM
they did, plants do have feelings from there test. it was plausibal.
AJBrawlLvr in reply to shenker10Sep 4, 2010. 12:50 PM
Mythbusters beats EVERYTHING!
myth-bstr225 in reply to AJBrawlLvrMar 6, 2011. 5:38 PM
Yay Mythbuster comment on an Ice Cream thread!
squirrelMLM in reply to VulcanatorJun 30, 2010. 9:55 AM
I'll never eat a coconut again :O
zascecs in reply to VulcanatorJun 16, 2010. 3:51 PM
hehe... =P
radiochemist in reply to kiwiriseSep 3, 2009. 3:02 PM
why do you feel guilty about eating ice cream? i just buy it and dont hurt anyone in the process.. how do you get your ice cream?
earth_cruiser in reply to radiochemistMar 13, 2011. 11:51 AM
I stopped eating dairy because of the environmental harm. Cows are the number one producer of Methane (a greenhouse gas that's 20x more powerful than CO2), which is emitted due to their digestion process. There are about 1.5 billion cows on our planet today. Cows are also responsible for land degradation, and most importantly they eat more than half of the grain produced in the US. The grain factor bothers me because of the millions dying from malnutrition each year; the majority being children. As a mother, I want to do something that reduces the negative environmental impact, and I don't want to demand that grain be given to a cow rather than a starving child. Not that everyone needs to stop eating meat and dairy, but it is more than worthwhile to reduce consumption.
Minke in reply to radiochemistMay 6, 2010. 7:28 PM
Calories.

Btw- There IS a such thing as vegan ice cream so....yeah...
Brittz303 in reply to MinkeFeb 14, 2011. 10:46 PM
OM NOM NOM SOY ICE CREAM! :D I'm not even vegan and I love it. I think it is amazingly good. It's exactly like ice cream, and its FULL of protein (which is good because I'm not really a big meat-eater)
calyad in reply to Brittz303Mar 6, 2011. 6:08 PM
The average banana contains about 1g of protein. IMO, they are more useful for the fibre, vitamins and minerals. They are all good!
Pie Ninja in reply to radiochemistSep 9, 2009. 4:11 AM
Vegans don't eat anything produced by animals, i.e: Cheese, eggs, milk, cream, etc. Personally I hate them, but I won't go on a rant cause this is a happy place. Also, awesome 'ible. Is it possible to do it with one an electric mixer? I don't own a blender :(
overblast in reply to Pie NinjaMar 7, 2011. 8:42 AM
Just wondering, if vegetarians eat vegetables, what do humanitarians eat????
beccane in reply to Pie NinjaMay 20, 2010. 12:13 PM
um thanks for not hating in this happy place. i'm not vegan but I can't really see the harm (in fact NOT harming is the point). Unless you just think they're annoying. which is a notch down from hate, I'd say.
BretMattingly in reply to beccaneJun 11, 2010. 12:58 PM
You can read Lierre Kieth's "The Vegetarian Myth" in case you're interested in the actual "harm" that widespread vegetarianism/veganism can cause. Quite eye opening. I'm personally with Pie Ninja on the fact that in general, they're mostly annoying, ignorant in regards to nutrition (really), and anti non-vegan, but, one of my best friends is vegan married to a vegetarian and we get along fine. :) Now, to smoocharoo, well done, because for a second once I saw "non-dairy", I anticipated some frankensoy nonsense. This was actually quite delicious. Thank ye, miss.
gafisher in reply to BretMattinglyMar 6, 2011. 10:37 AM
Well said.

Vegetables are what food eats. ;-)
spark master in reply to gafisherMar 8, 2011. 1:48 PM
give credit, alf says that
earth_cruiser in reply to BretMattinglySep 15, 2010. 1:40 PM
I eat somewhere between Vegetarian and Vegan. I don't think people are bad for eating the way the do, or wrong for that matter. My choice in diet has to do with many things. It's frustrating to me that I'm immediately stereotyped as "annoying" and "ignorant" by someone who doesn't even know me.

Please be open-minded. Whatever I eat, whatever my religion, whatever my ethnicity I am a human being just like you. I could be a human being that you like too, but you'd never know by shutting me out for eating the way I do. I think it's labels and stereotypes that are annoying and ignorant. No good may come of them.
BretMattingly in reply to earth_cruiserSep 15, 2010. 7:47 PM
I STRONGLY suggest you re-read the entirety of my comment. Nowhere did I say I find people BAD for eating the way they do. I merely stated that vegans, IN GENERAL, are ignorant IN REGARDS TO NUTRITION (which, in my experience, is mostly true. Since posting my initial comment, I've since met a vegan nutritionist whose views toward diet are quite scientifically sound). However, this is most often not the case.

Nor would I say I would "shut someone out" for their being vegan.
earth_cruiser in reply to BretMattinglyMar 13, 2011. 11:33 AM
I understand what your comment says with vegans/vegetarians being one way in general. I don't feel that generalizing is appropriate though. It assigns characteristics to someone until they prove otherwise. I would imagine someone who feels vegans are ignorant and stuck up in general would be affected by those assumptions when meeting someone who doesn't eat meat. As someone who doesn't eat meat, it's hard to hear people say vegetarians and vegans generally act one way. I feel like I have to hide the fact I don't eat meat so that I'm not stereotyped. These kind of generalizations are similarly found in racism, sexism and so on. While you may understand that not all vegetarians are one way, it's unfair to say that they are generally one way. Before you can say that you need to take the opportunity to get to know every vegetarian. Otherwise it's not substantial. While 2/3 of adult Americans are overweight or obese, I don't say that all meat-eaters are overweight and unhealthy. I know MANY people who are, but that doesn't represent the entire meat-eating population. I don't know them personally, so there's no way for me to know that.

Please don't get me wrong. I'm not out to get you. I just hope that you might consider the harm generalizations can have. I would love to just be me without people talking negatively about my personal life choices. While your statements aren't specific to me, they are specific to my lifestyle and thus has a negative connotation. Maybe it just something to consider.
Pie Ninja in reply to earth_cruiserMar 13, 2011. 10:55 PM
So you're comparing vegetarians (people who make the choice to not eat meat, something that is entirely unnecessary and pointless(unless, of course, they have some form of medical disorder)) to people who have been oppressed, enslaved and mistreated through no choice of their own.

I'd also like to point out that not many people introduce themselves by saying "I'M A VEGETARIAN", so unless they were publicly shaming the consumption of meat, or on their moral high horse about ethical treatment of animals (the very kind of vegetarians that are insufferable morons), there is no way for me to make an opinion of a vegetarian person without getting to know them.
DELETED_Magebear in reply to BretMattinglyFeb 4, 2011. 3:09 AM
(removed by author or community request)
earth_cruiser in reply to DELETED_MagebearMar 13, 2011. 11:33 AM
Great point. Thanks!
Ghalko in reply to DELETED_MagebearMar 6, 2011. 9:16 AM
Some people don't eat things because of traumatic childhood experiences... I've gotten over most of mine I think, but if you cook the broccoli too long, I probably will avoid it, crunchy or fresh, great!
boofsmom in reply to GhalkoMar 6, 2011. 9:31 PM
I SO totally agree. I still can't eat liver and onions. And cold eggs make me gag. People - PLEASE do not make your kids sit at the table until they clean their plates. Not only do kids know when they are full or they simply do not like something, doing so can give them deep-seated food issues that will last for decades.
Brad I. in reply to DELETED_MagebearMar 6, 2011. 6:24 AM
I am a B-vegan. That's a vegan who eats nothing but bacon.
randall550 in reply to Brad I.Mar 7, 2011. 9:05 AM
Cool...does that grow on trees or can you grow it in a garden?
Brad I. in reply to randall550Mar 7, 2011. 1:25 PM
It grows in a grocery store.
bearswife in reply to Brad I.Mar 6, 2011. 7:46 AM
Brad I. - you rock!
Pie Ninja in reply to beccaneMay 20, 2010. 9:49 PM
Not so much vegans in general, just the ones who are anti-anything that isn't vegan. If they shut up and leave me to my steak in peace, then that's fine.
bets_valle in reply to Pie NinjaMar 6, 2011. 9:28 PM
Well I believe what bothers most about vegans, frutarians and some others that may fit in the nonsensical/suicidal eating habits its the fact that some of those people tend to over-share their opinions on the matter, I mean, if you eat meat, then eat meat and if you don't then don't, just don't go around blabbing about how wrong someone else is about not eating like the one accusing...
I can understad that, and MOST non-omnivores SHOULD IMO be aware that statistically they are more likely to die young and suffer anemia and malnutrition, etc. Still it's not les valid to eat or not to eat whatever every single human being feels more like it (or can, in some cases), so I can understand the polemic caused by this, yet I don't support some of the opinions left clear here.
earth_cruiser in reply to Pie NinjaSep 15, 2010. 1:35 PM
I border between eating Vegeterian and Vegan. I go out of my way to avoid sharing this with people because it slaps a label on me and allows for quick judgement. My journey with food has evolved over the years and I now have many, mean reasons for eating the way I do.

I don't expect people to eat like me. What's right for me may not be right for others. What I do expect though is for companies to be ethical, the media to be informative, and people on our planet to know where there food comes and care about the process.

I don't look down on anyone who eats a steak. Hopefully no one will look down on me for eating the meatless alternative.
DELETED_kage_no_akiri in reply to earth_cruiserMar 7, 2011. 2:58 PM
(removed by author or community request)
Filthy Pazuzu in reply to DELETED_kage_no_akiriMar 8, 2011. 2:16 PM
(removed by author or community request)
devineDIY in reply to DELETED_kage_no_akiriMar 7, 2011. 8:34 PM
Hi friend,

If you are going to make general statements from the Bible ("not eat them.") then you should read the whole thing, not just the parts you feel back up your views: Didn't God send down Quail in Exodus 16:13?

I sure am glad God made bananas. Great invention!
aplauche in reply to earth_cruiserMar 6, 2011. 7:58 AM
sure doesn't seem like you go out of your way to avoid sharing your eating habits...
in fact i would say the opposite, you go out of the IN ORDER to share your eating style. other than that though you seem like a pretty decent person.
earth_cruiser in reply to aplaucheMar 13, 2011. 11:41 AM
Forums with open discussion on a topic are one thing, but sharing information with friends and family are another. I suppose that's one reason why I participate in online discussions. I read a lot of books and watch a lot of films discussing nutrition, health, and environmental issues. I've tried sharing things with others that I find exciting or shocking, but the interest isn't there. I'd love to talk about everything I've learned and all the things I'm curious about, but while I'm enthusiastic they're speechless. Because of this I keep most thoughts along this line to myself during day-to-day life. Hopefully I will meet people with similar interests one day so that I can have a face-to-face conversation about such matters.
gizmology in reply to aplaucheMar 6, 2011. 8:43 PM
Hahaha this thread is cracking me up... so out of this page, I get my dessert AND my laugh for the day! :D Thanks!
jello666 in reply to aplaucheMar 6, 2011. 9:10 AM
How true that is a odd practice. I don't go around introducing myself as a omnivore It reminds me of the South Park episode concerning Smug.
garrett10 in reply to Pie NinjaJun 14, 2010. 6:38 PM
HaHaHa lol Agreed
komecake in reply to Pie NinjaDec 28, 2009. 12:51 AM
  I think it would, but it might take awhile and might not get quite as creamy. Give it a try. Why not? :)
Kasm279 in reply to Pie NinjaSep 12, 2009. 11:09 AM
i doubt it wil work with a mixer, it MIGHT work with a food processor though...
kenneth I am in reply to Kasm279Mar 6, 2011. 12:36 PM
In her pictures she is using a food processor to make it. I would think the food processor would work much better than a blender, to be honest!
Obediah in reply to Kasm279Dec 27, 2009. 5:50 PM
totally worked with my food processor.
kiwirise in reply to radiochemistSep 4, 2009. 5:41 AM
oh i just feel guilty cuz I dont want to get fat.
kiddoforever in reply to kiwiriseAug 5, 2010. 11:50 PM
Bananas are fruit, fruit is good. ALSO bananas are rich in potassium which help cramps. Even if a banana has sugar in it it's not unhealthy like white sugar or corn syrup. It's pure natural fruit, good for you, and the only health food that doesn't have the texture of crunchy oatmeal and tastes like old people. (Not that I would know what old people taste like..)
deadchickens in reply to kiddoforeverFeb 5, 2011. 2:03 AM
but you shouldn't eat too many bananas (or too much banana ice cream) because you can overdose on potassium. then again, you have to eat like 15 or so. lolo
riff raff in reply to deadchickensMar 6, 2011. 8:22 AM
Actually, I ate a banana a day for months, until my lab tests came back, showing my potassium level was too high. Moderation in all things, I guess.

curecreator in reply to radiochemistSep 3, 2009. 5:50 PM
Very nice. I agree.
megmaine says: Mar 6, 2011. 4:38 PM
Can this be done in a blender, or must it be a food processor?
Yes, I realize bananas aren't "healthy" to anyone who has to avoid sugar, because the sugar they are most loaded with, is glucose, and they are LOADED with it. But my kids are both allergic to dairy and soy, and coconut milk ice cream is $7 a pint, and if I make it at home the only coconut milk available where I live is canned, which means loaded with BPA...so this may make it reasonable in price and health, to make a birthday party with a frozen ice creamy dessert.
flyred77 says: Mar 6, 2011. 8:01 AM
Does it taste like banana ice cream? I know it sounds like a stupid question, but what if your just scared of banana ice cream? Is it a strong banana flavor? If so what is the best way to temper the banana taste, to balance it out with say vanilla?
johnny3h in reply to flyred77Mar 6, 2011. 2:56 PM
I happen to like the flavor of Bananas, but for a change in taste, I also tried this using fresh squeezed Lemon juice [about 1 lemon per cup of 'nanas] and to my taste it totally covered any flavor of Banana.  It tasted just like ice cream shop Lemon Ice Cream to me.

Next time I'm going to try Limes.  I suspect that too will cover the Banana.  Although I like the Banana flavor and not trying to cover it.  Maybe IF I get the ratios correct I can get both flavors to be recognizable.
Etitan in reply to flyred77Mar 6, 2011. 9:07 AM
It tastes like cold bananas. I've tried this plain and with a few other flavors, but the banana flavor is pretty dominant no matter what unfortunately.
spark master in reply to EtitanMar 8, 2011. 1:53 PM
thank you Etitan, another who gets it!
igninja says: Mar 6, 2011. 12:21 PM
Bananas contain tons of sugar on their own and more calories then cream. There is nothing healthy about this desert, but the strawberry.
Zachalicious in reply to igninjaMar 6, 2011. 12:54 PM
there is more to health than just calories. Personally, I am not interested in store bought ice cream from a factory which has been loaded w/ preservatives and other chemicals. I would much rather use those calories on bananas.
ducktape.mac in reply to igninjaMar 6, 2011. 12:42 PM
bananas are good for you.
amirbn says: Mar 6, 2011. 10:54 AM
it is really easy to make and comes out amazing.
try it with fresh sweet mango... a blast!
SenKat says: Mar 6, 2011. 6:57 AM
Scooch - you did it again ! NICE WORK !!
NightElectric says: Mar 3, 2011. 6:25 PM
Thank you for making something for the lactose intolerant! This looks so good and I have bananas way past their prime, I am so making this tomorrow. Such a great instructable.
Shany120 in reply to NightElectricMar 5, 2011. 4:29 PM
I know! I feel the same way because I am also lactose intolerant! :)
legendx says: Feb 8, 2011. 8:08 AM
dude thankx
HowTo-Creative says: Dec 13, 2010. 5:40 PM
Im still waiting to try it... its mouth watering..
But i was wondering a few things:
-would adding a bit of sugar make it weird in any way?
-and, if this freezing and blending magic would work on any fruit (eg, strawberries, apples~just wondering???)

-thanks ;P
Pedrojoca in reply to HowTo-CreativeJan 23, 2011. 3:10 AM
oh yeah, i forgot, avocado should work too :D
Pedrojoca in reply to HowTo-CreativeJan 23, 2011. 3:09 AM
hmmm i guess it doesn't work in every fruit. The inside must be creamy but consistent, like the banana.

Cherimoya would do it, i have a lot of those where i live :D
Nick11255 says: Dec 27, 2010. 7:32 AM
used frozen banana and 1/4 bag frozen peaches, and some milk. Perfect! much more filling than regular ice cream too. :)
FACEfun says: Jul 22, 2010. 10:41 AM
I just tried this and it turned out fantastic! I also put in some frozen blueberries to mask the overwhelming banana flavor and it worked well. The consistency was a little too 'melted ice cream' for me, but still great. :]
Dean-Bailey in reply to FACEfunOct 12, 2010. 7:54 PM
I guess you could probably try re freezing it after blending it? See how that goes. :)
FACEfun in reply to Dean-BaileyOct 13, 2010. 4:55 PM
I could've, and it probably would've worked well, but the whole point of it for me was instant gratification, and the idea of waiting any longer would've killed me. :P
Trailblazers52 says: Jun 30, 2010. 6:22 PM
I like bananas and i got it the right texture but it was weird because i didn't really like the taste. i was probably just me but i used a mixer and it came out fine. i just didnt like the taste. how can i reduce the bananaish taste and add more of an icecream flavor?
mikaelthemycologist in reply to Trailblazers52Aug 19, 2010. 5:54 PM
you can probably try adding some vanilla extract
nosugarforme says: Jun 27, 2010. 7:54 AM
I understand that the whipped up bananas need to be frozen. I want to know whether the whole bananas, b4 processing, should be frozen
nosugarforme in reply to nosugarformeJun 29, 2010. 1:36 AM
I understand now that this icecream is for eating immediately. I was thinking that it could be made, frozen and then eaten from the freezer like "real" icecream. I think that I will try freezing the made recipe - what have I got to lose? - and will let you know how it turns it. Just need to wait for my bananas to ripen a bit more. Have a good day.
scoochmaroo (author) in reply to nosugarformeJun 27, 2010. 9:04 PM
Ok, I think I understand. . . you mean either freeze the bananas before being whipped or after? I don't know, to tell you the truth. If your bananas are pre-frozen, then you get to whip them and eat immediately. I don't know how whipped and then frozen bananas work out, but I imagine there might be some unsavory crystallization that happens during the post-freezing. Worth an experiment!
ilike2make in reply to scoochmarooMar 8, 2011. 1:59 AM
WOW that was a long thread
mathews98 says: May 17, 2010. 5:03 PM
 hey i blended mine and it came out all liquidy! did i do somethin wrong!
garrett10 in reply to mathews98Jun 14, 2010. 6:37 PM
Did you freeze it?
mathews98 in reply to garrett10Jun 15, 2010. 6:24 PM
yeah i froze it and it came out as a freeze pop. also if ya want an almost like yogurt product take it out about 30 min. after putting it in your freezer.
Twinkie4sho in reply to mathews98May 23, 2010. 7:34 PM
 Me too. And it just tasted like banana ice cream. but still Really Good. But i forgot to peel the banana before i put it in the freezer and it was hard to peel. I had to use a potato peeler.LOL I love it!! =]
BretMattingly says: Jun 11, 2010. 1:01 PM
A wee drop of vanilla extract takes the banana-y edge off some. :)
skip2mylou says: Mar 30, 2010. 9:55 AM
this is really interesting, I'm trying it out right now. I froze my *yellow* bananas for 2 days, but urg i forgot to peel them, before. no worries, i mnged to get the peel off. no i dont have a blender but i do have one of those knock off magic bullet like things, i figured it was close enough. i cut up the bananas and put em in and let em blend but the pieces would always get stuck and i could hear the blade whirring but no magic... so i added 2 Tbsp of cold water. let it blend for like 4 mins, at the end i had that mashed banana like consistency. i think that may be due to the water, but i was wondering what i could do now to salvage the mix. ive got it in the freezer and i was thinking i could freeze it, cut it up and go for round two in the blender, any thoughts?
DaveySprocket says: Mar 14, 2010. 7:07 AM
I've got to try this. For years I've been freezing bananas as ice cream substitute - I cut them in half, then stick the half a banana on a popstick, freeze, and then then I have a frozen banana popsicle! So delicious! But I'm going to try this because I miss that soft creamy ice-cream texture!
special_friend says: Sep 19, 2009. 8:18 PM
yum im gonna make this for mai lactose intolerant friend. poor him... now all i need to do is find lactose intolerant chocolate : ]
Inspire Collective in reply to special_friendJan 9, 2010. 5:20 AM
carob is a great healthy chocolate substitute... We give it to our 1 year old daughter who cant process dairy so well.  Its packed with antioxidants and protein. 
shamanwhitewolf in reply to special_friendNov 13, 2009. 5:11 PM
Dark chocolate is fine.  I'm pretty badly lactose intolerant myself. 

I get around the issue with little lactaid pills.  They're lactase enzymes (replacing the ones you're friend and i don't have enough of) that help us digest the lactose sugar.  I ~always~ keep one in my pocket just in case I end up somewhere eating something with milk in it!
special_friend in reply to shamanwhitewolfNov 13, 2009. 9:20 PM
I heard the pills don't work for some people.

I have never needed them of course but i'll ask my friend if he ever heard of them before.

It must suck to be lactose intolerant huh?
shamanwhitewolf in reply to special_friendNov 14, 2009. 1:16 AM
That's true... I have heard that a few people don't have any luck with the pills.  Maybe they are not lactose intolerant but actually allergic to milk?  Or just REALLY intolerant.

Ya, it seriously sucks.  However, in a good city, it isn't hard to find things like lactose-free milk or lactose-free ice cream.  At least, here in the US.  I've never seen it in Europe.

Worse, though, is gout runs in my family.  Gout is caused by purines, which is in red meat in small amounts, but also in shrimp, spinach, and legumes (peas, beans including cocoa and coffee)!  Lucky for me, I never did OD on coffee or chocolate, but I miss the spinach and shrimp.  (My cat would tear your arm off for fresh spinach.)
BretMattingly in reply to shamanwhitewolfJun 11, 2010. 1:01 PM
There's also casein intolerance, a hard-to-digest protein in milk. It's a little bit rough on everyone's stomachs, the bacteria l. casei helps, but this might be the problem for some...especially "lactose intolerant" people who can't eat real, aged cheese (which has no lactose).
octo137 in reply to special_friendOct 18, 2009. 1:19 PM
 i am pretty sure dark chocolate. or chocolate rice milk.
MDude in reply to special_friendSep 30, 2009. 7:37 PM
Baking cocoa might work, if it mixes properly. But I don't know how hard it would be to figure out the right banana/cocoa ratio to make your dessert chocolatey without being bitter.
dungeon runner in reply to special_friendSep 28, 2009. 6:00 PM
Use carub. It's an organic chocolate substitute found in many health food stores. Pretty damn close to real chocolate too. I'm not sure how pricey it is (or if would go well with this recipe; better call in the "Will it blend?" guy.) but it's perfect for lactose intolerance. Yay plants.
special_friend in reply to dungeon runnerSep 28, 2009. 8:32 PM
wait... soooo what is carob made of? I've never tried it before... but I've heard about it. It's good for pets too right? I think....
overblast in reply to special_friendMar 7, 2011. 8:46 AM
Little known is that Carob was created by cannibals. 2 parts "Carol", and 1 part "Bob", thus, "Car-Ob". But definitely no lactose. ;)
Pants3000 in reply to special_friendSep 22, 2009. 6:17 PM
Chocolate can be lactose intolerant too? Man, it affects humans and our food! I kid, I joke. Definitely good for people who can't have regular ice cream. Must try this one out.
special_friend in reply to Pants3000Sep 22, 2009. 9:16 PM
yes such drawback in human evolution *sigh*
scoochmaroo (author) in reply to special_friendSep 22, 2009. 4:36 PM
Dark chocolate is usually dairy free!
special_friend in reply to scoochmarooSep 22, 2009. 5:07 PM
really?
*gasp*
I seriously did not know that.... and neither did my friend. * double gasp*
THANK YOU!!! i should tell him right away! * fumbles for phone*
xXRRAAWWRRXx in reply to special_friendSep 28, 2009. 6:52 PM
no, we cannot just stop at just your friend,we most tell the world!!
special_friend in reply to xXRRAAWWRRXxSep 28, 2009. 8:33 PM
YES!! *determination*
cherishcherub says: Dec 29, 2009. 7:19 AM
I tried these when the bananas were yellow cos i couldnt wait for them to go brown.

i froze them UNpeeled and they turned out OK, 

Sugarego,

i think because you mushed them bbefore hand, that encoraged the bananas to go overbrowned, therefore you got a brown one

also the reason why yours werent cold was because they were alredy mushed so all you did is stir and melt from the first place!


Pentacle says: Nov 28, 2009. 12:30 PM
Whoo! My mom will love this one. Oh yeah... I gotta try it too.. Lolz.
Poelite says: Oct 5, 2009. 10:17 PM
Baileys and espresso.... You might pull the healthfulness down some but you'll certainly get all your fixes in order. I've gotta try this, actually looks very good.
dungeon runner says: Sep 28, 2009. 6:05 PM
Put some coffee in the mix. Bam, ice cream AND caffeine. The kids will love it. I kid, i kid...
geek12597 says: Sep 28, 2009. 5:10 PM
Try adding marshmellows perhaps. Might make more fluffly and sweet!
Zem says: Sep 22, 2009. 2:32 PM
Cool. Only bad thing is... I don't like Banana's on their own. What's the taste of this? And the mixing in of other things is a good idea.
scoochmaroo (author) in reply to ZemSep 22, 2009. 4:36 PM
I agree with other commenters, that if you add anything to it, you can hardly taste the banana in it. Chocolate syrup, peanut butter, caramel, or even other fruits. Have fun!
Zem in reply to scoochmarooSep 22, 2009. 7:17 PM
Thanks for responding! I tried this earlier and its interesting XD I mixed chocolate syrup with it and it's good =)
akascout says: Sep 3, 2009. 5:28 AM
guess you have to like bananas!
redsoxdrummer in reply to akascoutSep 20, 2009. 5:36 PM
yo i hate banas and this is osom!!!! I just ad som choc. sirup to the mix
Nick11255 says: Sep 13, 2009. 7:42 AM
does it taste like vanilla ice cream? wow i feel stupid asking cause its made out of bananas but you never said
Whatsername says: Sep 5, 2009. 2:05 PM
Thanks for sharing this! So stoked to try it ~ but I don't have any brown bananas. This will be a first for trying to buy the brownest bananas at the shop!
ludionis says: Sep 1, 2009. 9:43 AM
I can say one of my all-time favorite Food Network chefs, Alton Brown, featured this in one of his episodes, and it is indeed all it claims to be and wonderful tasting to boot.
dzent1 in reply to ludionisSep 4, 2009. 12:53 PM
HOORAY, ALTON BROWN! The best.
caityjay in reply to ludionisSep 3, 2009. 11:37 AM
Alton Brown is my perfect man.
Chocolate Moose in reply to ludionisSep 3, 2009. 5:25 AM
All hail Alton Brown, the Wolfgang Puck Geekdom!
Chikara in reply to ludionisSep 2, 2009. 9:18 PM
Alton is uber.
ludionis in reply to ChikaraSep 2, 2009. 10:14 PM
AB FTW
nerdmom920 says: Sep 3, 2009. 5:53 PM
Yeah!!! Finally a healthful trick to steal one more corn-syruped concoction from my son's diet. He's 3 and won't know the diff.
ardrhi in reply to nerdmom920Sep 4, 2009. 6:27 AM
You know, they do have these things called "ice cream makers", that let you use your own wholesome ingredients to make your own ice cream, sorbet, and other delicious frozen treats. You're allowed to leave out the high-fructose corn syrup and substitute whatever sweetener you want to use. They've been available for YEARS. Ummm...decades, if you want to use the kind you put ice and rock salt in and crank by hand. There are even little sphere shaped ones you put ingredients in and have your kids play catch with or shake up, and the ice cream freezes inside. It turns making their treat into a game. The nice thing about these gadgets (I got mine pretty much free using points from my credit card) is you get to regulate what goes in your ice cream. Use soy milk or rice dream if you are philosophically against cow's milk, or can't tolerate it for health reasons.
Aserathiae says: Sep 3, 2009. 10:16 PM
you can do the same thing with canned apricots, just freeze them, then blend- it tastes exactly like sorbet
RastaMonkey says: Sep 3, 2009. 9:23 AM
what flavor of ice cream is this trying to resemble P.S. that is a very interesting idea i think ill try it right now :)
troseph in reply to RastaMonkeySep 3, 2009. 8:25 PM
Chunky monkey?
kiwirise in reply to RastaMonkeySep 3, 2009. 1:19 PM
banana flavor.
scuttlebutts in reply to kiwiriseSep 3, 2009. 8:08 PM
lol!
wufeisgirl in reply to kiwiriseSep 3, 2009. 7:35 PM
LAWLZ.

i just made some, put it *back* in the freezer to harden up a bit. Gonna try it soon!!
aidoggy says: Sep 3, 2009. 4:05 PM
This tastes wonderful I made it in just 5 minutes (after freezing) and loved it!
Creaturiste says: Sep 3, 2009. 12:40 PM
Wonders! Amazements! I've been using frozen bananas as the base for kefir smoothies for months, but that extra step of blending the bananas longer really blows my mind! Thanks so much!! Making some today.
icelandinthesun says: Sep 3, 2009. 10:59 AM
I have done this but we added some yogurt to make it creamier and we did not have to listen wot hte wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii in the food processor for 3 to 4 minutes eighter. I have also used this 2 ingredient recipe with other fruits like berries, cherries and mango.
yjoshi says: Sep 3, 2009. 9:50 AM
the banana is already in the fridge.. will come back with results in hours!!
kidNeutrino says: Sep 3, 2009. 8:14 AM
I do this trick too. My hack is to a little chocolate milk in the blend. it is the BOMB! something like a chocolate dipped frozen banana shoot! I wish I was home right now to make one!
Sweetly confused says: Sep 2, 2009. 1:49 AM
Wow.. gr8 recipe.. tnx 4 it!
thomas.jtux says: Sep 1, 2009. 9:53 AM
well its good Actualy delicious
insanepotato says: Sep 1, 2009. 6:31 AM
can u scoop it if u blend then freeze?
Very Keri says: Sep 1, 2009. 6:12 AM
This is so simple, it blows my mind. I've frozen fruit before, but it never occurred to me to freeze bananas. Even if I don't like the "ice cream" (Who am I kidding? I'll love it!) you have still drastically enhanced my smoothie experience.
JoWinchester says: Sep 1, 2009. 5:30 AM
I'm definitely gonna try this one. So simple!
todd4551 says: Aug 31, 2009. 7:46 AM
Going to have to try that this afternoon.
JackJames says: Aug 31, 2009. 6:20 AM
Sounds really good but I guess you could not make some, box it up and send it to me..............................Oh well, back tp the fried peach pies!
Pro

Get More Out of Instructables

Already have an Account?

close

PDF Downloads
As a Pro member, you will gain access to download any Instructable in the PDF format. You also have the ability to customize your PDF download.

Upgrade to Pro today!