I have tried each of these on myself and they all work just as good as any eye makeup remover I have bought at the drug store. Try them out for yourself and let me know how they work for you!
Step 1: Avocados
For this I just took a q-tip and swabbed the avocado. You don't need to get a chunk of avocado on the q-tip, just coat it in the oil from the avocado.
Step 2: No-Tears Baby Shampoo
Just add a drop of baby shampoo (I like Johnson's Baby Shampoo!) to a cotton pad or swab to remove eye makeup.
I bought this bottle and it has lasted a couple years! What a great deal if you consider how much money you pay for eye makeup remover!
Step 3: Hair Conditioner
You already have it in your bathroom...
Just a little dab of hair conditioner does the job!
Step 4: Shortening
Its just vegetable oil and it keeps your skin soft. When your makeup remover runs out just run to your kitchen for some makeshift eye makeup remover. I used Crisco brand shortening.
Step 5: Petrolum Jelly
A little bit goes a long way!
Petrolum Jelly is a safe way to remove your water proof makeup. Use just a small amount to remove your eye makeup then go ahead and dab some on your lips!
Step 6: Grapeseed and Castor Oil
Step 7: Jojoba Oil
1 part Jojoba Oil
2 parts Water
Try this sustainably friendly makeup remover! It is non-allergenic so it is perfect for use on eyes. It can also be used to remove any other makeup.
Step 8: Vegetable Oil Medley
Step 9: Final Test - Which produces the best results?
I put 8 eyeliner marks on my arm (first picture). And then I dipped a cotton swap in each mixture and lightly rubbed it on the eyeliner ten times. You can still see the eyeliner for each remover in the second picture because I did not wipe away the the residue after I applied it (which you would normally do with any eye makeup remover).