Advanced Brushless Power Systems for Small Electric Scooters

 by teamtestbot
Featured
Thesis: It is feasible to construct a very powerful, efficient, and lightweight personal mobility device using hobby-grade equipment for under $400. This amount can be drastically less depending on the individual requirements of the builder. This is possible only through the extremely high power density of modern battery, motor, and controller technologies and the extremely low cost thereof in the radio control model hobbies. The advantages of constructing your own personal electric vehicle include educational experience, the ability to self-service, and the ability to customize to your own preferences at will.

I'm a builder and tinkerer by nature, and am always on the lookout for cool parts, devices which can be made better with cool parts, or some times both. During the summer months of 2007, I happened upon a chance to work with both.

As a bit of backstory, I build and compete fighting robots - as in Battlebots and Robot Wars - and as other builders of robots and non-robots may know, the search for the perfect motor is neverending. In June of 2007, I went on a trip to China to visit my aging grandparents... and hunt for parts. As RC hobbyists may know, China is the prime source of the vast majority of model equipment these days - big-branded or not.

So it was in a small hobby shop in a neighborhood of Beijing that I spotted this large outrunner motor. The only word to describe it was "assnormous" - according to the info card, it was a "7050/6" type motor. Translation: 70mm diameter stator, 50mm stator length, 6 turns per stator pole. Real translation: Massive power. It claimed 6 kilowatts maximum, but as overrrated as many hobby parts tend to be, I didn't trust the rating. Many high-quality BLDC motors of this size range can produce up to 10-11 kilowatts of power. They also cost a cool grand or two, not the $100 I ended up getting this motor for. Here's one example.

However, that didn't prevent me from impulsively buying it, since it's bigger than every other brushless motor I had at the time anyway.

Back in the US, I had to figure out what on earth to do with such a gigantic motor. I had no controller for it, no battery system that could possibly feed it, and no application. My personal hovercraft project was ditched a year before. I could not shove this motor into a 12-pound class combat 'bot.

It took a lucky trip to a local flea market to get this project going. On that day, I passed by the usual vendors selling toys when I noticed one had a small electric scooter, about the size of a large Razor scooter.

And it all went downhill from there.

(Update 15 January 2009) Hey guys, I have 31,000 views and 21 rates? Please rate whether you liked it or not, because that provides me with feedback! As always, comments and questions are welcome. Also, I am preparing a writeup on the wheelmotor scooter, but want to get my motor theory a bit more inline before I finish it.

 
Remove these adsRemove these ads by Signing Up

Step 1: Select your vehicle

General considerations Just about any wheeled object you pick up these days can be hacked, modded, or boosted to yield a higher power-to-weight ratio. What is particularly exciting about electric vehicles is that this process is comparatively easy, part of the reason why I am eagerly awaiting mainstream electric cars, having reached the age of unlimited desire in vehicular performance.

The basic technology of almost all small EVs - scooter, bike, or car - these days is lead-acid batteries and large DC motors. While the heavy build of these parts increases their relative durability compared to a lighter but more powerful part, performance is often left to be desired.

Hence, most small EVs you may find are amenable to power mods. I focused specifically on an electric scooter since.. well, I had one, but also because they tend to be small and extremely portable. One example of a commercial "mini-electric scooter" is the Roth Motorboard 2000XR, which, while extremely compact, has the performance of much larger vehicles.

Larger electric scooters such as the steel tube-framed pneumatic-wheel types can stand a more massive power system than what you can fit on a Razor-size scooter, but weigh comparatively more. Bicycles, electric or not, are another common conversion base. Conversions aside, you can build an electric powertrain into whatever you please.

Conceptually, however different the physical manifestation, the operation of the vehicles are the same, as shown in the diagram. EVs are relatively simple things at their very basic level.

In the end, the kind of power system and performance you will get is a function of how much money you want to spend and what your goal is. Something to move you around campus or town won't cost as much as the next Killacycle.

My personal conversion was an electric scooter whose primary intended application was as a campusmobile for college. It is a Sharper Image Electric X2 model scooter I bought nth-hand for $10, with leaking batteries, no charger, and a slipping belt drive. It was pretty much perfect.
1-40 of 175Next »
MustangGuy says: Mar 11, 2013. 5:08 PM
Can you please tell me what model that scooter is? It seems like the perfect platform for a carry on electric scooter.
ebikegp says: Dec 15, 2012. 6:45 PM
Hi I'm a complete newbie to this site so was wondering if anyone knows if & how you can contact the Author of this paper?
verdict26 says: Aug 14, 2011. 9:49 AM
Given your comments about the size of the scooter and the concern about the center of gravity (basically you're getting thrown off)....Have you thought about the Razor A5 Lux. I have two of them and work great for adults. I weigh 180 lbs and it works flawlessly. I imagine there will still be some handling issues, but given the larger wheels....I speculate it will improve.

http://www.razor.com/us/products/scooters/specs.html?name=A5+Lux
XylophonicMonkey says: Jul 19, 2009. 5:36 PM
Why not try to replicate (or just swipe) the throttle system on a corded power drill? (or similar device) Unless your insanely trigger happy you'll get a much smoother ride. (take a look at one of the more quality committed brands, some of the lesser admired brands simply use really sadly wired mosfets and lead heatsinks. :( Needless to say removing that nice stageless motor control.)
Pale_Flyer in reply to XylophonicMonkeyAug 28, 2010. 9:27 PM
i think the throttle he has is pretty similar...
arduinoe in reply to Pale_FlyerJul 13, 2011. 1:45 PM
Drill motor throttles are only capable of a 15 maybe 20 amps at around 12 volts. and that is a half bridge DC brushed motor controller.

The motors hes using draw far far far much more power. are brushless requiring a 3 phase AC speed controller.

It just wont work.
alfredhenriksen says: Oct 22, 2010. 11:07 AM
LOL! I loved your instructables. I want to build one! Maybe with max 6miles/hr, not 25! I have a 30 mm outrunner (gearing down 10-30:1) , but maybe it's too small? For 3-4 month ago somebody threw away a similar scooter as yours, but the backweel was ruined. Then I found a nice round wheel for a month ago... And then I saw this article... AAARGH!
funkybassman105 says: Sep 3, 2010. 2:41 PM
where did you acquire your motor and batteries?
Pale_Flyer says: Aug 28, 2010. 9:24 PM
you might be able to run the wires up the handle and across the t-bar for some protection...
Pale_Flyer says: Aug 28, 2010. 9:19 PM
that looks like you said to be a very brute force... but it also looks like you know what you are doing with components and a soldiering iron. I am thinking about doing something similar, and using a parallax BS2 system for control. i just haven't found a motor that would have enough torque. i want to find it somewhere that it comes to me from a store i can physically walk into. I might try the local home center...
Radioactive_Legos says: Aug 10, 2010. 10:33 PM
Very Nice!! I'm considering doing something similar (which is how I re-discovered this 'ible) with some sort of scooter - either the kind with the little bike tires, a Razor style with larger wheels, or using a broken electric scooter as a base. Anyway, I will use a 245Kv 63mm x 64mm BL outrunner and 70A 10S LiPo ESC (both from HobbyPartz, a good US-based chinese stuff distributor), although I will probably end up using 3 12V SLAs to save money at the cost of efficiency... Not sure what capacity I will need, though, what sorts of runtimes do you get with your 3000mAh cells? Thanks and great instructable!
drhoff says: Aug 27, 2009. 12:41 PM
Great Instructable! Very informative and well written. What was the cost of the battery pack? I didn't see it in the cost breakdown. Also, as a fellow combat robot builder (just antweights, but they count too ; D), I would love to check out your bots. Do you have a link?
leowhite in reply to drhoffJun 6, 2010. 1:00 AM
I'd like to know this aswell
drhoff in reply to drhoffAug 27, 2009. 3:25 PM
I have another question i forgot to ask earlier. How many rpm / v is that motor supposed to put out?
KT Gadget says: Apr 3, 2010. 12:50 PM
 Great instructable, I am now researching what would be a good substitute for the batteries (looking at lighter LiFePO4 or high capacity NiCads).

Question though, what is the run time of your system? I am going to be running a 24V with the battery capacity being around 6-9AH. Reason is I have a scooter I am converting to an electric skateboard, but I want to make something thats lighter than 40 lbs (due to the Lead-Acid Batteries, capacity at 13AH I think) that I can haul around school.
featheredfrog says: Dec 3, 2009. 2:59 PM
This is easily the best-written instructible I've ever read.  VERY WELL DONE.  Is the scooter still running?
struckbyanarrow says: Nov 28, 2009. 3:45 PM
i was digging through my garage and found my old razor electric scooter, i remember getting it new for a hundred dollars and it goes 15mph and the front wheel has an innertube, so you can go over large cracks.
Antleredguy says: Nov 25, 2009. 10:52 PM
 Does anyone know of an instructable that gives a total introduction to motors, controllers, batteries, and the like? It would be so helpful!
Thanks,
Nick
ElvenChild says: Nov 5, 2009. 10:27 PM
 did you by any chance call it the bwd scooter shown on the mittech website
teamtestbot (author) in reply to ElvenChildNov 5, 2009. 11:06 PM
The BWD scooter is a derivative of this build by a summer engineering program at MIT. I played mostly a consultant role.
robomaniac says: Oct 12, 2009. 2:16 PM


Here is my scooter! I can go up to 25mph ( 40.3km/h)!!
I got a 1480W brushless motor with 33.3V lithium battery.

Here is a picture of the scooter with GPS showing 40.3km/h
www.jeromedemers.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/scooter_speed_record_-002-545x409.jpg

Here is the post on ES
http://endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=12&t=13315

I also have my own website that is dedicated to the scooter.
www.JeromeDemers.com

I will be making a new video of the scooter going 25mph. Really fun and dangerous!

I also notice that you will be modifying a Xootr Street push scooter. I am really jalous!
I will be working on a new version of that scooter using 5 to 6 inch pneumatic wheels.

Keep up the great work! Can't wait to see you next projects!

ps- I can got faster then 25mph, since I am driving a 37V motor with 33V! :)

scooter_speed_record_-002-545x409.jpg
mattccc says: Oct 1, 2009. 7:05 PM
will you post a video of it working
bowmaster says: Aug 31, 2009. 1:26 PM
I would take the current system you have and pop it on to a mountain board. That would definitely solve the terrain issue. Check out MBS mountain boards here: http://www.mbs.com/ and this instructable: http://www.instructables.com/id/Electric-Mountain-Board/?ALLSTEPS
C7mb says: Aug 27, 2009. 10:35 AM
HAHAHAHAHHA Charles!!! Our scooters better.......
UbuntuNinja says: Aug 24, 2009. 11:09 AM
Does anyone know anything about using super capacitors (electrolytic double layer) instead of batteries?
markiscool says: Jul 10, 2009. 12:35 PM
how do you build the circuit for the different power outputs??? please help me
1-0_1-6 says: Jun 24, 2009. 12:14 PM
If I used one of these motors, maybe a bigger one; will it work for a "Bladez electric scooter? I sort of don't feel comfortable going 25 mph+ on a razor compared to a bladez scooter. Thanks and great work!
Junkyardmaster14 says: Jun 12, 2009. 9:40 AM
what type of brushless motor you used on your scooter? how much torque and rpm?
brokengun says: Mar 12, 2009. 7:40 AM
Excellent instructable, great read! Thanks for providing all those links of where you bought stuff. This is what an instructable should be helpful, fun and freakin' awesome!
teamtestbot (author) says: Mar 4, 2009. 9:27 AM
Site's back up! Now with an all new build report documenting the rebuild of the Razor scooter.
zabac70 says: Feb 26, 2009. 4:45 PM
Well done indeed! I've tried to see the other pages (Snuffles & Snuflles reloaded) , but , somehow , server sends message : forbidden...I was trying to find out how you've put a motor into the rear wheel , and how you built it (the motor - if it is what you did).
teamtestbot (author) in reply to zabac70Feb 26, 2009. 10:51 PM
I bum server space from a friend, who incidentally recently moved servers, and I've been a bit lazy/slow/unmotivated to get the site reloaded. I have it all backed up, including posts...
swbluto says: Feb 11, 2009. 11:06 PM
Thanks partially to this inspiration, I finally built the electric scooter of my dreams! Its build page (with warts and all) is at http://endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=12&t=7638&p=131721#p131721 . A few things I did differently - I ended up going with one with pneumatic tires in a common size so there'd be more suspension which I know from experience becomes more critical the faster you go. I also created my own signal board which converts the signal from a regular e-bike throttle to a servo pulse the Phoenix-85 understands. I also added capacitors on the input to ensure the controller won't fail, current limiting so that I could use my existing lower-C-rate LiFePO4 (I want to use it until it dies! Which, by my calculation, will be in 2-4 years.), customized current ramping and also temperature sensing on the motor and controller to protect them from thermal damage. I also ended up doing a battery mod to drop the battery voltage of the nominally 48 volt battery. I plan to add a customized LCD and I'm currently on the look-out for cheap, available serial LCDs(the black on green kind. Apparently, SparkFun is always out.).

Also, the batteries, custom circuitry and controller are in a back-pack. This keeps the expensive electronics relatively more secure, the scooter lighter(It currently weighs about 20 pounds) and "smaller" and helps shield the electronics from the weather.

Predictions -
Range: 10+ miles. Likely around 12 or so, but I'll need to measure it.
Top Speed: 27 according to my simulator, but I'll be limiting it to 20 since anything faster doesn't really feel safe. Top speed up a 7% hill? 15 mph.

When I get my battery repaired either tomorrow or the day after, I'll be sure to report actual information.

BTW, I think MIT's computer-science/electrical engineering program is so much better than University of Washington's(The university I'm currently attending). Most of the theory I learned from OCW's 6.002 seems to be at least "that's 300/400 level!" according to my current "intro to electrical engineering" professor(i.e., 3+ sequenced classes away) and these classes learn in 5 weeks what took MIT 1.5.
teamtestbot (author) in reply to swblutoFeb 12, 2009. 6:02 AM
Wow, that's some pretty sophisticated stuff. I bet the current limiting also helps prevent Funny Car Syndrome. I always want to put additional electronics on my stuff past the bare minimum to get it moving, but the whole "it works, don't touch it..." always gets me. FWIW, I see you-ve been to my site - I never fixed that ball of wire that was the signal driver on RazEr. Totally am not cut out for EECS :')
phugedaboudet says: Feb 10, 2009. 1:30 PM
this is my new fav EV instructable. I'd gotten close to a design uisng some huge kW brushless motors but was having trouble with transmission parts. Yours had the link to where I can get pulleys and belts able to handle the load. Now I just gotta find a big motor like that for the price you paid. Probably not gonna find it on this side of the Pacific without significant markup, huh?
teamtestbot (author) in reply to phugedaboudetFeb 10, 2009. 9:59 PM
Have you tried United Hobbies/HobbyCity? They have great deals on obnoxiously large motors... Or, you could roll your own.
trumpkin says: Jul 16, 2008. 7:53 AM
do you have any motor and battery recomendations?
nicholast in reply to trumpkinNov 1, 2008. 2:33 AM
If at all possible use brushless motors, they are much more efficient than brushed motors. And if you can afford it the best choice for battery's is Li-Ion, they have the best energy density for weight, they do however have a rather low power density. That shouldn't be an issue on a scooter
teamtestbot (author) in reply to nicholastNov 1, 2008. 6:01 AM
The best choice currently is not the usual "lithium ion", which is lithium cobalt or lithium manganese (the latter half referring to the battery's cathode chemistry), but lithium iron phopsphate, also known as "A123" cells after the company that made them popular. Your average laptop battery is still LiCo/LiMn, and they are indeed not suitable for high current discharge. LiFePO4 has a slightly lower energy density, but extremely high power density, which you'd want for high performance.
phugedaboudet in reply to teamtestbotFeb 10, 2009. 1:25 PM
+1 on the A123 recommendation. Good enough for the "Killacycle", good enough for me. Not only do they handle high current discharge like you mentioned, but handle a deep drain pretty well too. Unlike LiPO's that will be ruined if you flatten them.
1-40 of 175Next »
Pro

Get More Out of Instructables

Already have an Account?

close

PDF Downloads
As a Pro member, you will gain access to download any Instructable in the PDF format. You also have the ability to customize your PDF download.

Upgrade to Pro today!