Instructables

Ale Bread

Picture of Ale Bread
it took me several tries to perfect this recipe, but I've finally got it right where I wanted it. The best Ale Bread I've ever had the pleasure of noshing.
 
Remove these adsRemove these ads by Signing Up

Step 1: Overview

Picture of Overview
It took me 133 days to get up the nerve to face the dough, which had failed so completely to be dough-like on my last attempt that I described it at the time by saying:

"...And still the dough stuck to hands, mixer parts and floured counter tops like a living thing fighting for its life..."

But in the end, I beat the bloody thing!

In the days since June, I've occasionally searched for other recipes. For the most part, I found the same recipe repeated, but then I came across this post at Farmgirl Fare , and when I compared it to a comment left on my original post, I realized where everything had gone wrong!

For one thing, the recipe I had didn't call for enough flour. The ones I was finding now called for an additional cup. Secondly the first recipe we'd tried didn't call for any sugar, which meant the yeast in the beer didn't have anything to munch on. No yeast growth, no rise, I had to try this again!

And it was good.

Ale Bread Adapted from a recipe at Farmgirl Fare and a recipe I've made before, with a twist of inspiration and a pint of stout

Step 2: Ingredients

Picture of Ingredients
Bread mix:

  • 3 cups unbleached flour
  • 1 tbsp.sugar
  • 1 good pinch kosher salt
  • 1 tbsp. baking powder
  • 1 bunch finely chopped scallions
  • 1 cup grated sharp cheddar cheese
  • 12 oz. beer (I used Shiner bock, a dark German beer)

Glaze (optional):

  • 1 egg
  • 2 tbsp. water

Your photo makes this look incredible. I do have a question though, It appears you allow no time for the yeast to do its thing. You bake it without letting it rise and the soda acts as the leavening. At least it appears that way. Have you tried letting it sit for awhile and letting the yeast in the beer start working on the sugar and starch? I'm going to bake some tomorrow, and I'm going to let it sit and see if it will rise at all prior to baking. I'll let ya know.
The recipe does not call for any proofing time, so no, I've nevr let it sit and "do it's thang". It's basically a quickbread, but it might help to let the yeast work for a bit. Let me know what you find out!
I tried letting proof for an hour or so, and got no noticeable rise from the bread. I wasn't able to let it cool for long, and it it delicious! I used Samuel Adams Lager, and it worked great. I'm going to try making a starter with flour, salt, sugar and beer, just to see if it will rise over the course of several hours, or maybe overnight. I'll let ya know how it works, and if it's good, maybe I'll make it my first 'ible.
You can do this, but you MUST use a live beer.
Unless it is an unpasturized beer, the yeast is dead, so unless it is a zombie or vampire beer it cannot rise from the dead.
ajohnson1534 years ago
I love the looks of this recipe, I do howeer have one question. Could one substitute all purpose flour instead of unbleached flour and achieve basically the same result? I only ask because we mainly use the all purpose variety around my house and I don't want to go buying 5 lbs of flour if I am only going to use it in one recipe. Let me know.
Unbleached flour usually refers to unbleached, all-purpose flour. Ideally all of your all-purpose flour is unbleached. The bleaching process generally isn't good for you.

So. Yes. For future reference, you can use any all-purpose flour for this recipe. You could also use bread flour.
seansippo4 years ago
does the beer effect the flavor at all? if so i would like to try it with some of my hard cider i have.
suckrpnch4 years ago
 It seems like people are unclear. This bread doesn't use yeast at all. It isn't about the yeast in the beer (lager), it is about the baking powder. That is why it is a quick bread and no proofing is needed.
dmt4 years ago
Re: yeast-based rising --

Beer that crosses state lines (or is imported) is required by law to be pasteurized. Find a local microbrewery or brew your own so that you can do this with "living" beers that still have active yeast. Then you may be able to avoid using baking soda with a little proofing time.
macrumpton dmt4 years ago
I suppose you could try adding some brewer's yeast from the healthfood store to make up for the dead beer yeast. Isn't that why it is called brewer's yeast?
ah, beer bread is something from childhood i dearly miss, let alone made from my favorite beer! 
Woody714 years ago
Made this bread today and substituted jalapenos for the green onions...turned out great!
slaughter5 years ago
do you have to use an ale or could a lager pass
slaughter, shiner bock is actually lager not ale at all, so lager works fine from the looks of it.
suckrpnch5 years ago
I would definitely like to adapt this recipe to my own bread recipe with yeast. I have actually added wort after making beer, but since I also added chocolate malt grains (dark roasted) the flavor was lost, but with the cheese and all sounds fantastic. I will try both yeast and baking soda to compare...
quinault5 years ago
I though baking soda and yeast is the same thing all the time. My god! La mama cucina
rolandblais6 years ago
I am going to try this today - looks delicious. For those asking about yeast, I believe this bread is getting it's rise from the baking powder, if I remember my food science (go Alton!) correctly. It's a quickbread, as cookingbytheseatofmy pants indicated.
Yup, it's a quckbread, and a good one at that. The basic recipe could be used for anything from banana bread to ... Well, whatever, really. Just substitute milk for the beer
t.rohner6 years ago
Looks great, i will try one in this direction, but i will do it with yeast. (Baking powder doesn't belong into bread doughs, IMHO) If you took Shiner Bock, it's a Lager not a Ale bread...(just nitpicking...) keep on baking
matthewabel6 years ago
Is the yeast in beer actually still alive? I thought beer was pasteurized and that killed the yeast. If so, it wouldn't really do it's "thang," but I imagine the bubbliness has a big effect. My ma makes beer bread with basically self-rising flour and beer. She likes the bread made with a Corona type beer as it is sweeter than, say, a Guiness type beer. It's very interesting how different beer yields different breads.
nbpendley6 years ago
from the Shiner website: "These unique and full flavored beers, brewed in the heart of Texas, are sure to provide you with an experience unlike any other. Open a Shiner beer today and enjoy!"

The bread was good!
There were many German immigrants in Texas in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The notion of a German beer in Texas is within reason.
I'm well aware of that, which is why I use German stye ales in most of my published recipes. It's an "Ode to Texas" if just in my own small way.
cookingbytheseatofmypants (author) 6 years ago
nbpendly, Glad you liked it! I'm actually planning on making some this weekend. Lost Moai, I was thinking of trying it with the Hefewiezen, also with their Dunkelweisen, for a deeper flavor. One of my blog readers suggeste adding in a bit of feta cheese as well, which sounds pretty good to me!
Lost Moai6 years ago
I love making bread and you're drinking my brand of beer. Have you tried making it with their Hefewiezen? I bet their new Shiner Black would be good in it too. I need to get baking.
cookingbytheseatofmypants (author) 6 years ago
GorrilazMiko, From now on I will be posting more than one image. I was actually "recruited" by someone related to the site, and this recipe was requested, so here it is!
Yum! Looks good! By the way, you should post more pictures instead of just one, but it looks good. ;-)
cookingbytheseatofmypants (author) 6 years ago
nnygamer, It would probably work, but you might need just a bit more flour for that
nnygamer6 years ago
We used to make a beer bred similar to this (without the cheese or onions) to use as a pizza crust. It was better then any store bought or restaurant pizza crust. I just wish I could find it again, your's might be close enough to try!