Picture of Best Peppermint Patties Ever

Step 1: Gather and Prepare your Ingredients

Picture of Gather and Prepare your Ingredients

frogcar2 years ago
I made these and they are excellent. I ended up with 49 patties. I used two 220 gram chocolate bars (about 15 & 1/2 ounces) and had a little chocolate left over. I will be making these for Mother's day gifts. The chocolate set very firmly, so there was no need to refrigerate them.
Voted for you! These look amazing.
rachellehcar (author)  enterusername2 years ago
Jace_Wolfe5 months ago

For some reason I can't see the ingredients or the instructions. All I see are the headings to the steps and the pictures. I would very much like to make these so if someone could message back with the instructions and ingredients list that would be much appreciated. Thank you!

Hello, for some reason I cant find the actual INSTRUCTIONS for this thing... Its just five pictures and the headlines of the steps. No recipe, no anything, really. and no matter what i do, I cant seem to be able to get the recipe to show up. I have used this one before and it was absolutely amazing, but that was almost a year ago and i cant seem to be able to recall how to do it properly. Please help.
ecrouch2 years ago
Thanks for this instructable! I tried this tonight. Here's what I learned. I had to use 3.5 tsp of peppermint extract to get the pepperminty taste I preferred instead of the 2.5 tsp. Also, I had to add an extra 1/4 cup of evaporated milk. Otherwise, the mixture was too dry to work with. I think next time I'll use just 1 lb of powdered sugar and I think everything else will balance out. Also, I had trouble dipping my patties into the chocolate because they would instantly soften from their frozen state into an unmanageable goo. My wife suggested I brush the chocolate on and that worked well. Thanks again for this awesome recipe!
rachellehcar (author)  ecrouch2 years ago
You're welcome. You may want to try adding just a little more milk at a time. You want the mixture to be very firm. If it is thinner, it is much more difficult to dip them in the chocolate before they melt. The more practice you have, the easier it will be to dip them.
bird1234572 years ago
You just made me a happy woman! These look easy AND delicious! Plus you know what is in them! If I wasn't missing the milk, I would try them this second!
rachellehcar (author)  thebeatonpath2 years ago
Thanks! I sometimes replace the evaporated milk with 1/8 cup regular sugar and 1/4 cup regular milk.
Thanks! I had the same problem with missing milk.
"Combine" was the hardest step. A pasty mixer works well. A wooden spoon does not.

I started making 1" balls, saw I might get only 20, so switched to 1 oz. balls (digital kitchen scale!) and made 27. They looked big when flattened, so I cut them in half after freezing to make 54 instead. Smaller patties means more surface. That, plus my generous dipping, meant adding more chocolate.

Next time, I might roll the mix out flat and cut it into squares for better size control.
peppermint patties.jpg
rachellehcar (author)  ephraimephraim2 years ago
I just mixed the ingredients with a fork - just rolled out balls by hand and flattened them on the cookie sheet. Hope they turned out well!
justbel72 years ago
yay for Aldi products!
About how many does this make? I think I see 20 on your sheet, but there could be another row out of the picture.

I'm drooling just looking at these. I can't eat a lot of commercial candy because of allergy issues, so I haven't had a peppermint patty in about twenty years.
rachellehcar (author)  ephraimephraim2 years ago
This recipe makes about 45.
you shop at Aldi's! :)
I haven't tried these, but they look great. Thanks.
SailorSue422 years ago
Wow! These look great...what "tool" exactly are you using to dip these? I have visions of loosing multiple patties into the warm chocolate, perhaps a smallish slotted spoon?
rachellehcar (author)  SailorSue422 years ago
Thanks! I used a sugar cube server, but have in the past used a fork.
these look great!!
john33472 years ago
Who gets to lick the bowl after the chocolate dipping?
armitige32 years ago
Someone shops at Aldi! Best store ever; love it!

These look divine. I'm going to have to try them.
rachellehcar (author)  armitige32 years ago
Thanks! Aldi rocks.