Cheap Acoustic Simulator (Crossfeed) for Headphones

 by faxwork
Featured
DSCF0678b.jpg
Hi! Welcome to my second instructable! Don't forget to rate and comment! :D

First off, what is an "acoustic simulator"?

It can be anything to simulate the effect of being in a room, creating an effect of open space, or even give the illusion of hearing sounds from different directions. This is usually achieved through software. Results vary, as there is coloration to the sound and the simulations can be very invasive to listening.

Unlike software implementations, what I will show here is a simple hardware solution to get rid of the "in-head" effect that headphones have. It is not designed to give the illusion that you're in an auditorium with reverb. Rather, it is designed to simulate the feeling of hearing audio in front of you. Its purpose is to improve the soundstage.

The main goal is to reduce fatigue and make headphone listening natural and pleasant.

In this instructable, I will show my build of a Linkwitz crossfeed. This particular design was modified by Chu Moy, the person responsible for the famous "cmoy" headphone amp design. I take no credit for this design, only my simple modifications.

 
Remove these adsRemove these ads by Signing Up

Step 1: What is a crossfeed? (Theory)

When you hear sounds panned hard right/left with headphones, you don't hear anything in your other ear. In real life, you always hear sound with both ears. A person speaks to the right of you. Do you only hear them with your right ear?

In reality, you're hearing with both. Your brain recieves signals from both ears and interprets the direction from which the sound is coming from. You may be hearing to the right of you, but your brain also interprets if the sound is close, far,  in front of, or behind you. When you listen to audio with headphones, this directional information is lost.

To remedy this, we welcome the crossfeed. A crossfeed circuit bleeds the left and right channels just a bit to give off  that lost sense of direction. While it does not give the illusion of surround sound, it does give you the feeling of listening to audio from speakers in front of you rather than through headphones on your ears.

Music from live performances and orchestras sound particularly good with a crossfeed. Mono recordings and music that generally sits "in the middle" will not benefit from a crossfeed much, or at all.

kweinberg says: May 21, 2012. 1:11 PM
This was awesome! My first real DIY soldering project and it works and sounds great with no troubleshooting! I had to use 1k instead of 910 resistors and electrolytic and mylar caps, but it doesn't seem to have messed anything up too bad. I'm looking forward to the day when I understand enough to start my own circuits like this. Thanks for the great instructable!
faxwork (author) in reply to kweinbergMay 21, 2012. 2:28 PM
Thanks!

You should be careful with electrolytic capacitors being in the audio path because they have a polarity associated with them. AC signals like audio are moving positive and then negative and then back. Over time, electrolytic capacitors "go bad" when the polarity is backwards. It might not be a problem now, but maybe in the future it will be.

Electrolytic capacitors are mostly used for power sections in a circuit that require filtering. An example is on a power supply to remove noise.

It's pretty awesome that it worked on the first try. That almost never happens. :D

Good luck on your future projects.
lindenturn says: Sep 29, 2011. 1:50 PM
This is a really good project. You did a nice job putting it together. Just as a thought people might want to use one of the "bread boards" that has solder pads instead of the cardboard to make it a little more sturdy.
faxwork (author) in reply to lindenturnNov 7, 2011. 8:08 PM
Thanks for the nice words. So far, after extended use, none of the parts have become loose. Although this is the case, I would still suggest using some sort of board if it's available as my method is only good if you have little to nothing in the way of parts.
nshabbir says: Sep 8, 2011. 3:59 AM
someone plz send me circuit diagram of this equipment
faxwork (author) in reply to nshabbirSep 21, 2011. 8:18 AM
You'll find a link to the original design and an image of my modified version in step four.
onlinemastering says: Mar 14, 2011. 1:50 AM
This is an excellent project, one of the best on instructables (still I am an audio geek i woudl say that). Perfect and highly useful prooject for beginning electronics. Thanks for sharing this, really enjoyed the read.

SafeandSound
mastering services
faxwork (author) in reply to onlinemasteringApr 1, 2011. 5:39 PM
I'm not sure if it's one of the best Instructables, but thanks for the comment. :)

Currently I'm trying to come up with another simple electronics project revolving around audio. If anybody stumbles across this comment, don't be afraid to give ideas. :)
7wist says: Dec 22, 2010. 5:08 PM
Thanks a ton man, I just soldered this up my my dads Christmas present :)
faxwork (author) in reply to 7wistDec 24, 2010. 2:03 AM
What a great gift idea! I hadn't thought of that.

Tell me if he likes it. :]
killerjackalope says: Nov 15, 2010. 6:37 AM
Great build, I wonder it it's easier to have a physical crossfeed or not, with digital music being to ubiquitous. Though I suppose a couple of hours building this would be way faster than fiddling with every song...
faxwork (author) in reply to killerjackalopeNov 15, 2010. 11:31 AM
I've noticed that many software crossfeeds can be invasive and can color the sound a bit. I built mine in about an hour, not including time spent designing the layout. :D

If you want more options, consider looking in to switching between different R1 resistors. This will enable you to adjust the soundstage to your choosing on the fly.

Thanks for the comment. :)
killerjackalope in reply to faxworkNov 15, 2010. 12:36 PM
Good to know, I may well build one depending on my ever changing sound setup, really taken to using my little bluetooth speaker about the house and just bringing it with me but this would be great for the bus etc, using big cans seems to make the issue more apparent than leaky earbuds...
faxwork (author) in reply to killerjackalopeNov 15, 2010. 12:48 PM
It's really great to have on the go, but the only problem I have now is finding a short 3.5mm cable to use it with. Having a cable from my sound source, between the crossfeed and amp, and my headphones is a bit much. :/
killerjackalope in reply to faxworkNov 15, 2010. 2:48 PM
Might be better with a small cable soldered direct to the board rather than a jack.

You get short cables in audio shops, also handsfree kits etc often have odd length cables with them if it's any help...
faxwork (author) in reply to killerjackalopeNov 15, 2010. 3:05 PM
I'll consider the idea. I just hate that it feels so "permanent". :p

Maybe I'll replace my input with RCA jacks instead. I see RCA to 3.5mm adapters everyhere.
killerjackalope in reply to faxworkNov 15, 2010. 3:29 PM
How about wiring on a little cable but keeping the input too? Just a couple of inches of cable you could slide away when you're using the input...
faxwork (author) in reply to killerjackalopeNov 16, 2010. 10:11 AM
Sounds good, but I would still need to find a cable to tear apart. :|
killerjackalope in reply to faxworkNov 17, 2010. 4:28 AM
Eh there's always a rub, old headphone cord? Though the wires are a little fragile...
Lexx217 says: Nov 15, 2010. 2:11 PM
thanks you :)
faxwork (author) in reply to Lexx217Nov 15, 2010. 2:31 PM
Welcome. :p
Pro

Get More Out of Instructables

Already have an Account?

close

PDF Downloads
As a Pro member, you will gain access to download any Instructable in the PDF format. You also have the ability to customize your PDF download.

Upgrade to Pro today!