3 Simple Ways to
Share What You Make

With Instructables you can share what you make with the world — and tap into an ever-growing community of creative experts.

PhotosPhotos

Share one or more photos of a project, recipe, or whatever you've made, quickly and easily.

Step by StepStep-By-Step

Share your step-by-step photos with text instructions of what you made so others can do it too!

VideoVideo

Share your how-to video. You'll need your embed code from a video site such as YouTube.

Clean Silver Tarnish with Simple Electrochemistry

video Clean Silver Tarnish with Simple Electrochemistry
How to restore old silver with aluminum foil or a battery by electrochemistry.

Old silver is often tarnished by a thin layer of silver sulfide that appears as a brown color. The silver sulfide can be electrochemically converted back into pure silver if a negative charge is applied.

To do this, first make a solution of equal parts baking soda and table salt (NaCl) and adding enough hot water until they dissolve. Then simply place a silver object in the solution and contact it with a large piece of aluminum foil. In a short time the silver will be restored.

A very cool way to do the same thing is to use a battery. Connect the negative end of the battery to the silver and the positive end to a large electrode, like a copper plate, and dip them both in the solution.

This process occurs due to electrochemical reduction of the silver sulfide to silver.

Special notes:

THIS ONLY WORKS WITH ELEMENTAL SILVER! This restoration method does not work with silvery things like stainless steel or chrome. So make sure the item you want to experiment on really is silver before trying this.

A low voltage battery is best for this experiment, around 3 volts. Higher voltages do not improve the process and may actually damage the item you're trying to restore. If you don't want to mess up, then just use aluminum foil and skip the battery entirely.

More cool science videos at http://www.nurdrage.com
23 comments
May 14, 2012. 9:57 PMelectrokinetic says:
Using copper as the anode (the electrode connected to the positive end of the battery) for cleaning silver electrochemically is a recipe for disaster. The copper will disintegrate and enter the solution, turning it blue. And then it will plate onto the silver! So you will end up with a copper-plated silver object instead of a tarnished silver object. For a demonstration of this see the video at http://www.philamuseum.org/booklets/7_42_73_1.html
You have to either use a metal that won't disintegrate, like platinum, or a substance that once disintegrated won't plate onto the silver, like graphite or aluminum or iron.

As far as the other method goes, the best substance to use in the water is lye, or sodium hydroxide. A 10% solution is what is recommended by conservators who do this type of restoration professionally (although to be honest, the preferred method nowadays is the electrochemical cleaning with the battery). But if you don't want to risk lye, which can be nasty stuff, sodium carbonate is better than sodium bicarbonate. I have to admit I'm a bit skeptical about the claims that a single dip of the tarnished object is enough, though. If it's anything more than lightly tarnished, it's going to take repeated dips with lots of changings of the aluminum foil.
Mar 14, 2012. 2:27 PMbox_of_cereal says:
When I do this after anodizing (using the same method as in the other video), there's sill a stubborn layer of tarnish (it lightens up a lot, but it's still not shiny).
I've tried heating, adding more water, more Al, more salt and more sodium bicarbonate. Nothing helps to clean that last little bit.

I tried with an egg when I got my silver bar, and it polished it magnificently using this technique... But not so well when it's been anodized...

Can you restore it with a battery and Al foil (instead of a copper electrode?)
Jun 5, 2010. 10:28 AMJakeTobak says:
Why did you use the salt, I did some Google'ing and it seems like everyone else uses JUST baking soda. Anyway, it worked it for me, thanks for the video.
Jan 31, 2011. 2:52 AMNagarok says:
Salt is a great electrolyte, it helps with chemicals moving electrons one to the other

And also it helps with moving products away from reactants a tiny bit.
Thats my knowledge at least.
Jul 22, 2010. 10:59 PMgnuoy4 says:
I used to own a fire and water restoration company and had very good luck using baking soda, water and aluminum foil. Never heard of a battery, however. We were able to clean/restore all kinds of silver by simply dipping items of all kinds into a large pot lined with the foil (completely) filled with a solution of approximately 1/2 C soda to 4 qts water. When the foil becomes black, empty the pot, re-line it with new foil and keep dipping. It should take one dip per piece/side of piece (rotated until comptlely cleaned). Be sure to rinse and dry your pieces with a soft polishing cloth immediately. It sure beats silver polish!! :)
Dec 26, 2010. 1:31 AMgethen says:
Rescaled for smaller jobs:

2 cups water for each Tbsp of soda


Jul 24, 2009. 5:32 AMsilverplated says:
Sodium carbonate (Na2CO3) OR Sodium bicarbonate NaHCO3 baking soda ??????????????? what is used ??????????????????
Aug 29, 2010. 5:44 PMmce128 says:
Yeah, I know I'm reviving a very old post, however, Sodium Carbonate (Washing Soda) as opposed to Bicarb (baking soda) works much better, at least in my experience. The salt is unneeded, no battery is needed. Just hot water a piece of Al, and the washing soda... touch the Al to the silver in the washing soda/hot water bath and it's basically instantaneous! Hope this answers you question even though you've probably arrived on the answer long ago by now.
Mar 27, 2010. 8:02 PMTrigonography says:
 Is there some loss of detail with this method? 
Jun 5, 2010. 10:31 AMJakeTobak says:
The way I understand it is that the aluminum takes the sulfur away from the tarnish (silver sulfate), leaving just the silver behind, so you probably retain more details this way than any other. I'm not expert though.
Jan 18, 2010. 7:50 PMreginillita says:
 i have tried like 3 times doing this and its not working.... baking soda, salt and hot water, and its not working!  i put the aluminium foil first then then the solution and then my jewrly (silver) and its not working, what can i do?
Jan 18, 2010. 9:17 PMreginillita says:
 i will leave all night and see tomorrow what happened and tell you ok? thank you!
Jan 18, 2010. 9:16 PMreginillita says:
 thank you!!! like very very very much!
Sep 11, 2009. 5:25 PMdagenius says:
I just got a new all Stirling silver flute(been playing for 5 years), and after the first practice my fingerprints left brown marks, even after I thouroughly cleaned it. I have deduced that it was tarnish. Apparently Males tarnish flutes faster than females. As much as I would like to try this out, I am very afraid of wasting 2700 US dollars. Apparently I will have to live with this for the rest of my flute's life. :( This just makes me sad :)
Sep 13, 2009. 3:59 PMkoakako says:
I wouldn't use the battery, but using the simple foil electrolysis technique would be fine for your flute. There's nothing in the salt and bicarb bath that will hurt it, especially since you're going to rinse it off really well and apply some car wax to protect the finish. Right? RIGHT? (Though you really ought to remove the valve seals and other 'soft' parts first.)
Mar 9, 2009. 10:35 PMBobS says:
Would you know how to restore cheap fake gold jewelery? I don't know if this is just brass with some varnish on it or badly gilded....
Jul 24, 2009. 3:51 AMsilverplated says:
please help me
Jul 23, 2009. 4:38 AMsilverplated says:
please help me i put backing soda and NaCl + H2O + Aluminium foil (hot water) my silver is black what is wrong ????
Jul 23, 2009. 4:30 AMsilverplated says:
sodium carbonate + NaCL + H2O this is solution H2O or demineralized water ??? sodium carbonate is pure? 100% or backing soda ordinary ????
May 29, 2009. 11:29 AMKarim Magdy says:
i am a new member it is really a great site ....... thank you please, would you write the chemical equations for reduction and oxidation for this process cause i am not expert in electrochemistry but i want to know waiting for reply

Pro

Get More Out of Instructables

Already have an Account?

close

All Steps Viewing
View all steps of an Instructable on the same page when you're a Pro Member.

Upgrade to Pro today!
613
Followers
46
Author:NurdRage(NurdRage)
NurdRage is a dedicate group of science nerds trying to further amateur science with direct how-to instructions in video format. We saw what was already online and we thought "we could do better"... s...
more »