Dirty Steak





Introduction: Dirty Steak

Paleo Recipe Challenge

Runner Up in the
Paleo Recipe Challenge

Meat Contest

Runner Up in the
Meat Contest

Dirty Steaks, a.k.a Caveman steaks are basically cooking Steaks directly on the coals rather than above them on a grill. Sounds like it should be a culinary disaster and a waste of a good steak, but what actually happens is as soon as the steak touches the red hot lump charcoal it sears the meat and removes any oxygen between the meat and the wood, so there is no combustion available to force a flare up - the steak starts to leak moisture as the heat begins to cook the meat through, meaning you get a superb crust on your steak, even if you've only cooked it to rare.

We liberally cover the steak with sea salt (kosher salt) and pepper (the pepper may burn a little but I find that adds to the crust - remove it and add at the end if you prefer). Once your lump wood is white hot blow away and loose ash and lay the steak down on the coals, you should see smoke & steam coming off the sides of the steak very quickly.

Thickness affects cooking times greatly but in our video we cooked a medium thick steak for 3 minutes on each side for a medium rare finish, remove this to 2 minutes for rare. Practise makes perfect.

Once both sides have been cooked rest the steak for about the same amount of time it's been on the coals. This allows the steak to equalise internally and the entire steak will be the same beautiful pink colour when you slice it. In our video we brushed some flavoured oil onto the cooked side of the steak to provide another level of flavour, again you don't have to do this but if you like the results then experiment with it.

Once rested slice the steak and simply Eat & Enjoy!



    • Science of Cooking

      Science of Cooking
    • Paper Contest 2018

      Paper Contest 2018
    • Pocket-Sized Contest

      Pocket-Sized Contest

    We have a be nice policy.
    Please be positive and constructive.




    Looks delicious! I have to do this on the coming weekends! ?

    I learned this from Alton Brown a while back ..it seems a tasty way to get an amazing sear and char taste..

    That's the key @dbess, it's almost a crust formed on the outside.

    Do any coals stick to the steak?

    Only slightly, and they are easily knocked off after - they don't cling like a lot would expect. If you have large pieces of wood then they shouldn't stick much at all.

    That. Sounds. Amazing. Good job

    Looks delicious! Thanks for sharing.