Easy Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Cookies

FeaturedContest Winner
Picture of Easy Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Cookies
These are delicious and super simple to make, as well as being wheat and gluten free. Nutty, chocolatey, and oozing with salted caramel goodness. Just follow these simple steps and enjoy...
Remove these adsRemove these ads by Signing Up

Step 1: Gather your ingredients

Picture of Gather your ingredients
You will need:

• A small jar of peanut butter - 8oz / 227g
• Sugar
• An egg
• Sea salt
• Chocolate covered caramel

I like to use chunky peanut butter for extra nuttiness, but smooth would work too. I used a large bar of Galaxy caramel, but any chocolate covered caramel will do - either a bar that can be broken into chunks, or individual pieces.

Step 2: Making the dough

Picture of Making the dough
This cookie dough is so simple - just three ingredients, and no fiddly measuring or weighing!

First, empty the jar of peanut butter into a mixing bowl.

Step 3:

Picture of
Next, refill the jar with sugar and add to the bowl.

Step 4:

Picture of
Then add the egg.

Step 5:

Picture of
Mix the ingredients together until they form a nice firm even dough. This should only take a minute or so.

Step 6: Roll out the dough

Picture of Roll out the dough
Now we're going to roll the dough out flat. You might find this stage easier if you chill the dough for half an hour first to make sure its nice and firm rather than soft and sticky.

Place the dough on a large sheet of plastic wrap and roll it out until its nice and thin - around an 1/8 of an inch - and roughly rectangular in shape.

Step 7: Add the caramel pieces

Picture of Add the caramel pieces
Add the pieces of chocolate covered caramel to one half of the dough only, evenly spaced - each one will form the centre of a cookie.

Step 8: Add the salt

Picture of Add the salt
Add a good pinch of salt on top of each caramel piece. Use the best sea salt you can find, and don't be afraid to add plenty - salty caramel is delicious!

Step 9: Form the cookies

Picture of Form the cookies
Carefully lift up the other free side of the dough using the plastic wrap, and fold it over the caramel pieces. Leaving the wrap in place, gently press the dough down around the pieces to seal them into parcels. Take a knife and cut the dough into squares around these parcels to create little pillows - like ravioli.
ecsaul232 years ago
these look sooooo good
scoochmaroo2 years ago
That's really clever!
H0rns (author) 2 years ago
Thanks guys. They were delicious. I'm just sad now that they're almost all gone...
bajablue2 years ago
Excellent job! Amazing "Who knew?" cookies!! Faved!!!
eatproperly2 years ago
You rock. These are great cookies
Oh those sound so wonderfully awesome! I love chocolate caramel filled cookies :D