The iconic New York egg cream is a drink that is considered wildly difficult to bottle. Over time the seltzer loses it's fizz becoming flat and separates from the milk, which is neither refreshing or appetizing. Consequently, egg creams are usually only found in fountain shops, delis, and old drug stores.....until now. For the East Coasters looking to take a sip down memory lane, or the rest of the world looking to dive into a delicious and refreshing drink this Instructable is for you.
Sweet chocolate, cold milk, and full of bubbles, the egg cream has me hooked! Follow these easy steps and you just might be too.
Step 1: Materials
- Whole Milk*
- Seltzer Water
- Chocolate Syrup**
- Cold and Frosty Glass (8oz)
**NOTE: Traditionally, Fox's U-Bet Chocolate Syrup was used (and still is!) to create the Egg Cream. Other chocolate syrups can be substituted. While creating this Instructable, I tried both Santa Cruz Organic Chocolate Syrup and the recommended Fox's. The Santa Cruz brand was thick and harder to mix without loosing too much of the milky foam an egg cream is known for. The Santa Cruz flavor in the finished egg cream was also lacking in comparison to the Fox's.
Step 2: Get Frosty
Step 3: Time for Chocolate
Add 1 inch of chocolate syrup to the bottom of your chilled glass.
Step 4: Milk
Pour 1 inch of whole milk into your glass.
By the end of this step you should have an equal ratio of chocolate to milk. If you want your egg cream to be even creamier and richer, add more milk. If you'd like less or more chocolate, subtract and add accordingly.
Step 5: Seltzer
Pour in your seltzer water, leaving at least an inch at the top for the froth and foam as the seltzer and milk react.
If you are lucky enough to have a pressurized cylinder and can make your own seltzer, this is the perfect opportunity. Fill your siphon bottle with fresh cold water and attach a fresh CO2 cartridge. Tilt your glass and spray an even stream of fresh seltzer into the glass. Make sure to leave room for the foamy head to form, about 1 inch. You will have a beautiful foamy chocolate head! If you'd like to avoid the brown foam head, simply combine the milk and seltzer first before adding the chocolate syrup.
Step 6: Stir to Success
An aesthetic note: some egg cream makers will combine the milk and the seltzer first before adding the chocolate syrup to keep their foam pure and white. I've found that as long as you wait to stir until after the milk and seltzer have had time to mix and mingle, and you don't stir overaggressively, your foam head will maintain it's pristine white color without taking on too much of the chocolatey brown tinge at the top.
Step 7: Enjoy!
A final note on the history of the egg cream: You've gotten this far, and maybe you're asking yourself, egg? cream? What's with the name? There are a bunch of different theories as to where the name came from. Here are a few to tide you over:
- A mispronunciation of the French "Chocolat et crème".
- Egg Cream evolved from using grade "A" cream as an ingredient. "A" morphed into "egg".
- Real eggs were popular in milkshakes and other fountain drinks around the time the NY Egg Cream was invented. At the invention of the NY Egg Cream, they cut out both the eggs and cream in order to save money and potentially increase profits.