Homemade Twinkie Challenge

Step 8 The Results

On the day of the tasting, I wanted to get everyone’s honest opinion, so no one knew which cake or which filling was which.  In an attempt to discover the greatest cake + filling combo, I allowed each taster to sample them individually and in combination, and rate them as such.  The results were surprising.

Here is a picture of the surveys each member filled out.   Most of the results explore how each taster enjoyed each of the elements separately, but they were also encouraged to express their favorite pairings.

The results were tallied and are represented in the bar graphs below.

The Favorite Cake Award goes to:     Copycat Twinkie Cake Recipe

The Favorite Filling Award goes to:    Gluten-Free Filling Recipe

And the Favorite Combination Overall  (drum roll please. . . .):   

Organic Vegan Twinkie cake with the Gluten-Free Twinkie filling!!!!! 

Although, to be honest, the Organic Vegan Twinkie with its own filling came in a veeeerrrry close second.   Which is why, I’ve decided, it deserves its own unique Instructable (coming soon).

 

Thank you for playing, and stay tuned for our next round of Instructables Test Kitchen!