Picture of How to Be a Guitar Hero/Rock Bander
Having trouble impressing the other persuasion with some furious fretwork? Not no more! NOTE: This applies to guitar only. If I get enough good feedback I'll make one for singing and drums on RB.

Step 1: Getting to Know Your Guitar

Picture of Getting to Know Your Guitar
It sounds dumb, but you have to be able to know the guitar with your eyes closed. If you use the Rock Band Stratocaster, there are little braille bumpies that identify the green, yellow, and orange buttons. On the Guitar Hero SG and Les Paul, There is a line on the yellow button. So just make sure you can make your way over to these without thinking about it too much.
Green Grass = some fast licks but it'll only take you 2 or 3 tries to pass

TtFaF = hellishly hard!! after 20 attempts im still at 3 %
Brother_D (author)  electricshavingcream6 years ago
I just beat TtFaF with 84%!
its fun to go into practice and mess around on that song. i got like 30 percent off of just gree, red, yellow.
Brother_D (author)  electricshavingcream7 years ago
The only thing that makes Green Grass hard is that whenever I get to the part with the up and down G-R-Y-R-G over and over, and I have to use my overdrive, and then when it moves up a color, I have none and I fail.
Brother_D (author)  Bran7 years ago
It's comparable
bakenbitz6 years ago
I can do it...It's not that hard. The guitar battle against lou is much harder, but I beat that as well.
Sgt.Waffles7 years ago
ATT: Playing Rock Band/Guitar Hero does not make you a musician. Now back to your regularly scheduled program.
Does it look like we Guitar Hero people think we're musicians? Do you see us get disappointed because we realize we don't have a record deal yet? No. These games are for fun, for the most part.

I always find it funny when people say something like this. Would you seriously think that people playing games like Forza Motorsport think they're actually going to become racecar drivers based solely on the game? And what about AirForce Delta Storm? Do these people really think they're about to get jobs as pilots?

People don't play games because they think it will make them better at the subject of the game (for the most part). People play games because they are fun.

That said, in some cases it could make you a musician. Have a look at The Guitar Zeros. You certainly have to have some knowledge of musical instruments, but who's to say you couldn't play a game controller as an instrument, with the right software? Also, a lot of the techniques you need to learn to master drums or singing in Rock Band could be applied to a career. Not to say you don't still need lessons, but it helps.

In short: 99% of Guitar Hero/Rock Band players don't think they are musicians. For further clarification, please see these two comics: [1] [2]
I play violin so I have found out something. GH doesn't make you any better at playing the guitar (in fact, it could make you worse) because a real guitar requires more complex finger movements, but it could help you play an instrument like a violin, viola, or even a cello or bass. This is because on GH your fingers are all in a single-file line like on a violin, and this could help work-out your fingers when you play the faster songs. Plus on expert you have to shift to play the orange note, which is very common in higher level violin music. In other words, Guitar Hero doesn't make you better at playing the guitar.
I think you have lost it... You do need to have your fingers in a single-file line on a guitar. (Don't tell me you don't, i've played it for long enough to know)
What I'm saying is that on a guitar you play chords, while on a violin you only play on one string at a time (unless you're playing double-stops, but that's a whole other story). btw, I never said you don't need to have your fingers in a single-file line on a guitar...
right, and i was agreeing with you oh well, some ppl, aka im not emo, just don't learn :P
Why don't we take a moment to vote and see who agrees with who. Since im_not_emo was the first person (if there was more than one) to disagree with me, I will run against him. Say whether you agree with me that on a guitar you don't play in a single-file line, or whether you agree with im_not_emo that you do have to play in a single file line. btw, this isn't to start any arguing, it's to end it.
umm obviously not man...i mean, have you ever played a chord? try Am, that's one, or C... I'm rather sure your fingers aren't in a straight row... rather, they're sprawled out along the frets,(1-5), and must move in vertical and horizontal motions(in relation to the neck) just out of curiosity, how long have you been playing?
Brother_D (author)  Gksarmy7 years ago
The closest thing to a single file row chord is a power chord...
Exactly my point.
That's basically what I'm trying to say...
What are you referring to?
I don't understand the question...
Don't worry
I have no idea where this conversation went...
Again, I don't think anyone ever claimed it did make you a good guitar player, and if they did it was misguided in my opinion. However, it is interesting to hear that Guitar Hero helped you to play the Violin. I'm thinking of trying to verify some of these claims sometime as an article for a site I write for.
I never said it specifically helped me play violin, I'm just saying GH helps with playing violin or viola more than it helps with playing guitar. Although I do think playing violin helped me master GH quicker. Most people have problems playing the blue and orange notes because their pinkie fingers aren't very strong and they aren't very good at shifting their hand position, but this wasn't much of a problem for me so I started on medium and completely skipped the easy difficulty. btw, what is the site that you write for?
In any case something I'm looking to test. It's www.www.arson-news.com. Small-ish website with a focus on stuff like this.
it doesn't make you, but it helps.

EXAMPLE: the weekend I got guitar hero up to expert, my guitar teacher and I had noticed my fingers were stronger, and could hold strings down longer.
I've never considered myself a musician for playing guitar hero more than i consider myself a war hero for beating halo 3 on "you ARE gonna die" mode. Video games are a fun part of life, while some of us can play real instruments, and others can't, it remains a fact that anyone that thinks they are a musician for simply hitting some buttons probably has some social issues that need to be tended to.
Brother_D (author)  Sgt.Waffles7 years ago
I didn't mean for this to send a message that these games make you a musician. It's just a help guide for playing on expert. I agree that people who play Guitar Hero/Rock Band are not neccessarily musicians. Thanks for the comment though.
your a musicican brother_d u play guitar and u can play some bass
Brother_D (author)  kaluke047 years ago
thank you, person that i know.
peach_fart7 years ago
the bumps are hard to feel while rocking out on rockband
sick-al7 years ago
in one by matallica, do you meen the solo near the end tha is stuffed of hammer-ons and pull-offs? (there are 4 solos in whole song)
Brother_D (author)  sick-al7 years ago
yes, the really fast part that goes YBO a lot and then moves to RYB and then GRY.
i beat green grass and high tides on expert and it just kept ruining me on solo h i think where its like g,r,y,r,g,r,y,r,g,r,y,r,g,r,y,r,g,r,y,r,g and eventually i figured out that i should save my star power and do that as far as i could into the solo before i failed and hit the back button ( which also helps activate star power because its easier than flinging the guitar up in the air and losing my streak ) and then i continued from there and finally beat the song
lol i passed greengrasstideswhateveritscalled on my second try, four stars, with the gh3 guitar its just that the timing window for hitting the notes is WAY too little in rock band
Brother_D (author)  electricshavingcream7 years ago
i thought that the hammerons in gh2 were fine
Brother_D (author)  electricshavingcream7 years ago
They are, they're just different.
It's like that with hammer-on notes in GH 1&2.
Brother_D (author)  OfficerKarl7 years ago
Actually, it's a little different. If you'll notice, in GH 1&2, you have to actually hammer it on whenever the note passes. Same goes for RB. But in GH3, you can hit the parent note, then hold down the note for the hammer-on until it comes, and it will hit the note.
Either way, hammer-ons are slightly harder in GH 1&2. I mostly play GH3 because I think it's a little bit easier to hit the notes, but there are more of them.