Gather up all the pieces and mold them together using some water. Mold them so the result looks like poop.
If you want to fool your friends with a creative (if somewhat gross) prank, make fake poop. You can freak them out by hiding it somewhere in the house or car. Get ready for an extreme reaction when they find it. You may want to hide.
If you found this instructable helpful please rate and vote on it in the April Fools Day contest.