How to make a Tortuga Rum Cake

Picture of How to make a Tortuga Rum Cake
tortuga cake2.JPG

The very first step in making a rum cake is to set aside your inhibitions.

Allowed to season for at least a day, your cake will not have a ‘smelly alcohol’ scent, nor will it taste as though you’ve doused your dessert with a drink. Or two.

This recipe is a clone of a well-known cake sold in the Cayman Islands by the makers of the rum used in this recipe - Tortuga. It is said to be difficult to find, but can be purchased in better liquor stores, often ordered by the store. Worth checking into. See the image in step 1 (not to be confused with this intro) so you will know what to look for in the liquor store.

Don't run at the note of 'clone', as this cake is indeed delicious, the next best thing to an actual Tortuga Rum Cake from the Carribean. If you are unable to locate this rum, Whaler's Vanille (not a typo) can be substituted.

Kudos to "Heart 'n Soul" of Minnesota, courtesy of Food.com for sharing this recipe with the world. This recipe is referred to as the 'Almost Tortuga Rum Cake'.

Alterations in text, but not the recipe, by Karen Manasco

Special thanks to Instructables member Starshipminivan, who reminded us that September 19 is
International Talk Like A Pirate Day!

Grab your bottle of rum and make a cake, or walk the plank!
See more at: http://talklikeapirate.com/

Step 1: Understand the procedure...

Picture of Understand the procedure...
Directions: Cake will consist of three steps. Please read entire recipe before starting.
Ensure you have all of the ingredients, as some are listed twice, and even thrice among all three steps.

Basic mix - You will first create a basic mix that can be refrigerated for several months. But why wait?

Batter - This is added to the basic mix as stated above

Rum glaze - The finishing touch
1-40 of 54Next »
hermit575 days ago

You want to use 2 teaspoons Madagascar Pure Vanilla Extract in the BATTER portion of the recipe. A good Tortuga Rum substitute is Malibu Spice Island Rum with coconut liqueur. Add a pinch or two of Roasted Saigon Cinnamon to the glaze. It's that hint of flavor you can't quite put your finger on that makes all the difference in that wonderfully mysterious flavored rum cake. For those asking about using a cake mix, I have used this with good success:

You can use a white cake mix and the box of vanilla pudding;

4 eggs

3/4 c. vegetable oil

3/4 c. water.

2 teaspoons Madagascar Pure Vanilla

Mix all ingredients together well, then pour into prepared Bundt pan according to original recipe above. (I like using PAM for baking. Good flavor without distracting from cake flavor). Bake at 325 for 45 minutes

. Finish up with the rum glaze according to original recipe above. Hope this helps. Hope you like the changes. :)

I have baked this cake 3-4 times now and it is a hit. Follow the directions exactly and you can't go wrong. I will never by the tortuga cakes in the caribbean again.

WUVIE (author)  kkarlinkamin24 days ago
Wow, glad you liked it, thank you for sharing!
kejoseph993 years ago
Hello WUVIE. Can you - or anyone else out there - help me? We used to live in the Cayman Islands and have very fond memories of Tortuga Rum Cake (the Blue Mountain Coffee was our favourite). Now we're back in a very wet and rainy UK and I'd love to make a nearly-authentic rum cake for my husband's birthday this week, just to remind us of all that lovely sunshine. I even have a proper bundt tin (rare over here). However, in the UK there is no such thing as Jello Instant Vanilla Pudding mix. What is it? Does anyone know if there is an acceptable substitute available here? For instance, is it the same as Angel Delight? I do remember seeing it in the supermarket in Cayman but we never tried it. I would welcome any suggestions.

Hey kejoseph99. Sorry this seems a bit late after 3 years. I was born in the UK and now live as a permanent resident in the US, and I used to work on a cruise ship in the Caribbean and the Med, so I definitely understand how you feel about missing foods in different places. Anyway, I believe angel delight will work well as a sub for the jello. It has the same consistency. I'm trying this today. I definitely miss sampling the Tortuga Rum Cakes that we sold on our ship. :)

WUVIE (author)  kejoseph993 years ago
Oh my gosh, it just seems so strange that a product like Jell-O pudding would not be available widely. Ah, the things we take for granted.

Though I cannot vouch for the following site, I did find several people discussing the lack of pudding mix in the UK.

I sure hope this helps! :-)



I tried many rum cake recipes and had no success until i found this one!. I have made this recipe many times and it always comes out delicious!!!! Thank you so much for taking the time to be so detailed and give us this jewel of a cake recipe!!

hochs5 months ago
I used a Captain Morgan Rum Blend called 1671 to make the cake. I was bringing it for a gathering of friends who are foodies. They loved it! I think I will be asked to make it again in the near future. Thanks for the great instructible.
daenergymon made it!8 months ago

How do you get the cake out of the pan? I left it in overnight and it wouldn't come out

I didn't use the pudding.

rum cake.jpg

dont let it cool all the way in the pan. i let it cool to as much as i can handle the pan.

WUVIE (author)  daenergymon8 months ago

Ouch. Did you try wiggling it? Tapping it on the side on a hard surface? Also, I see three pans. Did you try to divide the batter into three pans, and did you spray or oil the pan before pouring in the batter? :-(

garrett.jax.77 months ago

Okay ... I got to the last part about pouring on the glaze and was a bit perplexed as to how much time to take to pour ALL of the glaze on the cake since you said to be patient. I guess I was patient to an extreme because the cake cooled down before all the glaze had been used and, as I continued pouring, the glaze pretty much just sat on and around the cake and its cracks and crevices and the bottom of my cake turned out soggy.

So, for a novice such as me, would you say that I should have been more generous with the pouring while it was still hot. To be more precise I used a measuring cup to hold the contents of the glaze so about how much at a time should I have poured while the cake was still warm and cooling?

Other than that one small flaw I had, the cake was delicious!


I dont use the entire recipe for the glaze. i cut the recipe in half. i also pour it all on at once.

forrie3 years ago
I don't think Tortuga uses butter in their glaze. Also, whenever I make a cake, after glazing and it's set... there's always a lemony taste, and I can't understand why. I use Watkins, too.

The glaze is the real secret I think... probably loaded with vanillin or something that is other than what we think it is :-) I bet it's flavored sugar, less so any booze.
WUVIE (author)  forrie3 years ago
Aw, no fun, Forrie. I've never had the pleasure
of tasting an actual Tortuga Rum Cake. :-)

One day, one day... (sigh)
kjgjam22 WUVIE6 months ago

no need to sigh....you are not missing anything .....this cake is 100 times way better than the actual tortuga cake.

WUVIE (author)  kjgjam226 months ago

Oh, that is good to hear, thank you! I thought I would never get a chance to try a real one, but it sounds like I'm in the clear. :-)

kjgjam22 WUVIE6 months ago

can you order it online? where do you live? i ca find out how much it will cost to send you a small one.

Jim. I will be making the rum caramel corn next. I love rum!
Just made this. Can't wait to try it! And you don't heat up the syrup again after adding the rum because it burns off all the alcohol!
My sister used to order these every Christmas. Love them. Really can't wait to eat this!!!

me podrian enviar la receta por favor (ingredientes y como se hace paso a paso, graciass

ahhhh y donde puedo conseguir en panama este run tortuga gold

WUVIE (author)  denis.e.brassfield8 months ago
Hello Denis, I am so sorry, I do not speak Spanish. I tried to use Google Translate, but do not understand if you are saying something or asking something. Where do you live? :-)

Hola Denis , lo siento , yo no hablo español . Traté de usar Google Translate, pero no entienden si usted está diciendo algo o preguntar algo. Dónde vives? :-)
AileenO8 months ago

I've made this cake several times and it's always spectacular!

daenergymon8 months ago
I just make a straight sponge cake but I use rice flour instead with lots of eggs and butter and flavored rum.I don't think it tasted any different than the ones on island
jim.maroun8 months ago

For the past two holiday seasons I've made Rum Cake based off of this recipe. The only modifications is I add a couple of squirts of maple syrup to the cake mix and I use 3/4 of Kraken Black Spice Rum. Great stuff.

Rum cake got me thinking about rum Carmel corn. This is the first year I've tried it. I found a Carmel Corn recipe on Allrecipes.com and I added 3/4 cup of Kraken Black Spiced Rum during the boiling processes. OMG. This is totally delicious. Between my wife and I, I don't think we'll have any left for guests. Might have to make more.

By the way, I'm not a Rum drinker, but Kraken taste awesome. I took a couple of sips and I really think it makes a difference.

Hope this inspires. Good luck


Xavienne3 years ago
Just made one of these & a chocolate variant. Very tasty and so far a huge hit with my friends! I think I have a new holiday tradition!
can you provide the recipe for the chocolate variant of the rum cake?
Happy Talk Like a Pirate Day! I made this for dessert. Thank you for posting it!
WUVIE (author)  starshipminivan3 years ago
Wow, I don't know how I missed your post, Starship, but your cake looks fabulous!
forrie3 years ago
I've been working on trying to duplicate this rum cake recipe for a long time. Many disasters, some close.

I think their glaze has some flavoring (besides rum) in it. There's an almost crea my taste to it, it might be vanilla/vanillin. But the actual cake itself at the factory is very likely doctored up boxed yellow cake mix.

Anyone know more about the glaze.
I love rum candy if this tastes anything like that then I well definitly have to try it some day. I like rum candy so much I'm scared I may one day be an alcoholic (rumaholic).
WUVIE (author)  the_burrito_master4 years ago
Hmm. Rum candy. Now there is one I have to try, thanks!
Omg even tho it's non alcoholic, the first few I had i hated and then I got addicted to them XD. I've got to get some more.
urnaa3 years ago
sunshiine3 years ago
Another wonder???? Must make this one also! Thanks for sharing! Have a splendorous day!
jongscx4 years ago
I would love to find a cake-mix equivalent to this, using the same methods, but making it more idiot-proof.

Also, have you tried making the other tortuga rum-cake variants? I remember they had like Chocolate, Pineapple (almost like pineapple upside-down doused in rum), and coconut I think...
to be honest (and not to detract from what looks like a lovely recipe by WUVIE) i just make a boxed chocolate cake (any kind) and then douse it with malibu or parrot coconut rum, no glaze, just pure rum. Like WUVIE, i use a little bit at a time. People rave about this cake, especially if i make it in cupcake style. If you make cupcakes, i recommend the aluminum liners so the rum doesn't soak through the liner. It's a lot less steps and IMHO better than a tortuga cake b/c it's fresh...those tortuga cakes are fun in the carribean, and make great souvenirs, but if i'm craving a rum cake, i just whip up that rather than ordering one from amazon. BTW WUVIE, if you want to try one, you can order them from amazon, it's actually cheaper than buying them in the Cayman Islands...I discovered that trick and the year I went i didn't even have to lug back the souvenirs, i just ordered them and shipped them to my house and to my friends :)

I think WUVIE's recipe is worth a try though, the butter glaze sounds delicious!
WUVIE (author)  jongscx4 years ago
Oh my gosh, Jong, the other flavors, indeed! I would love to try the banana and coconut as well. It seems like I've seen something about a cake mix, I'll see if I can find it for you.
riff raff4 years ago
And definitely the rest of the rum. Arrrrr! *wink*
1-40 of 54Next »