Step 4: Lets Start Mixing Things Together

Alright lets start by creaming (mixing well) the cup of butter and shortening together in your big mixing bowl with that electric mixer.

If you don't have an electic mixer then do it with a whisk and a fork and a lot of elbow grease. It gets harder to mix when you add all that flour in. I give you my sympathy because I've had to do it before.

If you have a big fancy Cuisinart that can do all the work for you then I forgot to tell you that you're supposed to do it with just a fork and you get no sympathy. >:P
I think its finally time i made an account so that i can comment. Ive been making this cake for about 3-4 years now. And i hate it. Every holiday major or minor I'm talking even laborday and what not someone is saying "youre making that lemon cake right?!?!?!" Its that good! My family hounds me for it. Once i tried making a different cake and my mom almost killed me. I had to make both! One day i felt like making a lemon pound cake and googled it and chiose from the one i frlt LOOKED the most authentic looking one. Ive got a good eye, haha!
I LOVE LOVE LOVE this recipe. It's definitely my "Go To". I've used lemon extract, Rum and more recently, banana extract for my banana pudding pound cake. I add 2 mashed bananas,banana extract & banana flavored pudding and bake as directed. For garnish, I use crushed vanilla wafers. Delicious!
I'm making it now for Christmas made it for Thanksgiving as well. my husband's favorite thanks for the great recipe and even better instructions.
it's sooooo good omg .....I had to leave mine in the oven a little longer for the middle to get done so I'd say about 2 hrs total Idk I'd it's my oven or what but other than tht it came out great I can't wait to try it with other extract flavors thanks so much for the recipe!!!
<p>I'm making this next week for thanksgiving I can't wait to try it!!!</p>
Awesome! Let us know how it turns out.
<p>Do you have a good sour cream pound cake recipe? I tried your version as well and every one raved over it. thanks</p>
It's unfortunate that I do not have a sour cream recipe. I'll have to start working on one and post my version one day. <br>When I try new recipes, my favorite place to start is America's Test Kitchen.
<p>I went wayyyy back into my past on this one! Using only the ingredients portion of this recipe, I was able to lemon cakes that I hadn't made completely from scratch in years! Of course I had to a little &quot;extra&quot; by adding 1/2 tsp cornstarch, a dash of lemon juice (on top of the prescribed amount of lemon extract), 2 Tbsp sweetened condensed milk, canola oil instead of vegetable oil (I don't use veggie oil for anything anymore), and the cake came out AWESOME! Thanks for the recipe! :)</p>
<p>I made this a few hours ago. I used a nonstick bundt pan and filled it 3/4 full then made 12 cupcakes this was my very 1st pound cake. It's is very delicious and easy to make. I will use this recipe all the time. 5 Stars!! </p>
I made this cake yesterday for Christmas and it is fantastic!!! This cake was very easy to make and I had no problem following the instructions. This will definitely be my go to recipe for a lemon pound cake. 5 stars!!!
I made this yesterday for my moms bday and it turned out fabulous! Everyone enjoyed it. They were eating the crumbs off the plate! I'm making it again for Thanksgiving! I used pre-sifted flour so I was able to skip that step. Other than that I followed to recipe to a t.
So, Walmart has this sour cream pound cake that is cracked on top and it has like sugar crumbs (is not lemmon) omg and is delicious. Im hoping your recipe will make it as close as possible. But how do i make the crack and the sugar crumbs?
Hello was just wondering can I make this in my bundt pan from Nordic ware? I would love to try this but it don't have a tube pan and afraid it might overflow in my bundt pan....
<p>I have a smaller pan I use from time to time. If there's not enough room I put the rest in a bread pan and make a small cake with that.</p>
Thanks! So about how much should I fill that pan? About 3/4 of the way?
Made this cake for Memorial Day cookout my guest and family enjoyed it very much, as did I, DELICIOUS, moist, lemony goodness. This just may become my signature cake one of the best. Great recipe!!!
I made this cake today and WOW!!....this will be my new way of making a &quot;Southern Lemon Pound Cake&quot;!! It is simply FABULOUS!! I think next time I will substitute one of the 3 tablespoons of lemon extract with butter flavoring...just to add more &quot;depth&quot; of flavor! :-) You def. get 5/5 stars from me! I will continue to follow you and try more of your recipes! Thanks for sharing! :-)
I'm glad you enjoyed it. Please let us know how your lemon butter cake comes out. I've also made this recipe with a mix of orange extract and vanilla extract for a Creamsicle pound cake. It was very good.
<p>This has become my go to lemon pound cake. My husband devours it every time. I took it to my Mom's when we visited, and caught her sneaking mini pieces more than once!</p>
I used this recipe for Thanksgiving dessert 2013...I followed the Instructions to the T it is the best lemon cake ever ????? my husband actually hav me n the kitchen as I'm writing this post making another one for one ofhis Valentines day gift lol .. ThankQ soooo much for this recipe!!!
What's the rules with the evaporated milk? Why was that used instead if real milk? Can I use real milk, and if so what do I change/how much do I use? And how is the cake different with either option?
Evaporated milk gives a more concentrated flavor because it has had 60% of the water removed. You can use regular milk in the same proportions, I'm just not sure how it will come out.
Oh, I didn't know that. Thanks! :)
I use an oven thermometer whenever I bake. I had the temp a little above 300 F (312). After 1 hour and 15 minutes, the cake tester came out with liquid coating it. I turned up the temperature to 350 F and 15 minutes later the cake tester came out clean. It already had a brown crust so I took it out of the oven immediately and could see it right away starting to fall. I stuck it back in the oven (turned off) but my hopes are not high. Also, btw, the top never cracked. Next time I'm going to try 350F for an hour and hope things go more as planned!
Hey, this is the recipe i have been using, awesome, but have you tried it with all butter and no shortening?
I remember doing this once. Somehow it didn't rise as well but tasted just as good. Let us know how it turns out.
Will it work with all butter and shortening?
That's what it calls for. Although I may be misinterpreting your question.
What if one were to take 2 sticks of butter and use them as prescribed, then take 2 1/3 sticks of butter melt them and pour off the water and solids, and use that instead of Crisco. Because of those hydrogenated fats, alot of people have an aversion to using Crisco. Myself, I'd rather use lard than vegetable shortening---but just try finding real lard if you don't have a personal butcher. Yep, I think it's worth trying with the butter; but you've got to clarify it, there's just so much water in butter that your cake might not raise properly if you don't.
I'm quite intrigued by your observation that lard is better for you than vegetable shortening. Veg shortening is a manufactured product, but lard is pure saturated fat which I thought meant it has broadly the same properties <em>vis a vis</em> cholesterol, digestion, and so on. I'm not saying you're wrong, I just haven't encountered this idea before and I want to know more.<br/>
kissiltur:<br/>If lard were <em>pure</em>, saturated fat it would be rock hard at room temperature. Suet, beef fat, is more saturated than lard (pork fat) and is like wax room temperature. Chicken fat, the least saturated of the three is almost liquid. <br/>(I know I read an article explaining the physiology of these things in the New York times, but I couldn't find a link.)<br/>The next piece of the puzzle is that vegetable shortening, in order to be made sold at room temperature, is partially hydrogenated. Hydrogen atoms are added to stabilize the carbon chains so that they are not fluid at higher temperatures. When this is done industrially, the fat chains develop kinks in them, called trans fats, that literally become stuck in ones arteries. Trans fats are found only rarely in nature, so that an artificially saturated fat is more dangerous than a naturally saturated fat.<br/>Finally, if we are to use animal product, the more we can glean and the less waste the better off we are. Rather than putting tons of pork fat in industrial land fills, it would be better to make delicious pastry, and have the Unilever people figure out how they are going to meet share holder demand. <br/>
Excellent answer! A growing number of people are finding that they are soy sensitive/allergic, like myself. This makes a shortening alternative a must.
Thank you. That is a splendid and comprehensive answer. As it happens, I don't eat meat so I'd be very unhappy if pastry everywhere suddenly started to be made with lard, but I am glad to know more about how things fit in. Thank you again.
Looks yummy, can't wait to try it!!!! Do you think it would change the texture of the cake if I added some sour cream to the recipe? Would it be too heavy? I'm gonna try it and let you know how it turns out. <br> <br>Oh, the last time I try to make a pound cake, the cake came out kinda congealed in the middle, like it was under cooked. Not sure why. I have an electric oven and I even bought an oven temp. gauge. What did i do wrong??
Please tell us how the sour cream comes out.<br>As for the coagulated middle; more than likely it wasn't cooked long enough. This has happened to me before. I learned that every oven is a little different, so add some cook time to yours. I too use an electric oven.
Thanks so much. I'll be sure to post my results and a pic
this looks awesome. i can't wait to taste it but i don't have lemon extract. will fresh lemon juice work? <br> <br>Also, I found a vegan non-hydrogenated shortening at whole foods for those cocerned about the hydrogenated fat. not sure it it will work the same but worth looking into if you are really concerned about that.
I'm pretty sure the fresh lemon juice will turn out fine, you might even add a little zest for extra flavor just in case.
I&nbsp;posted a new cake Instructable:<br /> Triple Chocolate Brownie Cake<a href="https://www.instructables.com/id/Triple-Chocolate-Brownie-Cake/" rel="nofollow"><br /> www.instructables.com/id/Triple-Chocolate-Brownie-Cake/</a><br />
The recipe looks awesome!! A local bakery here in Philadelphia makes pound cake cupcakes and I&nbsp;was thinking about using this recipe for that purpose.&nbsp; Have you ever heard of this being done? Do you think I'd have to change the recipe at all?<br /> <br /> I almost hate to gamble with a recipe that seems a sure thing!<br />
Lemon Pound Cupcakes do sound delicious. I've never tried it that way.<br /> With this recipe you'll be making a lot of cupcakes. The cooking time will be the biggest factor to play with.<br />
I am making it right now, hopefully it turns out fantastic. Which based on how the batter tastes it will be :]. Awesome recipe :] :]<br />
ahhhh...so i tried to hurry the process up of bringing the butter to room temperature and stuck it in the microwave (i know i know, i shouldn't have tried to cut corners)...but now the butter is melted...can i put it in the fridge and still use it for the recipe? help please?
If you use melted butter your cake won't rise as well. I have used cold butter/margarine but I beat the crud out of it when creaming it and adding the sugar in order to provide maximum air bubbles. A great explanation I found on Yahoo! Answers: TNGal: "Butter adds flavor and texture to your baking and helps to keep it fresh. The temperature of the butter is very important in baking. When room temperature butter is used in your recipe this means your butter should be between 65 degrees F (18 degrees C) and 70 degrees F (21 degrees C). This temperature allows the maximum amount of air to be beaten into your batter. This creaming or beating of your butter or butter and sugar creates air bubbles that your leavener (baking powder or baking soda) will enlarge during baking. Most experts recommend 4 to 5 minutes of creaming the butter for maximum aeration."
thanks! good to know...it's baking now, so we'll see how it turns out!
I made this for my B-Day(yesterday), and It was AWESOME!
om nom nom....
that looks good the problem is that I have to ride my bike to the nearest store (a total of 8 miles) so its hard to make it

About This Instructable




More by bigwhitebear18:How to Peel Garlic Quickly Fresh Apple Cake with Caramel Glaze Triple Chocolate Brownie Cake 
Add instructable to: