Precision-cooking this tender cut of steak takes only an hour or two, so if you don't have a sous vide set-up this is a great candidate for the DIY cooler sous vide trick. I've simply paired the steak with browned-butter caramelized onions, but creamed spinach, some form of potato, or a salad are also traditional steak-house sides.
Not convinced that sous vide is useful for steak?
*or any doneness you like: just set the sous vide temperature appropriately, and you can make rare, medium-rare, medium, or even well-done steak without carefully-timed cooking or guess-and-check nonsense.
Step 1: Salt & Bag
I've used a fancy vacuum chamber, but you can also use a foodsaver, or a ziplock bag if you're going the beer-cooler route. Just make sure you get salt in, and the air and water out.
Step 2: Cook
Heat your water bath to 131F, and drop in the bag-o-steak. If you're using the beer-cooler method, make sure to adjust the water temperature so you HOLD with 131F water for the duration of cook time.
Cook for at least 1.5 hours if you want to pasteurize your steak. Holding a bit longer won't hurt; 2-3 hours is fine, and won't show any real change in the texture of the meat.
If you want an un-pasteurized steak, hold for an hour at 125F for rare, 131F for medium-rare, 140F for medium.
Step 3: Saute onions
If pan-searing the steak: remove onions from pan while you perform step 4, then replace and cook down with the fond and any remaining meat juice from the sous vide bag. Continue cooking until the liquid has cooked off.
If grilling or blowtorching the steak: go ahead and add the meat juices from the sous vide bag, and continue cooking until the liquid has cooked off.
Step 4: Finish steak
Shown below. Use a heavy pot, cast-iron if you can get it.
- Add a bit more butter to the pan if needed, and turn the heat up to medium-high.
- Sear the steak on both sides until browned, about 60 seconds per side.
- Remove from pan and rest on a plate.
See the intro picture for results - this is my preferred method.
- Pre-heat grill so grate is extremely hot.
- Drop steak on the grill, positioning for your favorite style/direction of grill marks.
- When the front side is properly browned (60 seconds or less), flip and grill the other side.
- Remove from grill immediately and rest on a plate.
This is a quick-and-easy method for flaming when you don't have grill access. I keep an industrial blowtorch under my kitchen sink at home, right next to the fire extinguisher.
- Set the steak on a sturdy heat-proof plate (metal or heavy ceramic), pan, or baking sheet.
- Light blowtorch, and slowly pass flame over the surface of the meat.
- Repeat as necessary to achieve a nice brown crust on the surface of the meat. It should sizzle.
- Pay close attention to fat on the edges - browned fat is delicious.
- Flip, and torch the other side.
- Allow torched steak to rest for a few minutes.