loading
Picture of Polishing Badly Tarnished Brass
beforeafter.jpg

I love the look of well polished brass, but the work can be daunting especially when the level of tarnish is bad. In this instructable I will tell you how I deal with the issue; it is fairly quick and quite effective. I should also note that not all brass is created equal, my method is mildly brutal so I would not use it on really expensive items without a bit of thought. Also for just a bit of tarnish less drastic methods should do. Take a look at the pictures here to see if you think it work well for you then read the next section. Also note that it can be a deeply ( but perhaps not spiritually ) satisfying experience to put a nice polish on a piece of brass ( or gold or silver if you can afford them ).

Step 1:

Picture of

The Big Picture

There is more to polishing brass than just the polishing. Just what you are polishing can make a big difference. Many brass items are coated with a protective material to stop them from tarnishing. This coating often fails ( sometimes over many years ) and the tarnish gets under the coating. In order to polish the item you need to remove the coating. I have one lamp where I still have not figured out how to get the coating off, so it is still unpolished. Sometimes the coating deteriorates and is gone by the time you are ready to polish and sometimes you can use a solvent or paint remover to get it off. But this instructable is not about removing the coating, use it if:

  • You have determined there is no coating.
  • You have gotten the coating off.
  • Many softer coating will polish off, try to test before you go big time.

Also note that some brass object have deliberately non polished or colored areas, this technique is probably too brutal to be used on these objects.

When you have finished polishing you can either add a coating or not. If you do not add a coating plan to polish again ( on a boat perhaps next week, in a house perhaps next year ), this is what I often do. Even if you do coat the surface it will not be permanent. Again this is not an instructable about coating, but about polishing. I will give a few tips later in the instructable on coating.

A couple of other things to look out for:

  • Baldwin has a brass that never tarnishes, just leave it alone. ( by the way it is nice stuff if you can afford it )
  • All that looks like brass may not be, if plated you may detect with a magnet, polishing plate may remove the brass down to the base metal ( which may not be magnetic ).
  • Some objects are not meant to be bright.

 

as with polishing/refinishing anything, the trick is to proceed from the coarse/aggressive to the fine. first, as you have pointed out, if the piece is 'coated', that has to be removed. this coating is properly referred to as lacquer, ('cause that's what it is.) unfortunately, in my experience, the only thing that will reliably remove it is stripper. and not the 'citrus' 'environmentally friendly', stripper either. nope, the nasty stuff that burns when you splash it on your skin. the kind with methylene chloride. foul stuff, but, if you want to get the job done... most of the rest of your advice is pretty good. however, i notice in your picture that you didn't polish the dog covers, and the finials that hold them on. they're supposed to shine too, and they ain't easy. the material you're dealing with here isn't metal tarnish, it's creosote. it comes out of the wood (it's not soot, it's a hydrocarbon chemical. it's also produced industrially and used to waterproof utility poles.) more creosote comes out of softwoods than hardwoods, so if the previous owners burned a lot of pine, it's going to be worse. here's where the aggressive part comes in. i've had the most success with 3m pads and a cleanser called barkeepers friend. this will clean them, but you won't have a high shine. you bring this back with progressively finer steel wool and polish. the best commercially available product for a mirror finish, imho, is maas metal polish. it seems expensive at first, but a little does go a long way.

russ_hensel (author)  liam.macgready5 months ago

I skipped the dog covers ( at the little finials at the end of them ) partly because they are difficult, partly because they are so close to the fire that they do not stay polished for long. If I did have to clean them I might try solvents, or even oven cleaner, the latter much to rough for most jobs.

RobinB311 months ago

I have a badly tarnished brass intricately etched round coffee table I inherited from my parents years ago. I started with Brasso-no luck. Tried Noxon today with no luck. Guess I'll try the cola first on a small area, and if no luck, I'll go the hard way. It's such a beautiful table my dad bought overseas.

you're ignoring one crucial ingredient that all sets of advice conveniently fail to mention. elbow grease. the job can't be done without it or machinery. you're looking for the miracle cure, and it's not there.

russ_hensel (author)  RobinB311 months ago
First you may have a lacquer that may need to be removed, that will defeat any polish, the tarnish can get under the lacquer. I have a lamp whose lacquer resists everything I throw at it.

Brasso and Noxon are both fairly mild. Copper bright and twinkle are much stronger. The very fine steel wool is also key for quick work.
lsk2041 year ago
Very helpful! I just bought a very badly tarnished solid brass coffee table. It was so inexpensive I figured even if I had to get a professional involved to get off most of the tarnish it was still worth it. It honestly took me 10-12 hours of following your steps but I was able get probably 40+ years of tarnish off all by myself! Honestly no one else could tell me how to do it, the antique store I bought the table only knew about the Noxon and steel wool. I tried skipping steps at first but really you need all of them to be successful.
I have found that allowing my brass items to sit in a bath of cheap stores own cola drink removes the need for almost all the hard work. Just allow the mild acid in the pop to do its job, then rinse with soapy water and buff with a cloth. Very pleasing results so far.
wire-nut2 years ago
You can also use toothpastes too. :-)
sunshiine2 years ago
Wow! I hate polishing brass but love how it looks when it sparkles and shines. I will refer to this when I polish my brass lamp stand. Thanks so much for sharing your hard work and do have a splendorous day!
sunshiine