Step 1: What You'll Need
I ended up taking the advice 'look in little old convenience stores' and it worked out to my advantage. The guy gave me the bottle at a steal, since it appeared to have been on the shelf since the 1920's...
What You'll Need :
• A pot you don't particularly care about
• At least two keyboards, preferably with similar keys [the one I subbed keys from had some non-standard ones, which was a pain]
• Rit Dye
• A screwdriver or lifter of some kind to dislodge keys
Step 2: Prep
They'll turn out streaky if you don't give them a good scrub beforehand.
Prep the dye by bringing a pot of water to a boil.
The bottle has some incredibly diluted instructions that I found didn't work. I ended up just dumping the whole thing in – but like I said- this dye was as old as the Queen, so use your best judgment for the ratios. I've heard good things about 1 to 1 [1 cup of dye vs 1 cup of water].
Step 3: Cooking the Keys
Add the keys, stirring constantly for the first fifteen minutes.
If you're especially concerned about them hitting the bottom of the pot, suspend them in a sieve.
Step 4: Timing
Don't do that.
I left the keys in for a total of 30 minutes. I would suggest 20 tops, as some of my keys shrunk during the process. Although, I imagine this would be less of an issue with heartier keys not foraged from a 5$ garbage board.
Step 5: Post
Rinse your keys thoroughly until the water runs clear. Give them a good scrub to remove any excess dye.
Line washed keys out on paper towel [residual dye may still exist, I don't recommend putting them on anything you care about until they're 100% dry].
Step 6: Comparison
Step 7: Subbing in Dyed Keys
It's a pretty good idea to take a picture of your base board and Photoshop your ultimate plan. You want to avoid jimmying the keys off and on repeatedly.
Also, it's a quick reference for where all the keys will go.
Once you've got an idea, gently pry the keys you'll be replacing off the base board. I use a small allen key, but if you have the actual key removal tool, all the better.
A screwdriver works equally well, but you have to be careful not to nick the keys.
I did the removal in like-minded clumps [number keys, etc] for simplicity's sake.
Step 8: Final Product
For a slap-dash first go, it didn't turn out too badly.
Learn from my multitude of [mostly negligent] mistakes and you'll have something pretty sharp, I'd wager.
Cost : ~$5
Time : 90 minutes