Secret Recipe Cream Cheese Cookies

This recipe was once a closely guarded secret.  The story goes that someone's great aunt made the very best cream cheese cookies and fiercely guarded her recipe.  She sweet talked her great aunt into giving her a copy but could never duplicate them just the same way her aunt had made.  One day after her great aunt passed away a family member was to go through her things and happened upon her recipe box, where she found the original recipe for the cookies, and written on the recipe was "Secret Cream Cheese Cookies" and on the back was written, "DO NOT GIVE OUT UNTIL I AM DEAD".  Luckily for me and you, this wonderful person shared the recipe here.

I made some alterations to this recipe, as well as added in some techniques, so hopefully you too can duplicate this recipe, to the enjoyment of your family and friends.  I hear this makes a good spritz cookie base as well.  It is also the base dough for my Double Cookie Cookie Monster Cookies Instructable

I chose this recipe because every time I bring this cookie somewhere I see several people eating the cookies, then eating more, telling others, or even grabbing extras to bring to their spouses to try, and then of course the questions come "Who made these?  Where can I get the recipe?"

Seriously...I had the wife of the deputy CIO of the company I work at trying to track down this recipe from is that good.

My advice is to do yourself a favor and print at least 3 copies of the recipe to bring with you every time you bring these cookies somewhere.  That or just tell them to search for this instructable.

And with that, I give you, Secret Recipe Cream Cheese cookies...the secret is out!
Remove these adsRemove these ads by Signing Up
poopsicles1 month ago

I tried to click the link but it's not working for me. From the comments below, it looks delicious to make and fun too! could you post another link for me?


If you clicked on the link with the orange word "hear" it doesn't work - tried a few times myself but if you click on the "Double Cookie Cookie Monster Cookies Instrucables" it will give you the basic recipe. Just not sure if it's the original or the altered version the author made.

RollerScrapper (author)  JeanK21 month ago
Thanks, the recipe is also on the 2nd page of this instructable, just click next off of the main page. It's too bad the original location of the recipe was taken offline.
RollerScrapper (author)  poopsicles1 month ago
I believe the place where I originally found the recipe was taken offline but if you click "next" the Recipe is on the 2nd page of this instructable.
yummers6 months ago

I made these cookies for my mother in law's Easter basket. I made them egg shaped and dipped the bottoms in Graham cracker crumbs (cheesecake!) I added lemon zest and chopped dried cherries, and drizzled with chocolate ganache. Awesome!

RollerScrapper (author)  yummers6 months ago

Wow that sounds amazing! I am getting hungry now :) Great job!

I don't have any limes handy, but do you think this would work fine with lemon juice instead?
Absolutely, you can also use other flavorings in extract form.
Sound delicious.....can you freeze the dough or the baked cookie before frosting?
RollerScrapper (author)  elsiecaptri1 year ago
Part of having the frosting work well is to frost a warm cookie, but they do keep well in the freezer after frosting them.
parismtb1 year ago
Those cookies look so good I could eat them right off the screen! I'll definitely be making these over the weekend!
RollerScrapper (author)  parismtb1 year ago
Cool! Post pictures if you end up making some!
NHquilter1 year ago
I don't particularly like making cookies...but having just finished a tin of these (a Christmas gift - store bought), I might just have to make some! Thanks for sharing the "Secret Recipe"!
RollerScrapper (author)  NHquilter1 year ago
It is well worth the trouble of making them :)