3 Simple Ways to
Share What You Make

With Instructables you can share what you make with the world — and tap into an ever-growing community of creative experts.

PhotosPhotos

Share one or more photos of a project, recipe, or whatever you've made, quickly and easily.

Step by StepStep-By-Step

Share your step-by-step photos with text instructions of what you made so others can do it too!

VideoVideo

Share your how-to video. You'll need your embed code from a video site such as YouTube.

Sourdough Bread

Sourdough Bread
The. Best. Sourdough Bread. Ever. (or The Key to the Bread Universe)

The first time I ever had this great bread was in my sister-in-law's kitchen. I thought I was eating some artisan bakery bread when she casually mentioned that she had made it herself. I've made a lot of bread over the years but I've NEVER made bread like what I was eating. The world of bread changed at that moment for me. Two years ago I wrote a lot about sourdough on my blog, My Sister's Kitchen. Since then, with a lot of practice almost daily, my recipe and technique has been perfected--at least for MY kitchen! (If you want to read more about my sourdough journey, please feel free to check out My Sister's Kitchen.)

I had resigned myself to simply buying good, crusty sourdough since I never even came close to replicating the famous San Francisco sourdough loaves I ate as a child. But no longer~! For over two years now my kitchen counter has been lined with many bowls of starter, batter, dough, etc. (Dr. Seuss aficionados should think, Bartholomew and the Ooblek.) My entire kitchen has been taken over by this wonderful project. So far, the results have been overwhelmingly excellent!

A very important detail to note is that this method makes extra large loaves that are approximately 4.5 pounds each. Each loaf costs only $0.68 to make. That is sixty-eight cents. I buy flour and yeast in bulk, so it's possible that if you buy your ingredients at a regular grocery store, your loaf might cost twice that....a whopping $1.36! As you'll see, that's for a loaf that's about 3 times the size of a loaf of grocery store bread.

(And don't be intimidated by all the steps. I've broken things down into as simple increments as possible because this is really EASY!)

In some ways, sourdough starter is the ultimate renewable resource because it's ALIVE! I was coaching a friend through her first bread-making experience and explaining how to care for her starter. She turned to me and said, "You're talking about this starter like it's a live creature!" And she's right. It IS a live critter. As long as I keep it comfortable and well-fed, it will go on growing, replicating, and replenishing itself.

The art of making sourdough bread is a delightful exercise in returning to the "olden days" of some of the original DIYers--the gold miners and the pioneers. Sourdough isn't a new, green technology; it's an old, even ancient, technology that has sustained people for milennia. Making our own sourdough returns us to an age of LESS technology and LESS speed. Don't forget: LESS money too!

Sourdough bread, made properly, ambles slowly in a world that frantically runs. It might even ask for a tall glass of sweet tea and a rocking chair on the porch.

 
Remove these adsRemove these ads by Signing Up
 

Step 1How in the world does sourdough save energy?

How in the world does sourdough save energy?
I'm glad you asked!

First of all, any time we prepare our own food instead of buying it at the supermarket, we're choosing a lower tech option.

*We start by saving the fuel cost of driving to the store to buy bread.

*We save the energy cost of the commercial manufacturing process of baking bread.

*We save the fuel costs of shipping commercial bread to stores.

*We know exactly what's IN our bread because we've made it by hand. There are no additives or funky unnatural ingredients.

*Every step of the breadmaking process is done by hand. We don't use mixers or blenders or any power-consuming appliances.

*We can even choose the option of baking our bread in the woodstove, on the charcoal grill, or over a campfire if we want to avoid using the oven.

*Both bread-making and the cultivation of sourdough starters have some great community implications. We're not in this alone. Just like the yeasts in the sourdough, we can permeate our communities with change.

*Best of all, anyone can make this bread. The average individual who is trying to live responsibly, minimize use of non-renewable resources, maximize use of renewable resources, and make small but significant changes can easily start making bread like this.

*Sourdough starter itself is a great example on a small scale of a renewable and renewing resource. The crock of starter sitting on the counter can remind you every day that small things make a difference.

So let's get started. This is much more of a method than a recipe. It's not difficult. The entire process takes several hours, but for most of that time, the starter does all the heavy lifting.
« Previous StepDownload PDFView All StepsNext Step »
136 comments
1-40 of 136next »
May 29, 2012. 5:29 PMgracedivine2u2 says:
I made just one loaf, HUGE MISTAKE , my family did not wait to cool off in less the 5 minutes was all gone, and I had to make more 6 loafs because every one want to take home half loaf(Memorial Day every body came to see our Grandfather he is a war vet WW II. He is 96 years old) so this was a double success . Thanks for the memories.
Apr 27, 2012. 7:01 PMdebbiecarol says:
I posted this to the questions when I signed up, but there are no peramiters for the second rise, double?
Apr 24, 2012. 12:09 PMmorgenlandfahrer says:
Just made the bread for the first time this weekend. I did not even add any extra yeast (but was generous on the starter) and it turned out great. We too it to a picknick and it was gone pretty quickly. Thanks for the recipe!
Mar 22, 2012. 6:16 PMPoincy says:
Thank you so much. I just finished my first loaves of bread and they really are amazing. I am assuming that the flavor will become stronger as the starter "matures". I have a proofing setting on my oven. What is you opinion on using it with this bread?
Mar 20, 2012. 1:31 PMrwilliams31 says:
You can also get some Oregon sourdough starter from 1847, for only the price of one envelope and a stamp from http://carlsfriends.net/
Feb 23, 2012. 12:34 PMmike 2012 says:
I followed the recipe to the tee......loaves turned out brown beautiful loaves.....crust was harder than a brick bat.......what can I Do?
Feb 4, 2012. 1:23 PMe-spiv says:
An excellent recipe, I just turned out my first loaf and it was phenomenal. My starter is a little mild, so I used 50% more than this recipe called for to get a good, sour flavor. I also added a tablespoon of sugar to balance out the sourness (I halved this recipe, so it would be 2 tablespoons for the whole thing), and it worked very nicely. I realize that doesn't help the sustainability/cost effectiveness of the whole endeavor, but it does taste quite good.
Feb 4, 2012. 4:26 AMBobett says:
How many scoops are we talking about? Just enough to get the dough out or are we kneading it a bit? 5-10? 20-30? I made this once before and it took a long time for my second rise. I wondered if it had something to do with this step since my kitchen was pretty warm. BTW..... I love this bread. A big thanks to my neighbor who introduced me to this site and gave me a starter.
Jan 2, 2012. 6:49 PMJoeWirth says:
This was my first ever sourdough bread and it turned out great, if a little wet, but really flavorful and jummy!

Can't wait to make more. The loaf is really big, I will try to get smaller cast iron dutch ovens.

Thumbs up!!!
Jan 22, 2012. 4:36 PMJoeWirth says:
Just wanted to update after having done this recipe a couple of times. If you have a nice and active sourdough starter, than you won't need the extra yeast.
Jan 21, 2012. 9:14 AMdrmike-s says:
I forgot to mention, - your recipe uses double the quantity that Jim Lahey uses in his loaf. This will make 1 huge loaf or 2 normal sized loaves. Adjust the size of the Dutch oven accordingly.

Mike
Jan 21, 2012. 9:09 AMdrmike-s says:
Thanks for a lovely recipe! This is basically the same artisan loaf that Jim Lahey popularized in his book "My Bread". The secret is in the long (18 hour) rise and baking the loaf in a cast iron pan in a hot (450º-475º) oven. I've been looking for a sourdough variation of his bread and you have provided it. Thanks again.

Mike
Nov 17, 2011. 8:20 AMbbowen5 says:
I was so skeptical about this recipe because the proportions seemed off, the rising time was so long, the second rising time was too long, and how could you cook bread in a Dutch oven? I am so glad to be wrong because my two loaves came out perfectly, tasting just like the "Staff of Life" my Nana talked about years ago. Thank you so very much! I did knead the dough for about 10 minutes after the first rise , but next time I'll follow it exactly. You are a genius baker!
Nov 17, 2011. 2:47 AMplasticprincess says:
Thank you so much for this. I've been working with a starter for several months and only succeeding in making bread bricks. Thank you for permission to use a tiny bit of yeast because my kitchen is cold. I live in Finland! Now, I know that our rye bread is made with a sour starter, but Finnish rye bread doesn't rise much. I am using a starter that I bought in San Francisco. I think it's considerably warmer there than here. I used 1/4 tsp of yeast and had great results. I tried cutting it back to 1/8 so I am sure that I'm using the least amount necessary. The result wasn't a brick, but it was extremely chewy. I'm going back to using 1/4 teaspoon of yeast through the winter/spring and will try again with no yeast in the summer.

Thanks from one very happy transplanted Texan.
Apr 9, 2011. 1:18 PMNaturalCrafter says:
Question about keeping active starter happy. When keeping it out at warmer temperatures, how can you tell you still have a pure product or other yeast or bacteria have not entered and take up residence? I had some starter from friendship cake and I cut it (for making cake and dividing up to give to other persons) and then added more flour and water and punched it down but was not sure how long you could keep doing this, and how much time do you normally have in between restorations. So with sour dough, must you be a daily baker or is there a way to efficiently store it for say next week.
Nov 6, 2011. 8:49 PMmuhu22 says:
Hey N.C....here's the scoop. No matter what you do, eventually the airbourne yeast WILL infiltrate your starter. This is okay as that it just gives your bread it's own "local" personality. As that you posted your note 5 months ago, hopefully you have learned that it can be refrigerated, and that refrigerated starter has to be used at least once a month to be healthy.
Also, some hardcore individuals keep a batch at room temperature at all times, but this means endless daily feeding and multiplying stocks unless you have a bakery. There are many online sites for care of your starter.
Nov 6, 2011. 8:35 PMmuhu22 says:
This recipe rocks! I made a beautiful (huge) round the 1st time out...with a VERY finicky starter. So few recipes fulfill their promises, this baby exceeded all expectations. Thanks a mil!
Oct 12, 2011. 12:11 AMdross9 says:
I created a PDF containing just the condensed recipe, for easy reference. In case anyone else would like to use it:

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/15572309/Crusty%20Sourdough%20Bread.pdf
Oct 10, 2011. 12:03 AMdross9 says:
This work really well- it's a huuuuuuuge recipe though. I halve it and the resulting loaf is still pretty generious.
Jun 25, 2011. 5:55 AM=3;04:>IQ:>20 2>;D says:
Mine is in the oven right now (followed this recipe).. I hope it turns out well! :) It sure is a huge loaf!
Sep 8, 2011. 4:41 PMnmilo1 says:
how'd it turn out?
Aug 30, 2011. 1:36 PMrpierce2 says:
I have to admit, at first I was a bit skeptical that my bread would not come out using these instructions but the fourth batch is now in the oven. My partner devoured most of a half loaf to himself. I took a double batch loaf to work and everyone loved it. The most exciting part is my second rise for this loaf ended up being longer than the first (because I fell asleep) but it seems to be doing just fine in the dutch oven. I love it. I don't think I will use another method.

My starter was a week old when I made this bread and the first loafs were so tangy and sour and ridiculously spongy; it was amazing. The second batch had been retarded in the fridge because the kitchen was too warm for my timing and the bread turned out fine, just not as sour/spongy.

Looking for the results i got on my first bake so I've got my fingers crossed for 15 more minutes. If it isn't the same as the first time, then in the future I will leave the amount of starter needed out instead of in the fridge, as that use of the starter had never been refrigerated.

I want to start another batch but am now out of flour. I've gone through 15 lbs of flour this week.
Jun 3, 2011. 10:46 AMMichiganBelle says:
Made my starter. Made this recipe and the huge loaf and multiple ungiven bits of my starter have consumed my kitchen! : [[ Oh mann. What do you do with it all?
May 12, 2011. 7:39 AMbowow0807 says:
i have made my own sourdough starter, here is what i did-
using equal parts flour to water mix well both at room temperature mix well then cover and leave for 2 days, after that add half of equal parts flour and water to your original mix then wait another 2 days, after that remove about half don't be precise just eyeball it and replenish, repeat the last step twice more and you have a starter. just add equal parts water and flour to replenish it after you use it

notes*
first-use whole wheat or preferably rye flour because the processed stuff will have the yeasts in it killed when packed so use those kinds of flour.

second-you will know that it is a healthy starter when it is bubbly and slightly runnier than when you mixed it and smell a bit sour then it is healthy, but to be sure that it is producing CO2 to let the bread rise cover your container with plastic wrap and if the plastic cover rises then it is healthy.

third-in the first or second replenish don't be scared of the unusual smell coming from it it is normal it will pass.

fourth- if you find that the starter has a gray/blackish fluid sitting on the top, that is normal just pour out he liquid and replenish as normal before using.

fifth- and finally if you wont be planning to bake for a while place you starter in the fridge to slow down the buggers and to allow moderate feeding.

Have Fun!

Reference-
sourdough 101 thefreshloaf.com
May 3, 2011. 10:23 PMrhdaviso says:
hey, i was wondering how you get the shape of your bread in the last picture. It doesn't have the ridged edges of the rectangular one. What pan are you using?
Apr 9, 2011. 1:33 PMNaturalCrafter says:
Your instructions were great and who can not want to start making bread right away. This got the family involved and making bread together. Now my helpers ask.. How is the starter doing?
Mar 16, 2011. 6:11 PMbonfire817 says:
Just wanted to drop a note to say thank you so much for this great instructable. I tried it when I was green to breadmaking and it turned out ok, but really burnt. Several months later and with a trusty oven thermometer (my oven runs 50 degrees hotter than the setting!!) I have been experimenting with various recipes, but came back to your instructible. I just made a loaf and it is WONDERFUL! The whole house smells lovely! Thank YOU!!
Feb 16, 2010. 12:53 PMlthomsen says:
 Thank you for this instructible! I have been using it for a couple weeks and while my first batches turned out too 'doughy' and wet, my most recent batch worked best. I added a bit more flour so it was a dryer dough.  Then I baked it longer than instructed.  Thank you again for the detailed instructions with pictures! I love it!
Feb 6, 2011. 4:14 PMtoklatkate says:
The relative humidity in your area will make the dough moister or drier. I lived in Alaska, where the air is dry, but not as dry as Arizona!, then moved to Kentucky with more humidity, and now, Southern Alabama, which is even more humid. I found that my dough will be different in each of those places because of the difference in humidity. But I also found here in Alabama, that if I add enough flour to make my dough feel like it did in Alaska, that my final product turned out too dry. So be careful about adding too much extra flour.

Another note about where you live: elevation... or how close or far from sea level you are will make the dough, and maybe the sourdough rise faster or more slowly. So length of time for raising or proofing could be different.
Apr 29, 2010. 2:53 PMalpine111 says:
I just found this discussion. The info is pretty good (except for the Baker's yeast addition). I own a sourdough bakery and currently make over 13,000 lbs. of sourdough bread monthly.

I wrote a paper on sourdough for new employees; I found people who don't understand sourdough can't make good sourdough. I'll post it here if it fits:

 

What is Sourdough Starter

Sourdough starter is a working culture of yeast and lactobacillus that flourish together. The lactobacillus produces the sour flavor; the yeast causes the bread to rise. The microorganism community in a good starter is pretty special. Not only must the strains of yeast and bacteria thrive on flour and water only, but they should also not compete for the same nutrients in the flour. The strain of lactobacillus must also be tolerant of the anti-bacterial effect of the alcohol the yeast produces; and the strain of yeast must be tolerant of the acidity the lactobacillus produces. Since the lactobacillus works slowly, the yeast in the culture must also be slow acting. For this reason, some of the best, most perfectly balanced sourdough cultures have been handed down for generations, are closely guarded, and are very old.

NOTE: Do you want a good sourdough starter? Go to www.sourdo.com. They inventory and preserve many excellent (and some very old) starters for everyone to enjoy. I tried several over the years while a hobbiest, I personally recommend the Ischia Island starter in the Italian package.


 

Want way too much information? Read On.

The sourdough lactobacillus is a bacteria similar to (but not the same as) the dairy lactobacillus strains used to produce the sour flavor in sour cream and yogurt, and the lactobacillus strains used to make vinegar. The dairy fermentation process produces mostly lactic acid; the vinegar fermentation process produces mostly acidic acid. The fermenting sourdough lactobacillus produces both lactic and acidic acids, giving sourdough it’s unique sour taste. The lactic acid provides the mellow, good aftertaste sour; the acidic acid gives you the sharp, in your face sour.

 

The lactobacillus also produces a bonus: It actually predigests the flour to a certain degree while producing enzymes that help human digestive systems digest not only the bread, but many foods eaten with the bread as well. Some people with gluten and wheat digestive issues claim they can eat sourdough with little or no problem.

 

The slow fermenting yeast (yeast is a fungi in the mushroom family), produces not only some flavor, but most importantly, the carbon dioxide gas necessary to make the bread rise.

 

Currently, about 1,500 Yeast species have been described; it is estimated that this number represents 1% of all yeast species. The genus Lactobacillus currently consists of over 125 species and encompasses a wide variety of organisms. (i.e. Huskies and Chihuahuas are members of the same species, but are not particularly interchangeable.) Capturing the best wild yeast and wild lactobacillus to create an excellent starter is purely a matter of luck. Again; this is why some of the best commercial starters are closely guarded and very old. (Some people believe starter "acclimates" to an area and the various DNA somehow magically mutate to become the same as all the other starters in the same geographical area........Completely incorrect.)

 

Commercial baker’s yeast is a strain developed to feed on all the food elements in flour and produce a fast consistent rise. The down side is that baker’s yeast produces very little flavor (and no enzymes). Almost all of the flavor in regular bread comes from additives such as sugar, milk, oils, eggs, etc., etc.

NOTE: If a "sourdough" bread label lists vinegar as an additive and does not list starter, it’s artificially soured standard bread dough with zero of the above health benefits. (I’ve seen both vinegar and starter listed, I can’t imagine why, except to prop-up a really inadequate or incorrectly used starter.)

 

Sourdough needs no additives; although combining the sourdough flavor with: nuts, dried fruits, honey, onion, herbs, spices, etc., while not required, is certainly not a bad idea!

 

In short: Sourdough is simply the best bread in the World...And the best bread for you...Period!

Feb 6, 2011. 4:01 PMtoklatkate says:
The long explanation of sourdough was wonderful! thanks for sharing that.

I have made sourdough bread off & on for years, but have used store bought yeast to start it.

Apr 29, 2010. 4:04 PMalpine111 says:
One more comment, We DO knead; the first rise is two hours @ 90f; the dough is then rolled-out into loaves; the second rise is five or six hours @ 90f.

But, that's using our 95 yo+ starter. Every starter has its own set of rules: Slow lactobacillus / fast yeast = retard yeast a lot, long proof will kill yeast. Slow lactobacillus and yeast = do not retard yeast very much, can proof much longer.

If you don't start with a good starter, no rule will work.
Dec 4, 2010. 2:16 PMstr8jacket says:
How come my starter looks so different than yours? Hmmmmmmm. Mine is more like Playdough mixed with a bottle of Elmers glue.....really thick and sticky. I have to cut it with a knife to get out 1 cup to make the sourdough bread. Yours looks more liquid. Am I doing something wrong? I bought the starter from King Arthur and followed the directions to a "T". It is obviously alive....bubbling and all, it's just super thick. Should I add some more water? I am just about to make my very first bread! I read your instructable at least six months ago and have thought about it every single day since! I am baking breads for Christmas presents this year. Maybe you would be willing to teach us how to make those fancy sourdough tops like you have pictured on your starter page??????

Thanks for this amazing instructable!!

~Leesa B
Taos, NM
Oct 18, 2010. 8:35 PMDavidLaPlante says:
Hello every one my name is David and I make sourdough and I made this movie. I was wondering if anyone was interested in watching. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNNwzt8eoTQ
Oct 5, 2010. 6:48 AMpcline2 says:
I have a quick question for anyone out there. I know you should not use metal utensils with the starter, but i was wondering about using them with the bread. i have a small kitchen and using my stand mixer would make the whole process a lot easier. thanks
Oct 18, 2010. 8:34 PMDavidLaPlante says:
Absoulutley, you could use a metal bowl for just mixing. The key is not to let it sit in the metal bowl. Although I still don't recomend this because it seems to feel more personal when you use ceramics and wood. In closing go ahead use metal as long as the dough is not going to be setting in the metal bowl for a long time. Now, here's a movie how I make sourdough.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNNwzt8eoTQ
May 9, 2009. 2:15 AMKairah says:
Note for the bake temperature, that in Europe we don't use Fahrenheit but Celcius.

450F = 232 C
Sep 22, 2010. 5:25 AMgamya says:
A simple thumb rule at baking temperatures level is simply to half the F temp. to get C temp. 500F = 250C (actual is 260C), 450F = 225C (actual is 232C),
400F = 200C (actual is 204C), 350F = 175C (actual is 177C), 300F = 150C (actual is 149F).

Gamya
May 17, 2009. 3:02 PMlil jon168 says:
lol you put urs on 450 celcius
1-40 of 136next »

Pro

Get More Out of Instructables

Already have an Account?

close

All Steps Viewing
View all steps of an Instructable on the same page when you're a Pro Member.

Upgrade to Pro today!
54
Followers
2
Author:My Sisters Kitchen
I'm Barb, one of two sisters who live in two different states, cook in two different kitchens, and each raise our own families. In a larger sense, though, we Share a Kitchen. We're bound together by ...
more »