Step 1: Materials and tools

To make the Bolt puzzle you will need:

A left-handed bolt (For size, look at the picture) and matching nut.
(By the way you can also use a right-handed bolt if you don't have any left-handed bolts, I have used a right-handed bolt and not had any one guess it thus far. However the puzzle will no doubt work better with a left-handed bolt.)
A split washer (Notice that I split it more, see picture).

Tools:
A file for metal.
A saw for metal.
Pliers.
A welder.
A vise.

Optional:
Drill with wire brush attachment.



Housedog says: Dec 18, 2010. 9:02 AM
Really cool! I finally have an excuse to buy that welder I've been wanting for years. Nobody would figure this out, unless by accident.
FriendOfHumanity says: Dec 19, 2010. 2:58 AM
I like this a lot .... I'm making one today.... the notches are very good touch.
Mattrox (author) in reply to FriendOfHumanityDec 19, 2010. 11:01 AM
Yeah they distract the person doing it. When they look at it they see the notches and immediatly think it is part of the puzzle.
FriendOfHumanity says: Dec 22, 2010. 10:03 AM
I was skeptical that anyone would fall for this but I had to find out.

I made it with slots that go right over and through the head and a washer that almost makes it possible ( the leading upper edge of the washer and the angle of the slots make the person actually tighten the bolt as they try to get the washer off).

Anyhoo, the results are as follows:

1- 11 Year old girl; solved in 5 minutes.
2- Woman with no real mechanical background; solved in 2 minutes.
3- Male mechanic; gave up after 30 minutes.
4- Another male mechanic; gave up after 20 minutes.

It is very funny watching the disgust they have with themselves as they are told the solution.
robosilo says: Dec 24, 2010. 3:15 PM
this was a funny project. I had funny building it and fun watching people try and solve it. it made for a great stocking stuffer too.
SenKat says: Dec 27, 2010. 5:30 AM
DIABOLICAL !!!!! I LOVE it ! I've seen this 'ible a few times and never read it - VERY Glad I read it today, though ! :) Thanks for the entertainment, I cannot wait to try this one out of my Mom and Dad ! Wooo-hooo ! ESPECIALLY my arrogant, "holier-than-thou" Brother ! Muahahahahahaha ! Thank you VERY much - 5 out of 5 !
Mattrox (author) in reply to FriendOfHumanityApr 29, 2011. 4:38 PM
Yeah this puzzle is great because to most it is illogical. They look at it and see a bolt welded to a nut, "obviously" the nut will not come off. A mechanic is going to see the weld and imediately assume the nut ain't going nowhere. Whereas someone with less knowledge will try anything.
scraptopower says: Aug 16, 2011. 12:53 AM
You should make one that can't be opened at all, and one that can. Alternate between giving the dud one out and solving the real one , would it drive everyone crazy ? :o
Mattrox (author) in reply to scraptopowerNov 30, 2011. 11:32 PM
Good idea!
c3ralki1l3r says: Dec 5, 2012. 8:36 PM
could i use jb weld ?
Mattrox (author) in reply to c3ralki1l3rDec 11, 2012. 6:55 PM
I'm sure that would work. :)
ALogan97 says: Dec 20, 2010. 12:08 PM
that's awesome! would soldering work instead of welding though?
jadronx in reply to ALogan97Dec 23, 2011. 8:18 AM
it will work fine if you have a nice hot torch
arpruss says: Dec 3, 2011. 7:51 PM
Wow: I had no idea left-handed bolts were so expensive. Fastenal's 1/4-20 left-handed bolts start at about $11.58 .  McMaster-Carr's prices are in the same range.  Has anybody found a cheaper source?
tech dawg says: Dec 2, 2011. 5:32 PM
this is amazingly clever ....................I LOVE IT!!!:D
tpartic-gray says: Sep 17, 2011. 3:21 AM
one drop of superglue will do the trick if you dont have a welder
Wasagi says: Aug 27, 2011. 7:50 PM
I really like this idea!
dreamberry says: Aug 15, 2011. 6:51 PM
My buddy made one of these and left it at my house, I leave it out during parties and watch people go nuts trying to figure it out. It's a good trick, but it's almost reached the saturation point, where not too many people Haven't seen it, around here at least.
jpnagle59 says: Jul 21, 2011. 11:23 AM
Nice brain candy...I wonder if Loc-Tight woud work? I was also going to say that you could get a Uni-Strut nut (1") in length, and Loc-Tight to hold the end welded piece, with out having to use a welder. The suggestion of GB weld is a good one.
Cubie2 says: Apr 28, 2011. 9:01 AM
Ha! I love puzzles like this where the solution has nothing to do with what everyone thinks it is!!
improyo says: Apr 21, 2011. 7:52 PM
great idea i made one and no ones guesed it yet....
josht says: Mar 23, 2011. 4:54 PM
I would really like to make one of these, but I cannot for the life of me find a left handed bolt. Where is everyone getting theirs?
Ivan Denisovitch says: Jan 23, 2011. 12:21 AM
Great puzzle! I made one and my boss still hasn't figured it out. It seems to help that I cut a few different notches on the bolt head, so people keep trying to find the "right" one.
davidpeck says: Jan 18, 2011. 7:55 AM
I made this for my 10 year old son for Christmas. I didn't do a good job setting up the scenario so he solved it by accident, but he's had a blast foisting it on others. Fun little trick puzzle.
jackatronix says: Jan 8, 2011. 8:55 AM
surely they would work out that they need to unscrew the nut
and when they do the small piece of the bolt will come off with it
then they can just slide the washer off of the big piece of the bolt
codongolev says: Dec 21, 2010. 1:40 PM
on the other website, it said to buy a left- hand bolt. that seems to make more sense, because I would think that the first instinct people would have (even seeing the weld) would be to try to unscrew the bolt, which would ruin it.
nimster64 in reply to codongolevJan 6, 2011. 9:33 AM
thats a great idea also. so if they try to unscrew it they are tightening it LOL
nimster64 says: Jan 6, 2011. 9:31 AM
the weld is there as a illusion to make the victim think that the nut is welded to the bolt so it can't unscrew and the only way out is through the head of the bolt. that will prevent the victim to try to unscrew it. LOL great Job I must make one
ybilou says: Dec 21, 2010. 2:37 PM
-- READ THIS--

For this to work, you need to use a left hand bold (reverse thread). Otherwise it is quite easy to unscrew instintively.
MaXoR says: Dec 19, 2010. 7:00 PM
What stops a guy from simply twisting the bolt during his attempt to take the washer off? I know the first thing I would do is try to take off the nut, and during that process, what is going to stop me from then accidentally unscrewing it? Especially since you state it's possible for the original person to just twist it off behind their back.

This seems like a game that only works on people with an IQ under 70. So I would find a way to not have the "prey" be able to open it, and WAY MORE important than that is... you MUST have UNIFORM color on the bolt!! Anyone with an IQ over mentally disabled, will wonder why there are two colors. (And if they think far enough that the WELD discolored it, then why would the other side not also be discolored. I think the JB weld would work the best, since it can be hidden better, and won't discolor the bolt sections)
Nelson_Yepez in reply to MaXoRDec 21, 2010. 1:08 PM
The point is that they see the weld so they wont even try to unscrew it because is WELDED. Your idea of using JB weld is a good idea (not), you should do it and then you can use it on people with an IQ of under 40 that also think is a good idea.
ss3e55 in reply to MaXoRDec 20, 2010. 7:21 AM
That's correct! The person writing this has missed the single most important part of the puzzle....its supposed to be a left handed thread bolt that you start with.

The site where they took the puzzle from explains it properly, and they were nice enough to quote that orign.

Incidentally this seems just like a reprint of that one - albeit with photos of their own model.

Next time they should read the original more carefully and understand the puzzle...obviously without a left handed bolt this is trivial.
laptop_geek in reply to MaXoRDec 19, 2010. 8:47 PM
Never learned about heat transfer did you? The other side could easily not be discolored because the bolt absorbed enough heat to keep the other side cool.

If you tighten the nut so that it is not easily removed (but not enough that you can't undo it) then it'll be fine. the weld also keeps people from trying to remove it (looks like its stuck), JB weld would not have as good as an effect.
jadronx in reply to laptop_geekDec 23, 2011. 8:16 AM
it looks better when both sides have been fired...it looks uniform and clean
jinxleah says: Dec 21, 2010. 7:16 AM
Wonderful trick!

A classmate of mine made this. He slanted the notch to make it appear that if you twist the washer just so, and get it in just the right position, it will easily come off. He also made the weld very obvious, so we "knew" that it wouldn't just screw off. In a class full of metallurgists none of us, including the teacher, were able to figure it out. When he simply unscrewed it, we were all thunderstruck. And quite a few of us ran to our welders to make one for ourselves!

Also, for those reading this comment who want to learn welding, check with your local community college! They may have classes, and from what I've found, they've got excellent rates! My community college's credit hours cost less the $40. Also, a very cheap welder will cost you about $100, and you can probably find YouTube videos of someone using that exact welder.
moosamech says: Dec 21, 2010. 2:12 AM
hi 2 al
qorlis says: Dec 20, 2010. 3:06 PM
I have one of these with notches cut into the threads instead of the head. If you do this, be sure the notches can't allow the washer to slip off when your "victim" works on the puzzle. Basically, they give the same impression as the notches in the head. In fact, you could do both.
awz123 says: Dec 20, 2010. 2:42 PM
Dang, too bad all my friends visit instructables everyday, I would really enjoy seeing them attempt to figure this one out...
atomicturkey27 says: Dec 18, 2010. 1:55 PM
I love this! if only i had a welder...
jamieinvents in reply to atomicturkey27Dec 20, 2010. 7:00 AM
Yeah, thats what i thought too cause im only 14 but the two things i did were either use a oplastic toy bolt and melt it or when i made a mettal one i used epoxy rather than welding
FriendOfHumanity in reply to atomicturkey27Dec 19, 2010. 2:56 AM
You could drill a hole where the weld would be and put a split pin through instead.
atomicturkey27 in reply to FriendOfHumanityDec 19, 2010. 2:46 PM
Thats a good idea now i think i might have to make this!
beehard44 in reply to atomicturkey27Dec 21, 2010. 7:47 AM
JB weld? Solder? Brazing?
buckminsterfullerene says: Dec 20, 2010. 4:26 AM
Amazing! at first I didn't get that it was only one bolt (as it is supposed to look) but I finally figured it out. Nice job! Also, doesn't the website call for a left-hand bolt, as in one with threads turning in the opposite direction? This would make it more challenging to figure out as most people would have it stuck in their heads to turn counterclockwise to loosen when they actually have to turn it clockwise.
skimmo says: Dec 20, 2010. 3:38 AM
ied love to make one that didnt come apart
dwells98 says: Dec 17, 2010. 5:32 PM
thats cool but when the las picture is shown were are the welds what do youdo please let me know
Mattrox (author) in reply to dwells98Dec 17, 2010. 6:30 PM
the weld is on the back so you can only just see it. Is what you wanted to know?
dwells98 in reply to MattroxDec 19, 2010. 5:16 PM
well do you let them know it is supose to be welded together when in fact its bot?
dwells98 in reply to dwells98Dec 19, 2010. 5:19 PM
i meant to say not sorry
jmanatee says: Dec 19, 2010. 12:48 PM
Very cool, Neither my son or my wife could figure it out :0
savant77 says: Dec 19, 2010. 7:59 AM
Wow, I never thought this would work, but it seems completely mind boggling to some members, so I guess it does.... I just don't see how a person can mess with this for more than 30 seconds and not try to unscrew it, I guess you tighten it back together pretty tight?

Cool puzzle
Mattrox (author) in reply to savant77Dec 19, 2010. 11:05 AM
You can give the end of the bolt that's going into the nut(The nut that is welded to the small piece of bolt) a couple taps with a hammer this makes it harder for the bolt to be unscrewed.
CimarronWarrior says: Dec 19, 2010. 10:52 AM
you could also use a dab of JB Weld to secure the nut and piece of bolt
blanchae says: Dec 19, 2010. 10:40 AM
You may be able to solder the nut on the bolt using a torch and plumbing solder/flux if you don't have a welder. Do a sloppy job so that it is obvious that it is soldered on.
cowskey says: Dec 19, 2010. 10:15 AM
Instead of welding, use super glue.
handy157 says: Dec 19, 2010. 9:46 AM
This looks really intimidating when you use a bolt that is 1/2" in diameter and 3" long!
handy157 says: Nov 24, 2009. 8:30 PM
Before cutting the bolt, screw the nut on so just past the point where you want to cut the bolt. Put the bolt into the vise so that the head is held by the vise and the nut is tight against the side of the vise. Then hack saw the bolt with the nut as a guide for the blade. Once cut, unscrew the nut and it will automatically clean up the first thread of the bolt that gets a little screwed up by the saw. This makes getting the nut on and off easier. Then just screw the not on from the 'good' end of the remaining part of the bolt to the position you want for welding it.
jlipimpski says: Dec 19, 2010. 8:23 AM
Very clever. I'm making this to annoy my dad with now.
zakamooza says: Dec 19, 2010. 7:31 AM
(removed by author or community request)
shveet in reply to zakamoozaDec 19, 2010. 7:43 AM
did you read the instructable?
iac says: Dec 17, 2010. 7:06 PM
On the back?
If you hand the thing to someone, and they move it around; they'll see the weld !
Grinding it off wont work either !
Mattrox (author) in reply to iacDec 17, 2010. 9:25 PM
The weld is meant to be seen, when you look at the bolt it doesn't look like it is made of two pieces. So you don't know to unscrew it. Are you following Me? To them it looks like you have put a split washer on a bolt and welded a nut on top you can't get the nut off.
shveet in reply to MattroxDec 19, 2010. 7:36 AM
when i seen that you had to cut the bolt, i instantly got it. cleaver puzzle, i might try to make one.
kasssa says: Dec 19, 2010. 6:40 AM
Great joke! Now I know what I'll do with some of my time off this week! :-)

Instead of a welder, people might be able to use a blowtorch (or something similar to heat up the nut and piece cut from the bolt) and some solder.
jaipai says: Dec 17, 2010. 7:59 PM
Nice Ible and geat pics,but you forgot to mention to use a LEFT handedbolt and nut!!
Mattrox (author) in reply to jaipaiDec 17, 2010. 9:17 PM
It would be better to use one but, I don't have any. Thanks :o)
I3uckwheat says: Dec 17, 2010. 7:54 PM
you could also say that is there so you cant take the bolt off then the washer
lemonie says: Dec 17, 2010. 4:58 AM
It would be good to explain how the puzzle / challenge is presented to a person, or mention tt it's in the pdf.
Good build and pictures

L
Mattrox (author) in reply to lemonieDec 17, 2010. 12:05 PM
Thanks I totally forgot.
lafnbear in reply to MattroxDec 17, 2010. 1:52 PM
Yeah, I was with lemonie before, and OK, I think I kinda get it now, but... do you mean "ask him to remove the washer. (without bending the washer)" AND without removing the nut?

If so, how does "he" know you didn't remove the nut behind your back?

Nice idea, and nice work on the build, but I think it still needs something (but I'm not sure what/how) on the execution... I'll let you know if I think of something.
Mattrox (author) in reply to lafnbearDec 17, 2010. 4:18 PM
Your victim doesn't know that the bolt is made of two parts thus he wont know you can remove the nut because it looks like it is welded on.
DIY Dave in reply to lafnbearDec 17, 2010. 2:04 PM
Your victim will see the the weld on the bolt and think the nut is welded on (and thus unremovable).
cowscankill says: Dec 17, 2010. 3:45 PM
Oh! I get it now, that's awesome!
Pro

Get More Out of Instructables

Already have an Account?

close

PDF Downloads
As a Pro member, you will gain access to download any Instructable in the PDF format. You also have the ability to customize your PDF download.

Upgrade to Pro today!