Use Your Overgrown Cucumbers! (Candied Cinnamon Pickles)

Picture of Use Your Overgrown Cucumbers! (Candied Cinnamon Pickles)
A few years ago I was "shooting the breeze" with my neighbor about our gardening adventures that year. She mentioned that while away on vacation her cucumbers became overgrown and she had to sadly throw them to the birds. Upon hearing this I cried inside...o.k. not really... but I don't like hearing about perfectly good food going to waste, especially if it can be used to make something fantastically delicious! I then shared this family recipe with her to make good use of those monster cucumbers. I've decided to also share it here on instructables in hopes to save countless cucumbers from a bird pecked death!

Candied Cinnamon Pickles involve a several day process, but they are worth the wait. They are a sweet & sour taste combination, with a little bit of heat. They taste very similar to a candied apple, and as a child I ate these like candy.  I've also heard them be called Christmas Pickles because they are a lovely red color & make perfect Christmas gifts. So don't throw those whoppers out, gift them away!
Remove these adsRemove these ads by Signing Up

Step 1: Gather Supplies

Picture of Gather Supplies
This was a recipe I was "playing close to the vest" because it's been handed down for many generations in our family but through recent research I see there are others who make the same or similar thing so I don't feel as guilty sharing it.(The cat is already out of the bag) To make these pickles you will need:

Crisping Solution:
*2 gallons of overgrown cucumbers (about 8-10 large ones)
1 cup pickling lime (NOT PICKLING SALT) 
1 tsp. Alum
2 cups vinegar NOTE:It has since been discovered that mixing the lime & vinegar can be a food safety issue. Like I said, this is an OLD recipe. So you can just replace the vinegar with water if you wish. In generations of making these we have never had any problems with it of course, but just thought I'd give the disclosure. 

Candy Syrup :
2 cups vinegar
2 cups water
10 cups sugar
16 oz. red hots (I've used anywhere from  14 oz - 20 oz)
8 sticks of cinnamon
OPTIONAL: Red food coloring

5 gallon food storage bucket for pickling them in (If you are concerned about using the plastic use glass containers. Again, this is just our OLD SCHOOL method)

Jars, lids, & bands for canning (about a 8 pints) 
Water bath canner

tara.sturgis.9433 minutes ago
My grandmas neighbor made these once when I was younger and they were amazing.
Anyways I was wondering if the water bath at the end was suppose to be hot or cold.
I can't wait to try this for myself!
I made these last week about to make more this week. oh so good but if u eat to many u get a tummy ache.
mygibzone (author)  mommasliltimberwolf5 months ago

Yes, they are pretty easy to "overdose" on! :)

I'm so happy I could cry right now. My great grandmother used to make these all the time and when she got around 97 years old she stopped, she forgot the recipe and when she passed away at 103 in May this year I thought all hope was lost of me ever having these treats again. Nobody else in my family knew the right way to make them (not even my grandma). You have just made my whole year with this thank you so much!!!
That's so wonderful! I think it's sad when great recipes get "lost" through the generations. I'm glad that I can help you preserve a family tradition & treat. :)
fretted2 years ago
You can force the redness into the cukes by pressure cooking them for ten minutes or so in the mason jar just remember the more pressure the softer the pickles unless you alum them heavily
mygibzone (author)  fretted2 years ago
Yes, that would work too. Just from the candies & the soaking process they turn red anyways. I left the food coloring optional because I like the color without it but It's all just preference. Thanks for the post & Have a fantastic Holiday season!
bajablue2 years ago
Ok... I faved this because I have just GOT to try it... but do the cukes have to be huge? Will regular-sized cukes work?
mygibzone (author)  bajablue2 years ago
Regular sized ones will work. For this "ible" I used regular sized store bought ones because It's not exactly cucumber season right now. :) They tend to break apart easier through all the processing so you have to be gentler. Plus they won't be as crisp because they cook faster. Maybe just simmer them for about 1 hour instead of 2.
rickharris2 years ago
we may be a bit Quirky in the UK but cucumbers here are around a foot to 18 inches long! We slice them to eat with salads. Weird!
mygibzone (author)  rickharris2 years ago
It's always interesting to see what others are doing around the world. There are all sorts of different kinds of cucumbers. Each have characteristics that make them preferable for different things. Last year I grew lemon cucumbers, which wouldn't work well for this recipe, but they made some fantastic relish. If you want to try this recipe try to find a variety of cucumber that is very fleshy without many seeds, or try it with watermelon rinds (something I'm planing on experimenting with), but I'm not sure they would turn out as crisp. Happy Creating in the UK! :)
KohdCilver2 years ago
My family makes these all the time. They are so amazing. I can eat a whole mason jar of these things in under and hour not even trying. And for the record, I dislike pickles quite a bit, but these things are just great.
mygibzone (author)  KohdCilver2 years ago
I'm not a pickle or a cinnamon fan either, but I love these things!
Stonehopper2 years ago
We have made these in the past only our recipe called them Mock Apple Rings.
WhiteLiger2 years ago
My grandmother used to make these when i was a kid. There are fabulous. Thanks for posting.
bajablue2 years ago
You're a certifiable GENIUS, Gib...

These look and sound delicious!!!
mygibzone (author)  bajablue2 years ago
Thank you! I can't take all the credit. It's a family tradition. I'll chalk it up to an awesome up-bringing. :)
suayres2 years ago
They sound yummy. Do they have a crispy texture, or are they soft, like pickled watermelon rind (also yummy) or "slippery pickles" (yet another yummy, which goes back many generations on my Dad's side of the family)?
mygibzone (author)  suayres2 years ago
They are very CRISPY. I've considered trying to apply this recipe to watermelon rinds to see how it would work out but haven't attempted it yet. I Haven't ever heard of the slippery pickles so I'm not sure what those are like, but these are not slippery in texture if that's what you are asking. I guess you could say they have the crunch & texture of a fresh cucumber only with a sweet & sour cinnamon flavor absorbed into them.
This sounds so crazy! I've never heard of these. They're very pretty, and I bet they would be really refreshing. :)
mygibzone (author)  jessyratfink2 years ago
They are very good, especially if you are a cinnamon fan! I just like being able to make good use of even the really large cucumbers from my garden.