Picture of coconut pie

This coconut pie is really quick and easy to whip up, though be warned - it's got to cool for a while before you chow down! Probably best to make it in the morning before you decide you NEED coconut pie.

This coconut pie recipe comes from Taste of Home, though I've altered it a teeny bit. The ladies over there truly know a thing or two about pies. Especially coconut ones!


Remove these adsRemove these ads by Signing Up

Step 1: Ingredients:

Picture of Ingredients:


  • 1 cup raw, shredded & unsweetened coconut
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 1 1/2 cups milk
  • 3 tablespoons flour
  • 1 tablespoon butter, melted
  • 2 eggs, beaten
  • 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • pinch of salt
  • pie crust (cheating today and using a ready made one!)

Probably all things you've got on hand. :D


Step 2: Mixing & prepping the crust

Picture of Mixing & prepping the crust

Mix together all the ingredients in a large bowl with a whisk - breaking up any clumps of flour, sugar or coconut that forms. :)

Get your crust into the pie plate and finish is however you like. I always fold over the edges and then press them with a fork. I also like to prick the bottom and sides to make sure I don't have any air bubbles.

One the filling the crust are prepped, pour the mixture into the crust! (yes, it is very runny! I promise it will firm up.)

Step 3: Baking!

Picture of Baking!

Bake your pie at 350 F for 50-60 minutes. A knife inserted in the middle will come out clean when it's done. This pie is super wobbly when cooked through, so don't let that worry you. Once it cools slightly it will flatten out and firm out.

Let it cool down to room temperature before chowing down. It will cut much better at that point!

Enjoy on its own or with whipped cream - it's delicious either way :D

P.S. Be sure to store leftovers in the fridge! 

Opticallusion5 months ago

wonder if you could substitute the milk and vanilla with vanilla almond milk? My roommate is lactose intolerant (though baked goods don't affect him as much) but I know almond milk isn't always a good substitute for "regular" milk. And I've not enough experience with baking to just assume it'd work lol. Might just give it a try and see what happens!

I made this, but forgot to take pictures. I upgraded the crust to a graham cracker crust. It was awesome, thanks.
I topped it with coconut frosting. http://www.instructables.com/id/coconut-oil-frosting/

PitStoP1 year ago

Ummm... Coconut, my favorite food. Yummyyy

Just the Idea of coconut in Pie watered my mouth Jessy :). I love it.

aorrason1 year ago
Why is this in the laser contest
jessyratfink (author)  aorrason1 year ago

Because our Full Spectrum Laser Contest is open to any and all entries! All categories are eligible, including food. :)

Your a wickedly great cook!

skåur71 year ago

It looks so yummy! I will definitely try to make it by myself.

Yum! This looks great! I am such a sucker for coconut things, I might have to make this sometime soon...