Introduction: Repairing a Rust Hole in a Car

Picture of Repairing a Rust Hole in a Car

My husband's car had developed a large rust hole in the fender under the gas cap. 

It needed to be fixed before the winter, and my husband hadn't had the free time to repair it himself; and I didn't want to pay the $150-200 to have it done by a body shop.

So I figured I'd do it myself and surprise him.

Step 1: Scrape and Sand

Picture of Scrape and Sand

The first step was to scrape off the loose paint surrounding the rust spot, and to sand off most of the rust.

I found, under the outer layer of metal, what I thought were additional layers of rusted, chipping metal, was actually dense foam padding. I scraped the rest of the metal chips off of the foam. I then taped off the area, and sprayed it with a rust treatment.

Following the directions on the can, I allowed the rust treatment to remain on overnight before I continued. (Rust treatment goes on clear, dries black.)

 On day 2, I again sanded around the area, removing paint around the hole to prepare it to be built up. For rust and paint removal, I used a 60 grit sandpaper.

Step 2: Building Up (part 1)

Picture of Building Up (part 1)

At this point, I used a metal mesh body patch (bondo brand) to fill the hole, replace the missing metal, and give the bondo a place to adhere to.

Using regular scissors, I cut the mesh to approximately the right shape, and then began fitting it into the hole between the metal and the foam. Along the bottom, I had to loosen the foam from the metal a bit using a screwdriver. Since the area is curved, I had to shape the patch as I worked, and getting the last (upper left) corner in took some work.

The body patch is self adhesive, and has a removable backing. You can see in the photo where it crinkled up while I was maneuvering the patch into place. According to the instructions, I should have taken the patch back out, peeled off the backing, and then re-inserted it. But once I got it in and shaped, it wasn't coming back out, and I decided that I don't care if there's a plasticy sticker bit in there.

Step 3: Building Up (part 2)

Picture of Building Up (part 2)

The next step was patching the hole with bondo body filler. This was interesting, as I'd never used the stuff before.

It comes with two parts,  the body filler putty (grey), and the hardener cream (red), which you mix together, and then apply.
The instructions say to use a golf-ball sized amount of putty and an inch and a half of hardener. It said to mix on a non-porous surface, and to use within 2-3 minutes.

A few lessons learned: mix up what you can use in 30 seconds. This stuff dries fast, and isn't workable once it starts drying. After the first batch, and trying to clean my non-porous surface, I switched to a half batch mixed on wax-coated paper plates that could be thrown out. 

Apply. Allow to dry. Sand. Repeat until you're pleased with the patch.

Because the rust hole was nearing the ledge under the gas tank door, part of my repair plan was to run the repair up under the plastic edge, to protect the repair from gas or water. This made application and sanding a little tricky, but I'm pleased with the result. Hopefully, the extra work will make the repair last longer.

I allowed the patch to cure overnight before beginning the painting process.

Step 4: Primer

Picture of Primer

The next step was to apply a primer over the patch. 

I used a self etching, sandable primer, and followed the instructions on the can. I taped over the edges while I was working. Once I was done, I used a 600 grit sandpaper to soften the edge of the primer, and roughen the surrounding paint.

That's me sanding. Photo by my wonderful husband, who was not at all worried about his wife attempting auto body repair. ; )

Hand sanding takes a bit of extra time, but allowed me extra control. Here you can see that I made sure to get the primer up under the lip of the plastic. I also kept tape and newspaper over the lower (plastic) fender, as I didn't want to scratch that up while sanding the bottom edge of the metal fender.

Step 5:

Picture of

The final step was painting. The first color I used wasn't right. It looked right on the can top, when looking at the car from a few feet away and standing up; but once on, was much too light.

I picked up the next shade darker, and it matched when I placed the spray can cap against the bottom of the car, with no sunlight reflection to skew the color.

The last step was to apply a clear lacquer coat over the color paint.

Lessons I learned about painting with spraypaint:
1. Light coats, sprayed quickly
2. Don't reverse direction. Spray across, stop while moving. Spray the opposite direction, stop while moving. The slight buildup on reversing directions leads to drips that have to be sanded off and re-done.
3. The lacquer says two light coats and then a wet coat. "Wet coat" does not mean "heavier coat". A heavy coat results in bubbles. Which is a pain to remedy when you were nearly finished.

Step 6: Final Result

Picture of Final Result

So there you go. My first attempt at auto body repair.
It turned out pretty well, in my humble opinion. I learned a lot. It cost me about $60 in supplies, and some of my time over the course of three days.
My husband's pretty pleased about my little present to him, and I'm proud of myself for figuring it out.


Squash (author)2012-08-23

Wow. Well, that's a little more than I would've tackled...before seeing your project! That's pretty cool and for a first-timer, great job! I need to do some body work on my car but it's fiberglass parts. I wouldn't mind doing it myself to keep from paying uber amounts just for looks. Maybe I will try it thanks to you. :)

cal_gecko - the site has a "...'be nice' comment policy. Please be positive and constructive with your comments or risk being banned from our site. " I don't believe your post was any of these...

KittyJ (author)Squash2012-08-23

Another commenter suggested a product called Kitty Hair for fiberglass. He says it works better than bondo, even on metal. You might want to check that out or mssg him. It looks neat!

ManuelM57 (author)KittyJ2016-01-27

i have a question what did he use to sand off the rust and what brand of rust treatment did he also uses please response back i need to know immediately please and thank you.

Squash (author)KittyJ2012-08-24

I will check on that! Thanks. You wouldn't want a fiberglass-fix practice car would you? Lol.

KittyJ (author)Squash2012-08-24

Ah, for lack of free time.... ; )

CEDRICWARD (author)2012-08-24

Great work. Very well written and done.
You SHOULD be proud.
How many husbands have such a smart and capable wife?
More women should be willing to know how to fix things.
You can't always be sure there is a man around to do it for you.
And of course, the 'retail' market for fixing things (if you can even find anyone to really fix something) is absurdly costly.
We are a throw away society and will soon drown in our own junk.
Good for you on this well done instructable.
Let's hope it encourages more women to follow suit.

KittyJ (author)CEDRICWARD2012-08-24

Thank you, CedricWard!

cwickenkamp (author)2012-08-23

Not only is this lady's initiative, native good sense and intelligence commendable, but she did a good job with what she had to work with ... an older car.

Also, this instructable was very well written, she should be writing manuals! Excellent job.

One comment .. I think she underestimated the cost of a "professional" job by a factor of 3 to 5, depending on how "professional" the professional is. It costs soooo much money to get body work done.

ps. My husband and I owned an auto repair shop for over 20 years, and we made a lot of money fixing the repairs done by "professionals".

KittyJ (author)cwickenkamp2012-08-23

thank you so much, cwickenkamp!
that means a lot coming from someone with 20 years of experience!!

cwickenkamp (author)KittyJ2012-08-23

You are welcome. It's only the truth. :-)

sdereis (author)2012-08-23

It is refreshing to see how some people, like yourself takes the initiative to learn and prosper from "first time" experiences. I grew up doing what you did, trying and learning from successes and mistakes. And it has done me good for my building, repairs, jerry-rigging projects. Kudo's to you. Well done! You saved some $ and learned something that you can teach others and improve with each time you need to do it again!

KittyJ (author)sdereis2012-08-23

Thanks, sdereis. There are a lot of things a person can learn just by trying it a few times. I'm quite accomplished at painting rooms in my house now. I'm great at canning pickles. They're projects I've done dozens of times. I bet the next time I refinish a hardwood floor or a staircase, it will be faster and easier than it was the first time. The next time my husband builds a shed, it will be even better than the one we built last year. And maybe, if this car lives long enough for that patch to fail, I'll try some of the great tips people on here have offered me, and it will be even better and last longer.

But if you never try, then you never learn anything!

graveswr (author)2017-07-25

The ability to do what you accomplished is a gift from god. Many of us have it, but most do not. I spent years trying to teach the kids practical stuff, but the result was various. Some get it, some don't. Give thanks for your gift, and thank you for sharing.

Barkfin (author)2017-06-20

Terrific! I am inspired :)

I heard grey is very very hard to match exactly and I think the patch is still slightly noticeable, but miles better than the rust hole.

Kali Jennifer (author)2017-04-07

Great Job! I wish that I saw this while I still had my Durango. I wanted to fix the small rust holes myself, but didn't know how. Thanks for sharing!

bobbydee (author)2017-03-12

I would LOVE to see this car 5 years later... dont suppose there are any photos around?

KittyJ (author)bobbydee2017-03-12

No, unfortunately. It was just starting to show a tiny bit of bubbling at one edge of the patch about a year ago, and I was thinking about reworking it, when a deer took out the entire car. :( I miss that old girl.

svigness (author)2016-08-22

really great work

Midlandr (author)2016-05-04

Wonderful, thank you for your clear instructions and lessons learned!!! I have to repair a few spots on my Jeep Wrangler.

jsaarberg (author)2016-04-23

wow! You did an amazing job!!!

carolag33 (author)2016-04-12

I'm really impressed by what you were able to do. My 2000 Subaru has rust in almost the same place and when the weathers abit more cooperative, I'm going to try this. I'm pretty good at detail type of jobs so think I can do it. Thanks again for the simple yet through tips!

LeeB70 (author)2016-03-23

Where did you get the mesh?

JoeyR27 (author)2016-03-23

Congrats! Great job on the repair! Think I'll try it myself!

3of5 (author)2016-01-21

Now I need instruction for repairing a hole that is bigger than my hand and goes through the metal.

3of5 (author)2016-01-21

Now instruction for a hole that is bigger than my hand, and goes all the way through the body.

TommyT7 (author)2015-10-05

I use to do body work and I will have to say, not bad at all for your first time. But I will say that the sun does not skew the color, the shade does. The sun shows the true color. You want to match the paint to what the paint looks like in the sun. At the body shop we use a sun gun to replicate the lighting effects of the sun so we can match the paint. But kudos to you, very nice job.

irideinstyle (author)2015-09-06

Would this same process work on most rust holes? I have a small metal shelf with holes, haven't been able to find other fix instructions so far...

SitaraCreativityIsPower (author)2015-06-06

You rock! And just the advice I needed, thanks.

DavidM55 (author)2015-05-01

You are an awesome wife.

Larrym3 (author)2015-01-02

Nice post, it looks like its been a long while so how is it holding up? Super cool thing you did for your hubby! If times ever get hard maybe you could do a little patching for extra cash!

MaxineLaRue (author)2014-11-23

Your Instructable was very excellent (for me)! I'm definitely going to try it out when it warms up here a bit. Looks 'almost' fun- haha! I've got a few little spots on my beloved '99 CR-V that just keep getting bigger as the years go by. Thank you so much. Keep rockin' it, girl! Now I have some real confidence in my project.

KittyJ (author)MaxineLaRue2014-11-23

Go for it MaxineLaRue!

bob.wheeler.3979 (author)2014-10-21

Great job! Can I pay you to fix mine?

alicecaregiver (author)2014-10-17

This gives me inspiration to maybe try fixing my '99 Honda CRV myself, instead of worrying about cosmetics and spending over $1000 to the body shop. It would definitely be interesting! I've done plenty of crafts in my time--doesn't seem like it would be that much different.

khakidin (author)2014-10-17

Thanks for making it easy!

skupadupe (author)2014-10-03

This might be in the comment thread somewhere, but what supplies did you use, if you remember, of course. Or where did you find the supplies, if you don't remember exactly what you used.

altomic (author)2014-09-08

awesome. great job.

Jesusfreak! (author)2014-08-19

Straight-up G. You nailed it!

DB28704 (author)2014-06-26

Bravo KittyJ! I have seen individuals getting PAID to do this, not do as well. Very well done.

falling_stone (author)2014-02-10

patch is still on there.

jimmygman (author)2013-10-13

you are the world's best wife ever!!! Ya gotta sister??? lol

TheFamousSamWise (author)2013-09-28

Awesome job! I'll have to try it now that I know it can be done! Haha

davjon (author)2013-09-18

You.Are.Amazing. Tell your husband he better not let you go! Wow.

89JeepComanche (author)2013-09-13

Great job, especially for a first attempt. There seems to be a lot of people say you didn't do it right, but hey... if it looks good and fixed the rust (even temporarily), why worry about it being professional? That patch will probably last longer than the car.

crazy man custom cycles (author)2013-07-01

Fantastic job especially to have done it in a parking lot!

dderolph (author)2013-05-24

Well, I admire your courage to delve into this project. However, your use of the mesh backing was not the way it should have been used. The mesh is sticky on one side, the side with the paper backing. The reason for that is that the mesh is normally applied on the outside of the area being repaired, not manipulated to the inside in the manner you did. So, you would sand and remove all rust, sanding 1/2 to 1 inch beyond the edge of the hole. Then, you would cut a piece of backing to cover the hole, remove the paper backing from it, and press it onto the clean, bare metal around the hole. The sticking side of the mesh holds it in place so that you can then mix your filler and not have to hold the backing in place while applying filler. When using mesh backing and filler in this manner, spreading some filler on some wax paper and then laying the wax paper over the backing, especially for all the area of the hole, is a good way to control the thickness of the filler you apply. If you simply spread filler over the mesh with a blade-type applicator, you may press an excessive amount of filler right through the holes in the mesh.

vanwazltoff (author)2013-02-18

wish my rust cancer spots were this easy but they are quite a bit more difficult because of the positions they are i have 6 of them DX

mattxcox (author)2013-01-29

Goodness... where does one find such a sweet woman as you! lol. he reapir looks solid for a first time, im very impressed :D

Lowriderpr (author)2012-11-11

Nice Job!

mrlunna13 (author)2012-10-18

What a Lady!! Great Job!! On the car, and also for looking up for your husband!
I bet he is very proud. I know I would be.
Jesse M.

About This Instructable




More by KittyJ:repairing a rust hole in a carRefinishing an Hardwood Staircase
Add instructable to: