299Views11Replies

Author Options:

I can't identify this fish. Please Help! Answered

I have a question about fish....I don't know if anyone can answer it though... I found a fish once while fishing in southern Indiana, it looked very similar to a pike, I was fishing with a dry fly on the top of the water, the fish went under it and sucked it in. Does anyone know what kind of fish it was. And I already know it wasn't a catfish.

12 Replies

user
rogers236 (author)2012-06-11

I know you asked this quite a while ago, but this PDF (I'm from Maine) has a good identification chart on page 13 comparing chain pickerel, northern pike, and muskellunge.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
jman0998 (author)2010-09-18

jeeze people. from the description it was probably a tiger muskie. they are a hybrid of pike and muskie created by humans but they do sometimes occur in the wild

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
Re-design (author)2010-08-18
user
Jack A Lopez (author)Re-design2010-08-19

Man, that is one ugly lookin' fish! Although, come to think of it, ugliness is likely one of the criteria they look for for featuring a fish on that show.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
Re-design (author)Jack A Lopez2010-08-19

They get very large in the rivers in Texas. I used to catch them on trot lines strung across the river. I never caught any thing big though. SOME people eat them, not me.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
SabreLightning (author)Re-design2010-08-21

He'd know if it was an alligator gar. Good lord.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
Re-design (author)SabreLightning2010-08-22

A few posts down he says it looked like a gar. If you didn't see it how do you know it wasn't? Good lord.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
gmoon (author)2010-08-19

Could be a muskie. It's a game fish here in Ohio (and throughout the midwest). They used to be pretty common when I was a kid.

They are sometime called "jack pike," "Ohio River pike," etc.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
pagosapig (author)gmoon2010-08-19

you might be right...it looked very similar. I am going back to that fishing spot this weekend and I will try to get a picture of the fish

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
zascecs (author)2010-08-18

Your best description was that it looked similar to a pike? How the hell are you going to get any help with that?

Do you remember what color it was? or how big it was? If you could provide some of that, maybe someone could help...

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
pagosapig (author)zascecs2010-08-18

The fish was about a foot to a foot and a half, it was a darker shade, more like a dark green or brown. It looked similar to the alligator gar but not an close to that size

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
pagosapig (author)pagosapig2010-08-18

it looked very similar a Chain Pickerel http://www.dictionaryoffish.com/freshwater_fish_directory.htm

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer