104Views6Replies

Author Options:

REQUEST: Mark Instructable as Video Only Answered

I would REALLY like to see a feature added to Instructables that would mark projects that only contain a video as "video only."

While I don't mind watching someone do something - sometimes that will help illustrate a point better than words ever could - for the most part I like to do this really weird thing called reading. I know in this day and age, the desire to read the printed word is seen as obsolete and old-fashioned, but surely I cannot be alone in this!

If I wanted to watch videos, I'd go to youtube. 99.99% of the time, if I click on a project and it's only a video, I click off of it, but by then, not only have I wasted that time (albeit even only a few seconds), I have also increased that project's view count.

Just my two cents, worth what it is in this economy...

6 Replies

user
mtairymd (author)2017-03-13

I like to see both video and text. This is especially true if the video demonstrates the project in action. I really dislike when someone shows something that is motorized (trike, skateboard, camera slider, etc.) but doesn't show it working.

BTW, I usually skip video only projects as well.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
Kiteman (author)2017-03-13

Video-only projects are in a small and shrinking minority, so it's not that big an issue, really.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
OrigamiAirEnforcer (author)2017-03-11

There used to be notations of the types of medium the instructables used--videos being among them.

That changed at some point since 2009, though I don't know when.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
darrenah (author)2017-01-03

I agree and do the same thing! If I click an Instructable and find it's only a video; 99.99% of the time I click away.

I know what I don't like about video only instructables... Two things; one I would have to watch the video just to find out if it's something I am even interested in and two, I like getting the information at my speed, not necessarily at the speed the poster wants to deliver it.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user

That would block any instructable with a video, though, wouldn't it? Some (most?) of those also have text steps as well and I wouldn't want to block those.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer