12805Views20Replies

Author Options:

Will I die if I eat "methyl blue?" (Or will my pee turn blue?) Answered

Because who doesn't want to have blue urine? :P

I can remember guzzling food coloring to get the effect, but then I found this.

My question is: Will Methyl Blue give the same effect as Methylene Blue? The MSDS says that methyl blue "may be harmful if swallowed," but that pretty much goes for anything. Wikipedia makes a point to say that "Methyl blue should not be confused with methyl violet or methylene blue, two other stains," and so I know that they are different. How much different is the question here.


Btw, methyl blue is available at your neighborhood pet store in the aquarium section as brown, granular crystals.

9 Replies

user
Kiteman (author)2007-03-21

I always thought methyl blue and methylene blue were the same, but the hazard advice is slightly different:

http://www.proscitech.com.au/catalogue/msds/c123.pdf

Still don't drink it.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
carbon (author)Kiteman2007-03-21

Emergency Overview


WARNING! HARMFUL IF SWALLOWED.

And that's for methylene blue, so how is the hazard advice different? Maybe I should be the one to blaze the trail for this. If I don't post in the next month, it didn't work. ; )

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
Kiteman (author)carbon2007-03-21

The emergency advice if you swallow methylene is "induce vomiting", but for methyl it just says "rinse the mouth out".

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
trebuchet03 (author)Kiteman2007-03-21

I wonder Methylene is reactive to HCI - to merit vomit inducing. From the wiki's the chemical structures are very different.

That being said, and saying this again.... It's used as a medical dye.

Here's What I Found in a Quick Google Search. The integrity of the gastrointestinal tract can be evaluated by oral or rectal application of methylene blue.

What's More Here is a Methylene Blue Drug. Notice the side effects: ...This medication causes the urine, stools and possibly skin to turn green-blue in color. Do not be alarmed. Expect this effect. The discoloration will disappear when the medication is stopped.

This of course is for this chemical in it's medical grade form. Non medical grade (like the flake fish treatment) is VERY likely to be contaminated with some nasty side effects.

Lastly, I will attest to the drugs effectiveness at turning your wastes blue. There's a similar drug that has a similar side effect - turning your wee an orange color (much better/less scary than blood red - believe me).

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
carbon (author)trebuchet032007-03-22

So, to sum up: Methyl blue has a very different chemical structure, does not have a record for being safe to ingest, and is probably laden with all kinds of nasty stuff (my source at the pet store, at least).

I guess I'll just use what I have left ( I ate some o.O ) to make my own light filters. Hmmm...I smell an Instructable : )

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
fungus amungus (author)2007-03-22

I remember eating a Kool-Aid packet when I was about five, figuring that i'd get closer to the source of the flavorful goodness. All I got was some green pee that freaked the shit out of me. If I want to change the color of my piss these days, I just eat a beet. All natural, baby!

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
gammatron (author)2007-03-21

Indeed. Is blue urine worth the risk? How do you know other people who tried it didn't die of kidney failer in their fourties?

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
trebuchet03 (author)gammatron2007-03-21

I'll let you know when I'm 40 :P Well, I used Methelyne Blue :P I'm not too concerned though as it's used as a medical dye. I'm more worried about the Methyl Ethyl Ketone Spirits I accidentally washed my hands in a few years ago.

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer

user
LasVegas (author)2007-03-21

Geez! You've got to be kidding! If the label say's "may be harmful if swallowed," don't swallow!!!

Select as Best AnswerUndo Best Answer