Copycat Sheila G's Brownie Brittle

Intro: Copycat Sheila G's Brownie Brittle

The first couple of times I tried brownie brittle was actually when I'd made them myself at home from a couple of different recipes I'd found online. I thought they were great. Then I tried the ever popular hot commodity, Sheila G's. Wow. How did she make it all so light and so airy and so crisp? I was on a mission to find out.

The difference between hers and the online copycats I'd tried is that glorious light, airy, and crisp texture. It is a spectacular mixed breed of meringue, cookie, and brownie. The recipes I tried (all using egg whites) had a crispy snap, they were harder and tougher. They were just not the same.

That's when it occurred to me to use meringue powder instead of plain old egg whites. And immediately after that, it occurred to me to check her ingredients list (you'd think I would have done that first!). There on her ingredients list: dry egg whites and cornstarch. Meaning: meringue powder.

Meringue powder is a little baking weapon you can find in your big box crafts store. It is a combination of egg white powder and cornstarch. Like egg whites, it gives baked goods body and stability. Its advantage over egg whites: you don't need to figure out what to do with the yolks, you can keep it in the pantry for years, and you can store your baked goods much longer than if using fresh or carton egg whites (not that these brittles need long-term storing in our household!).

Instead of butter, use margarine and you will see why in the ingredients list.

After several trials and errors, which happily fed friends and neighbors, I am proud to achieve copycat brownie brittles with that heavenly light and crispy crumb, just like Sheila G's. Unlike Sheila G's, I used a rich cocoa to give that deep chocolatey depth. The process is so fast and easy, it might take some resistance to try not to make them so often!

STEP 1: Ingredients

I highlighted some atypical ingredients on the package that can be easily replaced by typical ingredients at our local grocery stores:

Highlighted in yellow: Palm Kernel, Palm Oil, Soybean Oil ----> all fats found in margarine (which gives more fluffiness to baked goods than butter)

Highlighted in green: Dry Egg Whites, Cornstarch ----> two main ingredients in meringue powder, as noted in the intro (found at crafts stores like Michaels, Hobby Lobby, JoAnn, AC Moore in the US; found at Michaels and Bulk Barn in Canada)

Highlighted in blue: Soy Lecithin, Dry Milk ----> found in milk chocolate

Ingredients you will need:

2 tablespoons meringue powder

1/3 cup water

1/4 cup granulated sugar

1/2 cup all purpose flour

1/2 cup icing/confectioners sugar

1/4 cup cocoa (I used natural cocoa by Ghirardelli for a much deeper chocolate flavor than processed cocoa)

1 teaspoon baking soda

1/4 cup margarine

3 tablespoons milk chocolate chips (I used Ghiradelli baking chips)

2 tablespoons semi-sweet chocolate chips

2 tablespoons caramel baking chips (I found the Ghirardelli caramel chips to be larger than usual, so I piped them on a pan to make smaller chips)

Sea salt

Supplies

Stand mixer or hand mixer

1 extra large cookie sheet (I used 15"x21") or 2 standard size cookie sheets

Parchment paper

Cooling racks

Sieve or sifter

Offset spatula

Spatula

Pizza cutter

STEP 2: Meringue

1. In a bowl, combine meringue powder and water and whisk on high speed.

2. Slowly add granulated sugar.

3. Whisk on high speed until firm peaks are formed.

STEP 3: Add Dry Ingredients

1. Place a sieve above the bowl of meringue, and combine all purpose flour, icing sugar, cocoa, and baking soda.

2. Stir the dry ingredients as they are sifted through the sieve.

3. Fold the dry ingredients into the meringue until combined.

STEP 4: Add Wet Ingredients

1. In separate bowls, melt margarine and MILK chocolate chips.

2. Add melted margarine to batter.

3. Mix until combined.

4. Pour batter on a parchment-lined cookie sheet. If you do not have a large 15"x21" sheet, you will need 2 standard cookie sheets.

5. Using an offset spatula, spread the batter to less than 1/8" thickness. The batter must be very thin as it will rise slightly during baking. (And you want it to rise, thanks to the baking soda -- those air bubbles will make the brittles light and not tough.)

6. Drizzle melted milk chocolate chips on the batter and smear on the surface of the batter.

This addition of milk chocolate to the surface is what brings that crackly texture during baking. I've done several trials without this step and results were always a smooth surface. I had read somewhere that it is the soy lecithin and milk powder combination in the milk chocolate that aids in and guarantees the cracking surface of the brownie. The milk chocolate also adds more chocolate flavor to the product, which is always a good thing!

STEP 5: Bake

Preheat oven to 300F

1. Add caramel chips and sea salt to first half of the batter.

2. Add chocolate chips to second half of the batter.

3. Bake for 25 minutes.

4. Quickly remove from oven and immediately cut to smaller pieces using pizza cutter. Just make cut lines and do not separate pieces just yet.

5. Immediately return to oven and bake for another 5 minutes.

6. Remove from oven and slide parchment onto cooling rack. Let cool for 15 minutes.

7. Crack and get hooked!!

Comments

[rjroehrig]

Third times the charm. I live in Florida on the Gulf Coast and being at Sea Level baking times are much different here I've learned over the years. Nomally one add's additional time to all reciepe's and in the case of the Brownie Brittle it proved the same. First two attemps they turned out as "Chewy Brownies'. I increased the temperature of the first 25 cook time to 325 degrees. Took the Brownies out and made my cut into squares with the Pizza cutter. Placed back in oven at 350 degrees for another 10 minutes and WELLA.......nice perfectly crisp Brownie Brittle.....identical to the original Shelia G's receipe. So, depending on if your at a real high elevation or at Sea Level such as I'm at, use the same receipe, but just tweak it a bit for your individual elevation.

[sue2958]

Hi,
I made your brownie brittle recipe and may I say ‘thank you’, Jeromina? I so appreciate your hard work creating this recipe!
My question is, would it work to add a little more sugar? I just want a touch more sweetness : )

[gordoncarolyn]

I made them and they were amazing. I shared them with my neighbor as well and she loved them. Great recipe.

[JocelynM23]

Hello Jeronima. Thank you so much for the recipe, I have a lot of boxed brownie mixes I need to use up can you tell me how I could modify this recipe to use with a box mix?

[peggy.lingas]

Hello Jeronima. Thank you so much for the recipe. The sad thing is I cant find meringue powder in my town. They do however sell dried egg white powder which doesnt have any stabilizers or cornstarch. Can i use it as substitute? If so how much cornstarch should i add for every tbsp of egg white powder? Thank you

[Jeromina]

Hi! I'm so sorry that I didn't see this comment on this old post. Did you end up trying it out with just the egg white powder? I would think egg white powder would still work out for this without all the other stuff in meringue powder. I'm not sure what cornstarch amount would be needed.

[Borinxena68]

I love brownie brittle. I buy mine at Ollie's which is where I first discovered them at the best price thus far. I ordered some from the Shelia G website (expensive). But I was able to try a different flavor than the one at Ollie's. I want to try her other flavors, but they are too expensive. I decided to check online for any recipes and came across your recipe. I have not tried it yet, but I plan to in the near future. I will post to let you know how the brownies turned out. Thanks for sharing your process.

[jonnypopper08]

Turned out perfect! Sprinkled toffee bits on halfway thru baking.

[gretborg]

Your pictures are super helpful!

[gretborg]

what is the total finished weight of this recipe? I buy the 16 oz bags of brownie brittle, cuz I'm a pig, but want to compare price of the bags vs. the price of the ingredients to make my own

[Artist567]

What's the object of caramel chips on one side and chocolate chips on other side?

[Jeromina]

Hi there! I'm not so sure what you mean. Do you mean like, why did I juxtapose them side by side?

[gretborg]

to have half salted caramel flavor and half chocolate chip flavor?

[Penolopy Bulnick]

I have also never heard of this, but now really want to try it!

[Jeromina]

Sheila G's is yummy! I'm finding that most grocery stores carry them now in the cookie aisle. But you also have this copycat if the original is nowhere to be found. :D

[jessyratfink]

I had never heard of this but it sounds amazing!

[Jeromina]

Wow, sorry, I just saw this message! I hadn't signed on all these months. Sheila G's is amazing and it's become more common now, I see in a lot of grocery stores (here in NY anyway). If you can't find them, there's this recipe, I did my best at copycatting. :D