Survival Debate

Intro: Survival Debate

This is not a how to but I think this is a good discussion. Please comment. Here is a list of some things I think you do not need in a survival pack. This is NOT a 72 hour sos pack

Compass. If your lost and have no map why do you need to know the direction
Glow stick. Flash light is better because you can turn it off and on. I you use the glow stick for signaling and the plane flies past you and you use it it is a waste
Hammock/tent. I have seen a few people have these but I think a ho made shelter or a tarp would be better
Food. If you think a piece of gum or some rice or bars are gonna help you your wrong. I would rather replace that space with some more snare wire fishing stuff or slingshot This stiff will last longer and you food thou packed will run out.

STEP 1: Tip

Wrap your fishing line around the bottle and it is easy to cast and retrieve

Comments

[Mattakers]

You need the compass because if you remember what way you came, you can go the opposite way and go back to civilization. Also, if you are in a cold place you need to know which way is south because it is warmer there. I agree with you that flashlights are better in a survival situation, but if I'll take what I can get. With flashlights, you can short circuit one of the batteries to start a fire. For the tent/hammock topic, in my big survival backpack (no, not a bug out bag) I have a Mylar blanket, a tube tent and a poncho. For food, I 50% agree with you. I would pack a couple of MRE's because snares might take a while to work and that fish might not want to bite. Hope that answered your questions :)

[Rkaynjehll]

I completely agree with Matt on the compass. I wouldn't wanna be lost without one. A good one if it's my choice. I also pack a home made paracord hammock with a poncho to use as a tarp over the top. In a rainstorm, my wife and I both fit in it and are completely dry in the morning. I 50% agree with you as well. I have parts of MREs in my pack. Just some main meals and a few peanut butters for protein. But my pack is designed more towards hunting/fishing. Havent worked on the trapping portion yet. I really need to. Anyways hope this helps Survivorkidjr

[guitarman96]

I agree with most of the stuff you said except the food If you are hungry you lose energy if you lose energy you can't stay focused on finding more food or staying warm

[Survivorkidjr]

Can you also make on of your whole bag and we can compair.

[Survivorkidjr]

I got the comment on making one on my whole bag but may take a little. School gets busy but ill start it today

[Mattakers]

You are welcome. I'm glad to here that I've helped you :)

[Survivorkidjr]

I keep a little food just in case for backup or for emergency. Thanks again. You have really helped me get started