223Views8Replies

Author Options:

Is a 1" brass rod weaker than 1" iron pipe? Answered

If you where to put the same diameter brass rod and iron pipe in a bender, which one would be toughest to bend?

Comments

The forums are retiring in 2021 and are now closed for new topics and comments.
0
jeff-o
jeff-o

Best Answer 10 years ago

In general, the brass rod would be heavier, stronger, and harder to bend.

0
kelseymh
kelseymh

10 years ago

Bending isn't the issue. As Steve has already pointed out, it's stripping. You can't thread brass and have it hold up under the same load as threaded steel. For yield strength and design information, try a good engineering resource, such as eFunda.

0
onrust
onrust

Answer 10 years ago

Who says it has to be threaded? Where the contacts meet the motor, why could that not be steel sleeved?

0
randomray
randomray

Answer 10 years ago

You could braze or solder it .Frankly it would be very heavy and an expensive . I would plate a steel frame . 1" rod is 1" OD, 1" steel pipe is 1.315 " OD .

0
rickharris
rickharris

10 years ago

It depends - as it stands your question does not have enough detail for a sensible answer.


The brass would be a LOT heavier.

0
seandogue
seandogue

10 years ago

That all depends on the wall thickness of the iron pipe.

0
NachoMahma
NachoMahma

Answer 10 years ago

. And the composition of the brass.

0
Re-design
Re-design

10 years ago

If you like the idea of a brass motorcycle, use a regular steel frame, strip the paint off it then have it brass plated.