591Views50Replies

Author Options:

The rich get richer Answered

I'm kind of ticked off about a big problem I noticed. The main page in every contest has a big panel for the most viewed instructables posted in the contest. The problem with this is that because a lot of people only click on the instructables they see right in front of them. So all the other instructables no matter how good they are , if they don't have many views , get buried under the most viewed ibles and don't get any views. So the people who don't even need any more views get them piled on and the people with hardly any stay that way. Somebody please do something about this!

Discussions

0
None
frollard

9 years ago

I'd like to see a 'cant see rating until you've rated it' setup for contest entries, as well as a randomized listing as the default view.

0
None
Kiteman

10 years ago

You're probably right. Maybe the first view should be randomised?

0
None
tankguyKiteman

Reply 9 years ago

That would be great! If only I worked for instructables...

0
None
Kitemantankguy

Reply 9 years ago

A dream many of us share.

0
None
KitemanLithium Rain

Reply 9 years ago

Hey, at least you are on the right continent, and a more employable age.

0
None
frollard=SMART=

Reply 9 years ago

Lol@ my non-involvement to this point.

0
None
iectyx3cKiteman

Reply 9 years ago



  • I would like randomizing if it were a sort option.
  • Do away with the 5 newly posted row.
  • Do not show ANY thumbnails.
  • Instead have buttons: (Newest) (Oldest) (Page Views) (Rating) (Votes) (Random) (K'Nex) (Altoids) (Fire) (Catapults) (Duct Tape) (Grenades) (Mentos) (TicTacs)
0
None
dave spencer

9 years ago

try submitting them to digg / reddit / make etc. to get them more exposure. If it's good, this will massively help your page views and push you to the front page.

0
None
Matt21497

9 years ago

What they should do is this. They have a day that all the instructables must be posted by. Then there would be a set date for the instructables to start racking up views, and votes. Also the instructable can be viewed before the set date(s) acure but these views and faves don't count in the contest. This would work like a month to enter. And week to rack up votes and views.

0
None
mman1506

9 years ago

yes and an istructable posted early wil usally be ahead

0
None
Rotten194mman1506

Reply 9 years ago

I disagree. My "How To Plant A Tree" Instructable had been in the works for months, and thus I only needed to take pictures. It was the 8th Instructable submitted. It barely has a thousand views :(.

0
None
Bartboymman1506

Reply 9 years ago

That isn't an issue. They were ready first, they deserve an advantage.

0
None
BartboyLithium Rain

Reply 9 years ago

Then it's unfair. If you enter your instructable earlier, you had less time to work on it. You did it faster, so you deserve an advantage. Anyway, you can't change that.....

0
None
Lithium RainBartboy

Reply 9 years ago

I still don't think that faster entries deserve an advantage. I don't think there's anything inherently special about being first that merits reward.

0
None
ChrysNLithium Rain

Reply 9 years ago

Someone may spend a lot of time working on and documenting a project may not get it done until closer to the deadline, and won't get as many views (even if it is featured, popular and in the newsletter) as one that was released early and not even featured. I think for contest voting, the main page should be randomized or perhaps ranked by rating.

0
None
mman1506Bartboy

Reply 9 years ago

the instuctables that ccome first can suck vbut just because they did\ it faster suldn't make a advantage over a very good one that came late

0
None
Bartboymman1506

Reply 9 years ago

But if they suck, then they won't win.....

0
None
mman1506Bartboy

Reply 9 years ago

untrue it only has to be slightly better than the suckier one's

0
None
Bartboymman1506

Reply 9 years ago

I still think it's fair.....

0
None
Euphy

9 years ago

It is kind of a problem - I noticed that during the epilog contest that the most-viewed group that was shown on the main page didn't change an awful lot after the first week, and once the contest had closed and the voting was open, the final 5 entrants got featured on the contest page as the most recent entries too. It does seem to be of benefit to get your Ible in very early (to get most views overall) or very very late (so you are potentially in the last 5).

Featuring the final 5 (most recent) so prominently during the crucial voting round does seem particularly arbitrary. I mean, I know they aren't literally featured, but they are permanently fixed as the first 5 to be shown on the contest page.

Saying that though, it isn't all about the votes - I was lucky enough to be amongst the winners in the Epilog contest, and more than one person has commented that they hadn't even noticed my Instructable during voting. I was ranked like, 60th or something by votes, but was picked by a judge to go through to the last round, so can confirm that it isn't all about having an eye catching first icon and getting the popular vote.

However: For tactical publishers, I'd say the best time to submit would be when there is still one newsletter to go, then hope you stand out enough to get featured during the voting phase. I say this because I was fortunate enough to get featured in the newsletter the week before voting was open, and I reckon I collected 10,000 page views just from that alone. If voting had been open during that time, each one of those people who clicked through, would only have to click once more to vote, and then, once they looked at the list of the other 550, might have been disheartened and headed off elsewhere.

I think the Instructables team have a really tough job trying to balance the wishes of the casual readers (page views = traffic = money) who want to see only the cool flashy things first and might get bored after viewing two or three (never mind 576), and the publishers who have something to gain and want to be exposed fairly and democratically.

0
None
tankguyEuphy

Reply 9 years ago

That does make a lot of sense, thanks.

0
None
steven67

9 years ago

you bring up a good point

0
None
gmjhowe

10 years ago

I just realized, your I'ble probably got caught in the filters 'crossbow' most likely the keyword. That often means that by the time they get through, they are missed by most the regulars.

0
None
killerjackalopegmjhowe

Reply 9 years ago

Actually I've noticed that unless there's a huge number of 'ibles waiting in the filters it won't knock you down the list much because it goes from the filters to the top of the recent list...

0
None
killerjackalope

9 years ago

Though a random view would be more interesting it just seems like a bit of self pity to me... Take the music contest I posted playing the spoon questionably, something I found hilarious and fun, however it probably won't get a vote, sometimes doing stuff for the sake of it is good enough. Besides that little crossbow looks like fun, we've been weird weaponry lately, but much, much bigger...

0
None
DJ Radio

9 years ago

yeah that kind of sucks. I could however, give you a hint on how to increase your pageviews. If you tried your best, it kind of sucks when it doesnt really get a reward.

0
None
tankguyDJ Radio

Reply 9 years ago

Whats the hint? please tell me!

0
None
dark sponge

9 years ago

It was worse in the April fools contest. The only way to vote for an Instructable was to find it in the contest page by going through pages of instructables ordered by views. There was no vote button actually in the Instrucable.

0
None
gmjhowe

10 years ago

Well, its more a case of those who put the hardwork in, get more out. Your I'ble is very good. But there are still much more 'Epic' entries. The more someone puts into an I'ble, and the more thought out there idea, the more likely they will get views, or featured. Your on the right steps, you have some excellent pictures, but a bit more explanation, and something a bit different, can go a long way.

0
None
dragonwarrior3000gmjhowe

Reply 9 years ago

i agree with gmjhowe, hardwork should be rewarded. if you put a lot of time and effort into something, you should be rewarded. if you want your project to be viewed, make something that people want to look at and want to try. then you'll be on the leader board.

0
None
PKMgmjhowe

Reply 10 years ago

What about people who see a contest and spend a while making an "epic" project, only to have it buried under the sea of entries from within a few hours of the contest opening so starts off on the back foot?

0
None
gmjhowePKM

Reply 10 years ago

Quite often, the project then gets picked out by the feature team. Which is a great advantage to such a team, the varying people will all pick out different things that they like, or that relate to them.

0
None
tankguy

Reply 9 years ago

Exactly, I agree that there should be some quality control, but everyone should at least be given the same oppurtunity for people to see there instructable and comment on it.

0
None
dombeef

10 years ago

Yeah!