98Views8Replies

Author Options:

Who Here Are Middle Earth Fans? Answered

Just wondering who here are LOTR/The Hobbit fans. If you are, let me know in the comments!

My favorite Middle Earth book is "The Return of the King" and that's also my favorite Middle Earth film.

My least favorite Middle Earth book is the "Fellowship of the Ring" and my least favorite Middle Earth film is the "Desolation of Smaug."

Comments

The forums are retiring in 2021 and are now closed for new topics and comments.
0
liquidhandwash
liquidhandwash

5 years ago

Im a bit of a fan, I was disappointed with that the film killed off one of the main characters (saruman) in the second film. Im sure it was done to shorten the three films which should of been four.

0
CorgiCritter
CorgiCritter

Reply 5 years ago

Yeah, the films were already very long and they must have thought that having yet another hour long fight scene at the end of the Return of the King would just be too much.

But yes, I would rather there been two parts to ROTK then three parts for the Hobbit.

0
liquidhandwash
liquidhandwash

Reply 5 years ago

I agree "The Scouring of the Shire" would of made a great film.

0
CorgiCritter
CorgiCritter

Reply 5 years ago

It could have been one of the best parts. "Amon Hen/The Breaking of the Fellowship" is my current favorite.

0
CorgiCritter
CorgiCritter

Reply 5 years ago

You have a point.

But you didn't say if you were a fan. ;)

0
Kiteman
Kiteman

Reply 5 years ago

I read it first over thirty years ago, and I have the films on disc..

0
CorgiCritter
CorgiCritter

Reply 5 years ago

I guess that's a yes. :D