171Views46Replies

Author Options:

single shots VS mags....... Answered

ok, I want an opinion on which is better: single-shots, or guns with mags?

so far........

6 single shots, 7 mags


arguments to help out

SINGLE SHOT

PROS

-faster to load
-get better range
-easy on knex parts
-easy to build

CONS

-you need to constantly reload after every shot

MAGS

PROS

-more ammo
-less reloads

CONS

-more prone to jamming and misfiring than single shots
-take longer to reload

judging from these arguments, and ones i forgot to mention, which is better?

Comments

The forums are retiring in 2021 and are now closed for new topics and comments.
0
TigerNod
TigerNod

12 years ago

Single shots are better. Imagine: what if you would ban all single shots from this site? No IAC cannon, no SR-v1, no other snipers (of course there are, but they are not powerful at all), and most important, ONLY STUPID BLOCK TRIGGERS! Don't want to have that, err? Mags will always jam, for sure. I must say that the Red impact by perfect duck has increased the reliability of mags rapidly, but it is still much less powerful then single shots Conclusion: Vote for Obam... I mean, for single shots!

0
Der Bradly
Der Bradly

Reply 12 years ago

Mags own! I am making a mag that is easily detachable and can be reloaded easily. Conclusion: Vote for McCai... I mean Mags!

0
TigerNod
TigerNod

Reply 12 years ago

Lol. I must say that the mags are into a revolution (unlike the republicans, who are in a dip >:-)). The decapicitated connector has been the greatest improvemint so far. But still, mags have problems like: the rods don't fall into the barrel, the rods fall left of the barrel, they are stuck in the mag, or they are blocked by the barrel. And they are less powerful because of the friction. I stick around at my single shots!

0
Der Bradly
Der Bradly

Reply 12 years ago

Mags are getting better all the time... I just made a mag that never jams, on a pistol!

0
TigerNod
TigerNod

Reply 12 years ago

Sounds interesting... Have you posted it yet?

0
Der Bradly
Der Bradly

Reply 12 years ago

No, But it will be out after my T36

0
TigerNod
TigerNod

Reply 12 years ago

Can you tell me something about that T36?

0
Der Bradly
Der Bradly

Reply 12 years ago

It's posted! 250+ foot range!

0
DJ Radio
DJ Radio

Reply 12 years ago

and you said you liked single shots better............ oh well.

0
DJ Radio
DJ Radio

Reply 12 years ago

AR-4 Commando v1

0
Der Bradly
Der Bradly

Reply 12 years ago

I got better at making mags and now i really like them

0
DJ Radio
DJ Radio

Reply 12 years ago

so did i, as shown in the AR-4 Commando v2, but i still prefer single shot

0
Der Bradly
Der Bradly

Reply 12 years ago

For power i really like single shots.

0
TigerNod
TigerNod

Reply 12 years ago

OK then. Its beautiful to see so many comments in just one hour :P

0
Der Bradly
Der Bradly

12 years ago

Well you might want to consider how big the cons and pros are...

0
DJ Radio
DJ Radio

Reply 12 years ago

....

0
DJ Radio
DJ Radio

Reply 12 years ago

what was your comment?

0
Der Bradly
Der Bradly

Reply 12 years ago

error 404: not telling
0
DJ Radio
DJ Radio

Reply 12 years ago

kk

0
shadowninja31
shadowninja31

Reply 12 years ago

if u made an automatic orbital cannon (im gonna make the cannon (do and be smited)) id vote for that

0
KEYBOARDISBROKEN
KEYBOARDISBROKEN

12 years ago

MAGS ALWAYS JAM RIGHT AT THE WRONG MOMENT -AND SINGLE SHOT ARE MORE POWERFUL. IF YOU WANT MULTI SHOT THEN; 1) LOAD LOADS OF RODS INTO A LONG SINGLE SHOT BARREL OR 2) ATTACH A LOAD OF BLOCK TRIGGERS TOETHER...

0
DJ Radio
DJ Radio

Reply 12 years ago

kk

0
TheDunkis
TheDunkis

12 years ago

It depends on the situation...overall I'd go with mags. If you have a removable mag then that really helps in the reload department. If you preload multiple magazines before hand it gives you an upper hand. It isn't hard to make a reliable magazine for connectors anyways about the only thing you can hold against magazines is less power and even then it is possible although not fully developed to load the ammo into a separate are than the barrel and then load it from there into the barrel.

0
TigerNod
TigerNod

Reply 12 years ago

Yes, that was a beautiful gun.

0
DRADIS
DRADIS

12 years ago

Mags are way better. I've seen knex guns evolve from where a mag of any kind was special, but now in-handle mags are rather commonplace. If people keep developing magazines, I think they can get to the point where they don't jam and will be just as powerful as single-shots. In the meantime, they're just more convenient (not to mention more fun)

0
Dutchj
Dutchj

12 years ago

Mags. A magazine can easily be nearly 100% reliable, and when it is the disadvantage of lower power matters less.

0
ironman69
ironman69

12 years ago

I say this because I can make a mag fed gun stronger than most single shots I've built on this site except the srV1:p of course

0
DJ Radio
DJ Radio

Reply 12 years ago

well most of us cant

0
DJ Radio
DJ Radio

Reply 12 years ago

ok 1 vote 4 mags

0
Vynash
Vynash

12 years ago

single shot is more reliable. and powerful. i like singles better. way more.

0
DJ Radio
DJ Radio

Reply 12 years ago

good. i made one

0
Vynash
Vynash

Reply 12 years ago

k cool

0
Flumpkins
Flumpkins

12 years ago

eeeeerrrrggg.... whats a mag?

0
DJ Radio
DJ Radio

Reply 12 years ago

a mag holds the ammo until ready to fire. they auto-load the barrel

0
Flumpkins
Flumpkins

Reply 12 years ago

I might say single-shot.