Back to School Science Experiment

21,862

283

25

I'm a middle school science teacher going on 15 years in the classroom. I've taught 6th, 7th, an...

Intro: Back to School Science Experiment

I learned this trick at Happy Hour a few years back and have used it in my science class as an inquiry lab ever since. I just don't tell my students where I learned it!

This lab does require matches and involves fire so please use caution. Adult supervision is required!!

I suggest reading "Step One" before watching the video.

Step 1: "Water in the Glass"

This is the perfect science experiment to get kids thinking. I use this experiment to introduce the steps of the scientific method and to spark an interest in science related topics for my 7th graders. Because it's an inquiry lab, you might want to figure it out on your own. If so, do not watch the video or move on to the next step. If not, click through the steps or watch the video to learn a really neat trick. To understand the science behind the experiment, an explanation is on the final step and in the description below the video. You can also check out some of the brilliant comments by members of Instructables in the comments section!!

Here is how I pose the question to my students...

"How can I get the water from the plate back into the glass without lifting the plate?"

These are your materials:

A dinner plate, a drinking glass, water, a lime wedge, and 5 matches

Step 2: Procedure

As I'm handing out the materials, I have my students write at least two possible solutions to the problem before discussing as a lab group. After all materials are handed out, they are instructed to share their ideas with their lab partners.

Pour the water from the glass onto the plate (be careful not to spill the water onto the table). Now... Get the water back into the glass without lifting the plate!

Step 3: Some Initial Student Ideas...

Many students will want to light the lime on fire right away. I am happy to give them the matches, but I don't give them the match box to strike the matches with unless they can explain a logical reason for needing to light them. Some students will attempt to evaporate the water into the cup (my favorite). Some groups will realize the lime does not act like a sponge after squeezing out the juice. Some will come to the conclusion that they can't scoop the water off the plate without getting most of the water on the table. Every once in a while, a clever student will flip the glass upside down and see if a temperature difference might do the trick...

I do my best not to discourage any ideas. I encourage them when they are thinking in the right direction and give them hints when they are stuck. What does fire need? Are you using all of your materials? Can the glass be upside down and still hold water? We learn through failure, so it's important that they are allowed to fail. Schools often only reward students for coming up with the correct answer, but it's the process that is the most important.

Eventually, they start to piece together that they need the match on the inside of the glass. When one group starts to figure out the solution, the other groups inevitably peek and discuss what they should be doing differently.

Step 4: The Solution

Stick 4/5 matches into the lime with the heads of the matches close together. Use the remaining match to light the "lime birthday cake". Flip the glass on top of the lit matches. If the seal between the glass and the plate is strong enough, you can lift the plate right off the table. If you use real glass for this experiment, just be careful not to leave it sitting for too long because there is a risk of your glass breaking.

Here is a better explanation in writing for why the water enters the glass. Air has weight. At sea level, the air puts about 15 lbs of pressure onto every square inch (PSI) of surface area. Air is composed of several gases, including oxygen, which the fire needs in order to burn. You can demonstrate this by lighting a small candle and then placing a drinking glass over it; the candle will burn up the oxygen trapped in the glass, and then the flame will go out, since fresh oxygen from outside the glass is unable to replace it.

The drinking glass is cooler than the gasses inside the glass due to the flame of the matches. When the warm water vapor touches the cooler drinking glass, it condenses into a liquid. There's not very much liquid water visible on the surface of the glass, but there is a major change in volume: the conversion from vapor to liquid is about 1,000 times smaller. When the volume inside the drinking glass shrinks, it creates a partial vacuum—a space where there is very little gas. But a vacuum is invisible. The best way to show this vacuum to kids is to repeat the demonstration, but with water and food dye on the plate. As the partial vacuum shrinks inside the glass, the outside air (about 15 PSI), which has been pushing down on the water all along, will now push the water right under the rim of the glass, causing it to fill the glass. The water won't fill the glass completely; it reaches equilibrium. It's fun to have students analyze how to get more water to rise in the glass: a larger flame, a taller glass, colder water, frosty mug? Have fun!

I have students recreate the experiment at home for homework. They need to get a parent to sign that they were witness to the experiment. If they don't have a lime at home, they can always use something else to hold the matches. I tell them a piece of banana, apple, strawberry, potato, or any other fruit works well. I like lemons or limes because students think they might be flammable. They can also use a birthday candle and a lighter if they don't have matches.

I hope you learned something and please comment after you've had a chance to try it!

Share

    Recommendations

    • Audio Contest 2018

      Audio Contest 2018
    • Optics Contest

      Optics Contest
    • Electronics Tips & Tricks Challenge

      Electronics Tips & Tricks Challenge

    25 Discussions

    0
    None
    Skyrimislogic

    1 year ago

    Cool, will be great for school. thanks

    0
    None
    DEEJAY642

    2 years ago

    awesome im gonna do this right now

    0
    None
    Festrada007

    3 years ago

    If all of you would like to know where the water comes from, I woul suggest measuring the depth of the water in the platewith glass and fruit in the water. Then conduct the experiment and re mesure the water. The vacuum is created by the flame convering the oxygen into heat. You also notice how large forest fires creat their own wind by creating low pressure pockets in the heart of the fire. Simple thermodynamics. ;)

    0
    None
    TammyMoore

    3 years ago on Introduction

    I love the creativity used here lol should keep this article in mind.

    0
    None
    stacko12345

    3 years ago

    Yeah going to show her the your 'ible maybe for a class experiment if that's ok with you

    0
    None
    Biodynamicstacko12345

    Reply 3 years ago on Introduction

    Bring all the materials and see if your science teacher can figure it out. If not your science teacher, bring the materials to the teacher you think would find it awesome and see if they can do it, but I hope your science teacher would be interested enough by the challenge that they would use it as a teachable moment. Good luck. (Maybe have the teacher supply the matches ;)

    0
    None
    htariq5

    4 years ago on Step 4

    I DID it i worked very well and i showed it to my class fellows and explained

    0
    None
    Noble_Knight

    4 years ago

    Were you saying that the volume shrinks or the glass shrinks? the volume that the glass holds or the volume of the gas inside?

    0
    None
    swawrzyniak

    4 years ago on Step 4

    I used to do this as a demo in my science class and I found I had to be careful about explanations. When using a candle, the flame does not go out when the oxygen is gone. I used to demo relighting the candle for a little while after waiting a minute (I started with a thin bare wire around the wick that I could short the wire and heat the wick with a power supply). Carbon dioxide and water are produced so it is not accurate to say the negative pressure inside is from using up the oxygen. The event also demo's that the water does not go in as the candle first burns. If anything, air bubbles move out of the glass until the candle burns out. Then as the gasses inside cool, you get the negative pressure inside compared to outside and then the water moves in. The used up oxygen point is easier to make by sticking some steel wool up in the glass with no heat source and waiting for most of the oxygen molecules to become part of the rust that forms. I was very lucky that my college science teaching methods class over 30 years ago focused on these kinds of experiences.

    From one teacher to another, thanks for challenging students.

    2 replies
    0
    None
    Biodynamicswawrzyniak

    Reply 4 years ago on Introduction

    I hate that I didn't explain it correctly the first time! Thanks for letting me know. Would it be okay if I paraphrase what you have written above when I go back and edit? Thanks for the comment.

    0
    None
    swawrzyniakBiodynamic

    Reply 4 years ago on Introduction

    Sure, but my explanation is not perfect - I don't know how much of the negative pressure is due to cooling gasses and how much is water condensing (which you can observe). A great use of the demo is to beware of explanations that do not actually fit the observation - like bad science. If time permits, further investigations might help to complete the explanation.

    0
    None
    MrFrancis

    4 years ago

    Great experiment, trying with the kids ASAP!

    0
    None
    MicioGatta

    4 years ago on Introduction

    I did this experiment with a candle and blue ink in the water. My pupils loved it so much that we did it lots of times when talking about air and lots of time at the end of the year with no links to the subjects.

    1 reply