Choosing and Buying a Fiddle




Introduction: Choosing and Buying a Fiddle

A few thoughts for beginners

Step 1: Where to Buy

If you have a teacher, he/she will probably tell you what to do.

But even if your teacher instructs you, you will need to find a cheerful music shop that you trust. You are NOT looking for a shop full of electric guitars here: they need to have at least some expertise with stringed instruments. They needn't be slap next door, but you should be able to reach them relatively easily.

You are going to need strings, sheet music, stands, repairs (or at least setup), bow rehairs, and so forth. OK, you won't need these things every week, but this will be an ongoing relationship. So find a suitable retailer and get to know them.

Then go there, tell them how much you want to spend, and ask their advice. They know that if they make you happy, you'll be back for all the things I listed above - and in a few years, a better violin. And a few years later an even better one. And a new bow. And....

It's in their interest to satisfy you, and they know more about what student instruments are available than you or I ever will.

Step 2: Fab Instruments From Ebay. or Not.

Don't buy from the internet unless you know - really know - what you are doing.* Don't buy from Ebay unless you really reallyreally know what you are doing.

Here are some violins available on Ebay at the time of writing. Do you feel competent to fix them? And these are the ones where you can actually SEE the problems!

* One exception I can recommend: ELIDA TRADING are expert and trustworthy.

Step 3: How Much Should You Spend?

For a beginner, a good way to start is to find the cheapest violin available (at the time of writing the cheapest outfit I could find was about GBP 60 / US $100) - but don't buy one! A really cheap violin will be more difficult to play and less satisfying to hear: cheap instruments are probably the prime reason for people giving up.

Watch out for the difference between buying a violin and a violin outfit. A violin means just that; a violin outfit will include a bow and a case, which if bought separately could double your outlay.

There's a kind of geometric progression that applies to most musical instruments - and indeed other things like cars. All other things being equal, a $200 violin will be twice as good as a $100 violin. A $1000 violin will be considerably better than a $500 violin. But the difference between a $50,000 violin and a $100,000 violin will be imperceptible to the ordinary person.*

So budget to buy a violin outfit at double the cheapest price you have found - ie as of now, GBP 120 / US $200. Spend more if you can.

I must stress that this is for a beginner: advanced players will not be content with a violin of this standard. But then an advanced player will know all this already! :-)

* This principle is not infallible. It ignores the fact that two $200 violins will be different from each other! But it helps.

Hope you find this useful.

Be the First to Share


    • Mason Jar Speed Challenge

      Mason Jar Speed Challenge
    • Pumpkin Challenge

      Pumpkin Challenge
    • Bikes Challenge

      Bikes Challenge

    3 Discussions


    9 years ago on Step 3

    To get a plug in here for an excellent World class Instrument maker I choose Raymond Schryer, from the District of Algoma, Ontario, Canada.

    He is from a family of awesome fiddlers and now that he has grown builds World Class instruments. Home town boy done good.


    11 years ago on Introduction

    This is good stuff. The only part I disagree with is your middle image in step 1. I recently bought a bass fiddle and a bass guitar. The shop owner is a luthier who works alone and builds violins and mandolins. He makes about a dozen violins and half dozen mandolins per year. His shop looks like that step 1 middle picture because the guitars pay his rent while he's working on the special instruments.


    Reply 11 years ago on Introduction

    Yeah, you're probably right: I was being a bit too jokey. Like you, I play guitar and violin, so there's no anti-guitar prejudice at work! Anyway, the point is that a beginner needs someone who knows about string instruments: if they also sell guitars that's fine of course - and if like your guy, they actually make the things, then fantastic. Glad you liked it otherwise.