Crustless Homemade Peanut Butter and Jelly Pie

Introduction: Crustless Homemade Peanut Butter and Jelly Pie

About: Paramedic. Hazmat. Fire. WMD. ON CALL FOR LIFE<3

Growing up my favorite sandwich was a PB&J with the crust cut off...just kidding it was grilled cheese with ketchup. But I loved them and so do millions of kids EVERY day. I got the inspiration for this pie while eating a blueberry pie, the filling was one of those cans with super sugary filling. It was great but it needed a contrast, something salty? Thats when I thought of peanut butter...jelly..theyre husband and wife.

I also had recently made a homemade peanut butter I have been lazy to post, this would make the pie even more homemade.
Here is the link -

The concept is- The crust is grahm cracker on bottom a little on the side but not to the top to make it crustless. Next is the peanut butter filling . And the topping is a jelly reduction (done in microwave) :0

Step 1: Step 1 the Bottom

I cant call the bottom crust. ;0

Crush up a bunch of graham crackers. Mine were already crushed they were leftover from an instant cheesecake box missing the cheesecake.  This was about 3/4 -1 cup . It covered the bottom of my pie dish.

Melt 6 tablespoons of butter (or margiarine ) Im not a huge butter fan.

Mix the butter and graham crackers together in the pie dish. It will be like sand and the perfect ratio, more dry than wet and you dont want it to go too much on the side because its crustless=)

Because the butter was hot when mixed the pie  dish warmed up, put it in the freezer for 20 minutes or the fridge for at least 30.

Step 2:

The peanut butter filling is next.
  • First add half a cup of cream cheese, any flavor, theres a honey nut flavor Phlidelphia makes that would be great with this recipe.
  • One cup of PB store brand or my recipe on the first page
  • Vanilla
  • 1/4 cup milk
  • 4 tablespoons of butter, not melted

Mix all this together, mix until its airy like the picture. This will make it easier to spread.
Spread the filling ontop of the pie.
My glass dish was from the freezer so it was thawing not messy on the sides=) Had to point that out

Let that sit in the fridge while you make the jelly topping.

Step 3:

Choose your jelly (ok I got jam , whats the difference)

Measure one cup, melt it, not boiling though, about 1 minute 30 seconds in microwave.

Pour ontop of pie starting in center and go in a circle tilt the pie to move the jelly up and down so its even . This way you will not mix the peanut butter mix and the jelly and you will keep layers.

Top with peanuts if you would like. Refrigerate the pie before serving.


Pi Day Pie Challenge

Participated in the
Pi Day Pie Challenge

Be the First to Share


    • Pumpkin Challenge

      Pumpkin Challenge
    • Build a Tool Contest

      Build a Tool Contest
    • Mason Jar Speed Challenge

      Mason Jar Speed Challenge

    2 Discussions


    8 years ago on Introduction

    This is a great idea. Thank you for sharing, and good luck on the contest!