Instead of buying a tag and then trying to label
it with awkward handwriting, just take a funny
picture of the target and use that. You can use
a real photo or just print one. The kids know
which is theirs, and like to look at each other's
photo.

Step 1:

You can use a photo, or just print one out with
an inkjet. The ink can smear, so I cover mine
with a layer of clear tape for protection.

Step 2: The Edge

You can leave a white area around the edge
as a border. The scrap book stuff might be
an idea for the border or for "wingdings".

Step 3:

I kept mine simple, with just a bow to accent the edge.
It's a great opportunity to pull out the awesome photo
of friends embarrassing snapshots or photoshopped
ones.