Homemade Reese's Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cake




Who doesn't love peanut butter and chocolate together, especially when it’s Reese's Peanut Butter Cups? No one! That being said, I decided that I was going to make a Reese's ice cream cake. I have been experimenting with ice cream cakes a lot lately, and decided to give the idea in my head a whirl. During the summer, I picked up the magazine Mixing Bowl, and it had the Ultimate Ice Cream Cake on the front cover. I tried an ice cream cake similar to the magazine's recipe, and it tasted wonderful; however I felt like I could make a few adjustments according to my taste buds.  So here it is…

- 1 package of Peanut Butter Oreos (15.25 oz)
- 1/3 cup of butter, melted (approx. a little more than 5 tablespoons of butter)
- about 1 1/2 jars of Smucker's Hot Fudge (11.75 oz)
- (1) 18 oz. jar of Peanut Butter
- (2) 1/2 gallons of Vanilla Ice Cream (You May Not Use All the Ice Cream)
- (1) 8 oz. bag of Mini Reese's Peanut Butter Cups cut in half
- 1 cup Cool Whip
- 4 snack size Reese's

1) Let the ice cream thaw at room temperature for about 20 minutes or while you prepare the crust.
*Note: You can opt to not bake the crust and just set it aside- skip to step 7. I just prefer to tone down the butter taste of the crust.
2) Preheat the oven to 350 degrees.
3) In a food processor, crush up the Peanut Butter Oreos.
4) In a medium bowl, combine crushed Oreos and 1/3 of melted butter (still warm).
5) Press the Oreo and butter mixture into a 9" springform pan (about 2 inches up the sides of the pan) and bake for about 5 minutes.
6) Once your crust is out of the oven, set it aside and let cool.
7) In a small saucepan, heat 2/3 cup of hot fudge until its smooth. Then spread the fudge evenly on the bottom of your crust mixture. Place in freezer for a few minutes while you prepare the ice cream.
8) In a small bowl, place 3/4 of the jar of peanut butter. Microwave for about 1 minute or until it becomes liquid.
9) In a large bowl, thoroughly combine melted peanut butter and vanilla ice cream.
10) Place half the ice cream mixture over your fudge and crust. Evenly, sprinkle cut halves of mini Reese's over the ice cream in the pan. Place remaining ice cream on top of cut up Reese's. Place springform pan in freezer for at least 6 hours or overnight.
11) Carefully, release cake and place on cake plate. Spread a layer of room temperature hot fudge over ice cream.

To decorate: Microwave the rest of the peanut butter from the jar for about one minute. Once the peanut butter is a liquid consistency, mix it with about a cup of cool whip to achieve a peanut butter mousse consistency.  Place mousse inside Ziploc bag. Cut a corner of the bag to pipe mousse around cake. Cut snack size Reeses in half, so you have 8 pieces and place around cake. Drizzle extra chocolate fudge and sprinkles over mousse and enjoy!

Teacher Notes

Teachers! Did you use this instructable in your classroom?
Add a Teacher Note to share how you incorporated it into your lesson.

Be the First to Share


    • Meal Prep Challenge

      Meal Prep Challenge
    • Reuse Contest

      Reuse Contest
    • Made with Math Contest

      Made with Math Contest

    11 Discussions


    4 years ago

    How far in advance can you make this? How long does it keep?


    4 years ago

    Sadly they changed the pb oreos to reeses oreos. Not as good as far as I am concerned so I hope this still turns out great. :/


    4 years ago

    My son has requested this for his birthday so am looking forward to making. Just have to find the oreo cookies. Seems our store has not been carrying them here lately.


    4 years ago on Introduction

    I was just making this for my girlfriend and realized...did you really mean 1 gallon of ice cream? I improvised and only used...less than half of a gallon because I simply could not fit all of the ice ccream into the pan.

    1 reply
    sharlzzGeneral Zod

    Reply 6 years ago on Introduction

    Haha! Sorry for the late response. It's a rich and delicious ice cream cake :) I loveeeee peanut butter so it's perfect! Def. a fun cake to make!!

    I have never had peanut butter oreos! There sure are a lot of different types of oreos :) Your cake looks absolutely delicious!

    1 reply