Make Custard-style Yogurt




Introduction: Make Custard-style Yogurt

Homemade yogurt is just about infinitely customizable, and very, very easy.

This is my version of the thick, custard-style yogurt you usually get in the grocery store.

A half gallon of milk
1/2 to 1 cup powdered milk
1 cup of live, active culture plain yogurt

Large saucepan
Candy thermometer
9 very clean plastic yogurt cups with lids
Something to stir with, like a fork or a spoon
Cookie sheet (optional)

IMPORTANT: Make sure that all of your equipment is very clean. Your goal is to create a fertile, inviting environment for the yogurt cultures, so it's important to make sure that there aren't other, unwanted cooties lurking around as well.

Step 1: Scald the Milk

In the saucepan, mix the powdered milk into the milk. The powdered milk is what gives the yogurt its thick, custard-like consistency, so add more powdered milk for a thicker, spoon-eating yogurt; less for a more pourable yogurt.

Scald the milk by very slowly bringing it almost (but not quite!) to a boil. If you'd like, you can put the candy thermometer in now, to check the temperature as it's cooking. If you do want to use the thermometer at this stage, put it in the milk while it's still cold. If you put it in after it's started to scald, it will boil over and make a big mess.

At the scalding stage, the milk will start to look foamy and you'll see the tiny bubbles rising to the surface pretty quickly. This will happen at around 200 degrees F.

Remove it from the heat immediately. Once milk starts to boil, there's no stopping it.

Step 2: Let the Mixture Cool

If you haven't already stuck the candy thermometer in, do this once the milk has cooled a little, and set the saucepan of milk aside until it has cooled to about 115 to 120 degrees. This is to ensure that the mixture is not so hot that it destroys the yogurt cultures.

Step 3: Mix in the Yogurt

Divide the cup of active yogurt among three of the yogurt cups, then add a little of the cooled milk to each cup.

Stir well to combine the yogurt and the milk, then pour the milk-yogurt mixtures back into the pan and stir it all in well.

Step 4: Cultivate Your Yogurt!

Pour the milk and yogurt mixture into nine yogurt cups and put the lids on.

Arrange them on a cookie sheet, just to make it easier to move them around, and put them somewhere where they will maintain a temperature around 95 degrees F for an extended period.

I put mine in the oven, with the light on and the oven door closed, and it works well.

Alternately, you could put the cookie sheet on a heating pad and cover the yogurt cups with a towel.

IMPORTANT: If you use the oven, make sure everyone in the house knows not to turn the oven on. That would just be a hundred kinds of horrible.

Step 5: Go Do Something Else for 8 to 10 Hours

I usually sleep.

Let the yogurt cultivate undisturbed for about eight to ten hours. The longer you let it cultivate, the tangier and more distinctly yogurt-ey it will taste.

Test the consistency by taking a cup out and tilting it.

Once you're happy with your yogurt, refrigerate it immediately to retard the growth of the cultures.

Remember to save your last cup of yogurt for the next batch.

Be the First to Share


    • Potato Speed Challenge

      Potato Speed Challenge
    • Pumpkin Challenge

      Pumpkin Challenge
    • Build a Tool Contest

      Build a Tool Contest

    5 Discussions


    5 years ago on Step 5

    This is the best yogurt recipe I have ever done -- THANK YOU ! The key is the powdered milk -- I would have never thought of that trick :)


    12 years ago on Introduction

    After hanging yogurt in cheese cloth, it looks like this:


    14 years ago

    good idea here--you can also thicken it up by letting it sit in cheesecloth. Incubation: put sum water b/n 80 an 100 in a mini- or lunch cooler and put the jars in that...why bother with the coal-powered blankey? You can even put the cooler w/warm water and soon-to-be yogurt in the fridge and go away for the weekend...


    14 years ago

    One way to ensure a good warm environment is to do what I used to do: take an electric blanket, put it in a basket or box, and wrap the yogurt containers in it. Turn it on low to maintain a warm but not-too-hot heat. This protects against drafts and gets it out of the kitchen if you want.


    Reply 14 years ago

    Ooh, that's perfect. I'm going to try that next time. I think I'll try it in a cooler.