Unicorn Edible Cookie Dough




About: Instructables Community Manager - I am powered by sugar and rainbows! For realz!

I've been trying to think of different things to do with the 2.5lbs of cereal marshmallows I bought and figured I would try adding them into edible cookie dough when I got the craving for some. I also added in some white chocolate chips just to give it something else special. I'm sure this is the cookie dough unicorns would eat if given the option :)

Instructable 272

Step 1: Ingredients

This is meant to be a single serving of cookie dough as the marshmallows get all squishy in the fridge, but this still took me a few times to eat it all. Just evenly multiply up the ingredients if you want more.


If you decide to chop up the white chocolate chips, you can just use a knife and cutting board. I also tried a chopper one time which didn't give perfect results, but it was easier than hand chopping.

Also, I really liked the marshmallows so I might have added a bit more. Add as many or as few white chocolate chips and marshmallows as you prefer.

Step 2: Mix Cookie Ingredients

Start by creaming the butter and sugars. Mix in the vanilla.

Add in your flour and salt.

Lastly, put in your milk. I decided to do it last in case I wanted more or less added in. One tablespoon worked out perfectly for me.

Step 3: Add in Extras

Time to add in the extras!

Start with the chips because they are more resilient.

Once those are mixed in, add the marshmallows and just stir until mixed in. They break easier so I didn't want to mix it more than I had to once they were in.

That's it. Enjoy :)

Step 4: Eat or Store for Later

Time to eat!

Like I mentioned earlier, the marshmallows go soft in the fridge which isn't bad, it just changes their texture. So if you can, eat and enjoy right away. If you can't store in the fridge. It will get stiffer once it's cold.

For something a little different, put some on a plate in the microwave for 10-30 seconds (depending on how much). It's like a very gooey cookie.



    • Frozen Treats Challenge

      Frozen Treats Challenge
    • Growing Beyond Earth Maker Contest

      Growing Beyond Earth Maker Contest
    • 1 Hour Challenge

      1 Hour Challenge

    12 Discussions

    M.C. Langer

    1 year ago

    This looks delicious, magic and incredibly sweet! I love it!

    1 reply

    1 year ago

    My girlfriend's daughter is absolutely obsessed with Unicorns. I'm sending her this link. She's going to love it!!

    1 reply

    1 year ago

    You have to be careful with raw flour--it can carry e. coli. It's not always eggs that make you sick when you eat raw cookie dough.

    1 reply

    1 year ago

    It's so cute! I would probably make this right now if I had the marshmallows :D

    1 reply

    Thank you! You just gotta invest in that 2.5lb jar of marshmallows and you'll be set forever ;)