Wonderful Banana Split Ice Cream Pie




Introduction: Wonderful Banana Split Ice Cream Pie

First let me say, this recipe is a delicious medley of all your favorite sundae flavors.

This recipe reminds me of a kindergarten art project - it's really really fun, really easy, sorta messy, and just a little time consuming. It's more an outlet for your creative energy than one particular pie. You can substitute ingredients with their ready-made counterparts with no effect on the end result. We made a 1-2-3 cookie crust, but you can make (or buy) any type, graham cracker, chocolate, regular. This pie will go well with all of them.

Let's begin, shall we?

Step 1: Ingredients

Pie crust

1 stick of butter
1 egg
1/4 cup sugar
1 1/2 cups flour
1 tsp vanilla


2 medium size bananas
1 quart Neapolitan ice cream
1 bag chocolate chips
1 20 oz. can of pineapple in its own juices, not heavy syrup
1 carton strawberries
1 pint whipping cream

Step 2: Make the Crust (if You Are)

Soften the butter

Cream together the butter, sugar, and vanilla

Add the egg

Blend until smooth

Add the flour all at once

Mix on a low speed until just blended

Form into a ball

Wrap in plastic wrap.
An airtight container will work too. That's what we used.

Refrigerate for at least an hour.

Preheat the oven to 325° F

Roll out crust between two sheets of parchment paper.

Take off the top parchment paper.

Put your hands under the bottom paper, pick it up, with the crust on it, and flip it onto the pie plate.

Smooth the crust into the pie plate and trim around the edge.

Bake for 10 minutes.

Let it cool.

Step 3: Layering the Filling

Drain the Pineapple, reserving the juices

Slice the Bananas

Coat them in the reserved pineapple juices (to prevent discoloration)

Layer the bananas in the pie crust

Using your hands press the chocolate ice cream over the bananas
(it gets pretty cold, so we had to take a quick break and run our hand under hot water :)

We used chocolate first because we're masochistic and decided we absolutely HAD to have the middle flavor first. I guess.

Sprinkle the chocolate chips on top of the ice cream
We saved some to sprinkle on top.

If you need to, you can put it in the freezer in between layering to set.

Using the same method you used for the chocolate, layer the vanilla ice cream on top of the chocolate chips.

Layer the pineapple on top of the vanilla ice cream.

Same method for the strawberry ice cream.

Put in the freezer for about an hour or so to set, or until your almost ready to serve it.

Take out the pie and, if your freezer's really cold, you will probably want to let it sit out for ten or twenty minutes to soften so you can cut it.

While it's sitting (either, in the freezer or on the counter), husk and slice the strawberries and layer them on top of the ice cream (I suppose if you want your strawberries frozen you can put them on before you stick the pie in the freezer)

Whip up the cream with 1 tsp vanilla and 1 tbsp sugar (or use ready to use whipping cream) and put it on top of the strawberries.

Now for the really fun part.


You can pretty much put whatever you want on top. We put chopped nuts and the leftover chocolate chips, but you could put pretty much anything you can think of! (Of course the best are sundae toppings.)

Step 4: One Last Note

This is not a strict recipe. You can pretty much use anything you can think of.

For example:

Fudge sauce on top of the chocolate ice cream

Marshmallows (or marshmallow creme) on top of the vanilla

A different flavor ice cream in between layers

...you get the idea.

If there's something in the recipe that you don't really fancy, feel free to substitute it. It'll still taste delicious!

Be as creative as your imagination will let you and enjoy!

Participated in the
Pie Contest

Be the First to Share


    • Frozen Treats Speed Challenge

      Frozen Treats Speed Challenge
    • Backyard Contest

      Backyard Contest
    • Exercise Speed Challenge

      Exercise Speed Challenge

    3 Discussions


    9 years ago on Introduction

    Looks so wonderful and delicious!! MMmm.

    I'm making this as soon as I get the ice cream. :D
    I have everything else...

    Fate is so cruel. lol.