215Views25Replies

Author Options:

Do you think people are too quick to rate something 5*s? Answered

Hey there guys. We all know that getting to 5*s with a kne'x ible used to be quite hard, say a year and a half ago. Now, there are so many knex guns with 5*s its impossible to count!

How? I will list a few of the reasons.
1) 'Ye of little knexing experience' are simply voting 5* instantaneously if they think it is remotely good.
2) There are simply too many members doing the above!
3) Nobody really knows what not to rate high anymore :-/


The 'Knexperts' of ibles are producing top quality work, that is being treated frankly the same as something that is not so top notch!

Therefore, I propose that we formulate an instructable that would show people what we think work should be rated on. We need to get rid of ratings like 'Wow! First Derringer! 5*'  - Don't you think?!


Please also comment on things I need to add to the list!

Tags:Knex

Discussions

0
None
Oblivitus

8 years ago

Someone should take the images of some of the knex guns out now and rate all of them from .5-5 in.5 increments and explain why they gave them that rating.
For example, My AP4 could get 3.5 stars and my Z35 could get 5 stars followed by an explanation for each with lots of criteria for the various ratings.

0
None
mahmel

8 years ago

If a nice gun is rated >4.51, most people are rating 5* because then he will lower it.
I agree people rate 5* very very quick, but hey:

Aren't you happy if someone rate your ible 5*, right?;D
that's what I mean.

0
None
TheFoofinator

8 years ago

I am sick of it. Another niggle is the fact that when someone who is less well known posts something that is awsome, immediately gets compared to the pros, people rate things for what they aren't. Example: 'not as good as Kairah's, 2*.

0
None
DJ RadioTheFoofinator

Reply 8 years ago

There's a reason for that. A good gun must give people incentive to build it over what is already available right now.

0
None
bounty1012DJ Radio

Reply 8 years ago

Yea, but thats like comparing an SMG to a Sniper Rifle.

0
None
DJ Radiobounty1012

Reply 8 years ago

I mean guns of similar types. I'm not going to say that a generic mag fed knex gun is inferior to the SR-v2 and thus should not be built.

0
None
KnexFreak360

8 years ago

I agree my stakeout shotgun is already like 4.90 and i want it to be good and im glad its that high but I'm not sure it does deserve that high of a rating.

0
None
PindaHoofd

8 years ago

I TOTALLY AGREE! 5 stars.

0
None
Shadowman39

8 years ago

All Instructables were bumped up a star, which is also why there are lots of them with a perfect 5* rating. There should be 6 stars, so if something was at 4.14 before it would be 5.14, and not 5. No Ibles would reach 6, just like none used to be able to reach 5.

0
None
Shadowman39Hiyadudez

Reply 8 years ago

Yes, but the reason they raised them up was so it compared better with other places on the internet.

0
None
bounty1012

8 years ago

People should rate honestly based on quality, originality, and if it applies, whether its lifelike or not. However, we should rate something because its: the first, you cannot follow the instructions and make it, or if it shoots far. I think we could use a new rating system, something similar to fpsbanana.com's rating system. Like if you rate something then you have to leave a comment why you left the rating you did, and split the rating into different categories.

0
None
bounty1012bounty1012

Reply 8 years ago

and yes I know I'm one of those people who rate 5* just for something being the first, I've changed the way that I rate things now.

0
None
Oblivitusbounty1012

Reply 8 years ago

This is off topic, but the guy in your avatar makes everything you say seem crazy.

0
None
bounty1012Oblivitus

Reply 8 years ago

Yea its a random GIF I found when I was trolling those anonymous cam sites.

0
None
bounty1012Oblivitus

Reply 8 years ago

Yea my friends laughed real hard when I started video chatting with them on skype using it xD.

0
None
shadowninja31

8 years ago

Yes and no. Yes, because Ibles changed the rating by adding a star to each ruining the ratings we had.
No, because people rate things on how they like them and that's the way it should be right? I mean, I shouldn't rate something bad because someone else doesn't like it. However they should spend more time on choosing.

0
None
cj81499

8 years ago

I totally agree. I used to rate EVERYTHING 5 stars even though it isn't the "Best Ever". I have changed my ways over time and while I still rate higher than most who rate properly I rate much more appropriately.

0
None
DJ RadioFred the Penguin

Reply 8 years ago

That's different. This is talking about people who go ZOMG 5*!!!!1111 on mediocre knex guns.

0
None
TheDunkis

8 years ago

It has always been this way. Yeah it's annoying but people don't really care. They rate either .5 or 5 whether they don't like it or they do like it. They don't actually "rate" it per se. And you receive a major backlash if you rate something 3.5 even though that's a good, 7/10 just because it's not a 5 even if it isn't perfect. I'd say only a handful of K'nex creations, even fewer of them being guns deserve a 5 star. The majority, including most of mine, deserve a 3-4 at max looking from a purely K'nexer standpoint. Looking from a non k'nexer, they're worth even less to them.