90Views18Replies

Author Options:

Grammatically incorrect! Answered

Hello Instructable community/team-

I recently recieved a email message saying that a user has subscribed to me...

"Congratulations!

Member (xxxx) has subscribed to you! Visit their member page here: (link)"

With the key word being their. It should be his/her.

Discussions

0
None
Kiteman

9 years ago

The non-gender-specific usage of their is correct in this instance.

With the number of grammar-Nazis that frequent this site, the administrators hardly dare be anything other than sticklers for accuracy ;-)

0
None
PadlockKiteman

Reply 9 years ago

You are correct in the fact that their is not gender specific. It also refers to more than one person, or which there is only one. That means the correct expression would be he/she

0
None
PadlockPadlock

Reply 9 years ago

strike that, justhis/her in this case.

0
None
KitemanPadlock

Reply 9 years ago

Sorry, "their" is correct. Check with your English teacher if you want.

0
None
Labot2001Kiteman

Reply 9 years ago

Check with your English teacher if you want.

Or with your American teacher, to be politically correct!

0
None
KitemanLabot2001

Reply 9 years ago

Or, your teacher of American English, to be pedantically correct.

0
None
fwjs28Kiteman

Reply 9 years ago

or your language arts teacher

0
None
PadlockKiteman

Reply 9 years ago

I have... She's the one who brought up the entire issue (at school) of using their and her/his. Which is why I spotted it.

0
None
KitemanPadlock

Reply 9 years ago

Please tell your teacher of English that a teacher who is English says that she has made a mistake - the use of the "his/her" duality is made when offering a choice wherein the gender of the subject is, ultimately, contextually significant and known.

Generally, "his/her" is used when filling in forms, but "their" is used when speaking about an individual whose gender is unknown.

0
None
PadlockKiteman

Reply 9 years ago

I disagree. Regardless of "filling in forms" or speech, one should always follow the general rule of agreement in number AND gender. Besides, if nothing else, following correct grammar.

0
None
KitemanPadlock

Reply 9 years ago

"Their" is usually considered plural neuter, but can also be used as singular neuter. That's correct grammar.

If your teacher of English isn't aware of that, ask them* why.

*Oh, look, a normally-plural pronoun beimg used in the singular!

0
None
Chicken2209Padlock

Reply 9 years ago

forget no child left behind we need something for these teachers :0 ! their can be singular and plural

0
None
gmjhoweKiteman

Reply 9 years ago

Indeed, Kiteman is correct.

0
None
Goodhart

9 years ago

*chuckle* which side of the fence has the greener hay, again?